Pittsburgh City Council is poised to approve spending that will create a city-sponsored Juneteenth celebration, despite criticism from organizers of the longstanding Juneteenth events in the city.

A final vote on the spending is scheduled for Wednesday morning.

The holiday, which was made a federal holiday last year and a state holiday in 2019, commemorates the end of slavery and has often been referred to as the Black Independence Day.

In a nearly three-hour meeting Wednesday, city council members discussed the Gainey administration’s proposal to give $125,000 of federal pandemic relief money to Bounce Marketing and Events, which has done events in Pittsburgh and nationally.

Advertise with us

William “B” Marshall, who has organized the Juneteenth festival every year since 2014, said that money was promised to him.

Last year, when the city decided to support the Juneteenth celebration with pandemic funds, it did so as a pass-through to the POISE Foundation, which then distributed the money to Mr. Marshall. City council authorized spending $250,000 over two years.

However, the contract that was actually executed was only for one year and $125,000.

This year, the city put out a request for proposals for companies to bid on the opportunity to help organize the city’s Juneteenth celebration,  said Jake Pawlak, director of the Office of Management and Budget. Mr. Pawlak told council last week that the administration received some criticism last year when the money was awarded to the POISE Foundation without considering other community groups.

“The intent was to open the process up to anyone who sought to submit a proposal,” Mr. Pawlak said, noting one of the proposals received was from the POISE Foundation.

Advertise with us

As a result of the competitive bid process, the city chose to go with Bounce Marketing.

But that left Mr. Marshall feeling the city had reneged on last year’s promise of funding.

“When we voted to approve this money, I was under the full impression this was going to POISE,” Councilman Anthony Coghill said. “For us to step out on our own, to me, is disingenuous. I feel like we’re not holding up to our word.”

Mr. Pawlak said that Mr. Coghill’s “impression of the situation” was the case at the time, and POISE did receive the money for 2023, but he added that “It was nearly a year ago that the decision to pursue an open bid process for this year was made and discussed with the parties.”

That open bid process produced three proposals, and “the proposal from Bounce marketing was the strongest,” Patrick Cornell, the city’s chief financial officer said last week. “It was very thorough; it was well-presented and met all the requirements as we saw it.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Cornell and three others sat on a panel that reviewed the proposals: one from Bounce Marketing, one from the POISE Foundation and another from Rainbow Serpent, a Pittsburgh-based arts nonprofit.

The full bid proposals are not made public until a contract is signed. POISE did not respond to requests for comment.

But there was frustration from some council members about the process and regarding the fact that there would be two, potentially competing Juneteenth celebrations.

Mr. Marshall’s Juneteenth event is currently scheduled for June 14 to 16. There is not an exact date yet for the city’s event, though officials anticipate it to be later in the month of June. The official Juneteenth holiday is June 19.

Mr. Coghill said he felt like the city had “broken our word to B Marshall.” He was the lone vote in opposition to the funding on Wednesday’s preliminary vote.

Advertise with us

Councilwoman Deb Gross also questioned the motives behind the administration's decision to host a second Juneteenth event.

“What I don’t understand here is why we have something that is a private event, that has really been successful, that we’re trying to duplicate and compete with,” she said Wednesday. She pointed out that the city doesn’t try to do its own St. Patrick’s Day Parade or Little Italy Days, both of which are private events.

Mr. Pawlak and the mayor’s Chief of Staff Jake Wheatley pushed back against that idea, saying the goal isn’t to compete with Mr. Marshall’s event, but to bring more awareness to the holiday by bolstering the celebration in the same way that there are multiple Fourth of July celebrations across the city.

“It was a priority of the mayor’s… to create parity or equity between the celebration of the Fourth of July and the celebration of Juneteenth,” Mr. Pawlak said.

The city does provide monetary support to the Fourth of July celebration. Mr. Pawlak said that both events this year are getting $125,000 of city funds.

Advertise with us

Council President Dan Lavelle explained to members that not approving the funds for Bounce Marketing didn’t mean Mr. Marshall automatically got them.

“If members vote this down, understand you are not supporting B Marshall’s production,” he said last week. “I don’t think there’s a scenario in the world where council members would say we shouldn’t have more than one Fourth of July… but now we’re going to question having two Black festivals. To me, that’s bothersome.”

Mr. Coghill and Ms. Gross suggested the city look for ways to find resources to contribute to Mr. Marshall’s events. Mr. Wheatley said the administration would “engage in that conversation.”

This year is not the first time Mr. Marshall’s event has hit trouble with the city. There were concerns that last year’s event wouldn’t happen because of issues with permitting with the city and the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, which manages Point State Park – namely regarding security.

Ultimately the event was held and brought about 50,000 attendees to the festival, according to Mr. Marshall.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com