The Pennsylvania Supreme Court dismissed a lawsuit Tuesday morning that attempted to create a citywide registry of rental units in Pittsburgh, saying that the case was “moot” because Pittsburgh City Council had passed new legislation last year.

The new legislation, passed last September, created a separate registry that included short- and long-term rental units. It requires rental property owners to obtain a permit from the city, contingent on an inspection of of the unit.

Dating back to 2009, city officials have attempted to hold irresponsible landlords accountable, only to be met with lawsuits over the rental registry requirements. In 2021, City Council passed a bill that would have required yearly rental inspections and for landlords to disclose proof of ownership.

Shortly after the passage of that legislation, multiple landlord groups including the Landlord Service Bureau and Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh, sued the city on the grounds that the required permitting fee would constitute an “illegal revenue-generating tax.”

Advertise with us

In May 2023, Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court Senior Judge Mary Hannah Leavitt struck down the legislation, saying it placed excessive burdens on landlords.

While this was playing out in court, a similar piece of legislation was making its way through City Council, in the wake of a fatal Easter 2022 shooting at an Airbnb on the North Side.

Councilman Bobby Wilson, who represents the area, introduced legislation that would require all owners of short-term rentals register with the city, so that if the building was owned by an out-of-state LLC, police knew who to contact if needed.

After a year-and-a-half of debate over the short-term rental regulations, City Council members combined the two efforts into the legislation that was passed last September, which rendered the former lawsuit as moot. It’s currently unclear when this will be enacted and property owners will have to start the permitting process.

At a hearing in April, Justice Kevin Brobson and lawyers for the Landlord Service Bureau and Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh all said that the court should throw the case out as moot.

Advertise with us

Representatives from the landlord groups could not immediately be reached for comment on Tuesday.

During that hearing, lawyers for the city indicated that if the Supreme Court upheld the legislation, they would reenact the 2021 rental registry ordinance.

Supreme Court Justice David Wecht wrote a dissenting opinion in which he said he agreed the case “technically is moot, but I believe nonetheless that we should review this case” under what’s called the public-importance exception.

This exception would allow a court to make a decision on a case that is no longer relevant, if the subject is likely to come up again in the future.

“The degree to which local municipalities may regulate their rental markets is an issue of great importance to the public,” Justice Wecht wrote.

Advertise with us

He continued to say that if this issue doesn’t arise again in the future, it would be because the decision made by the Commonwealth Court had “erected such a formidable barrier” to similar legislation that legal advisers told local lawmakers not to bother with the effort.

Justice Wecht also wrote that the court should consider reviewing the case to provide municipalities with “greater clarity, especially with respect to a topic as critical to health and safety as the regulation of residential housing.”

Mayor Ed Gainey’s office declined to comment.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com