Pittsburgh City Council members on Wednesday deleted an improper payment to a former employee who was recently arrested on charges of ethnic intimidation. The payments, which were done via PayPal, violated city code.

Because the payment system works like a credit card, the individual has already received the money. The council’s action delays the city from paying the bank while council members look into the city’s purchase card — or “p-card” —program.

“This was missed by every level of government,” Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith said Wednesday morning. “I really would like to get to the bottom of this and make sure this is not the tip of the iceberg but the end of a problem.”

Pending before council was a $1,200 payment for services that Mario Ashkar, 36, performed for the city in April, prior to an arrest last week allegedly in relation to antisemitic acts on the North Side that included pulling down an Israeli flag from outside a home..

Advertise with us

City Controller Rachael Heisler raised concerns to council members and urged them to pause the payment “indefinitely” while a larger investigation continued, saying the purchase card program was not the proper channel to pay Ashkar because the work constituted professional services, which city policy prohibits being paid for by p-card.

It’s unclear if the deleted item will be reintroduced as a departmental invoice, which multiple city officials said would have been the proper payment method.

The Office of Management and Budget is reviewing p-card policies and those involved in this violation are facing disciplinary actions, Maria Montano, the mayor’s communications director said Tuesday.

In the meantime, Ms. Heisler recommended that any payments via PayPal stop while further review continues.

Councilwoman Erika Strassburger said during Wednesday’s meeting that she wants to create a subgroup of council — with the budget director — to meet with the mayor’s office and the controller’s office to discuss what each is doing in terms of internal checks and what policy changes can be made to prevent this from happening in the future.

Advertise with us

Councilman Bob Charland said he was uncomfortable with the current p-card policies and would not be voting to approve any p-card payments until changes are made.

“We don't know who else is on this list [who] may be also abusing the system,” he said Wednesday. “Until we identify robust safeguards in this process, I will not be voting for p-cards.”

Ms. Kail-Smith and Mr. Charland voted against the other p-card payment approvals at Wednesday’s meeting.

Ms. Heisler originally suggested the payments could potentially violate the state Ethics Act. Ms. Montano responded Tuesday by saying in a news conference that after reviewing the situation, the city solicitor did not believe that was the case.

Ms. Heisler said the State Ethics Commission should have the opportunity to review the matter.

Advertise with us

The city of Pittsburgh has its own Ethics Hearing Board made up of nine members appointed by the mayor and approved by city council.

Under previous administrations, the ethics board was housed with the law department and was semi-independent. Since Mayor Ed Gainey has taken office, the ethics board has been moved into the mayor’s office and reports directly to him.

The mayor’s office declined to respond to questions as to why the ethics board wasn’t consulted on this matter and why it has been moved under the mayor’s direct control.

Ashkar had been getting paid by the city through p-cards monthly since July 2023, to the tune of $18,460. Ashkar had worked as a city employee from June 2022 until November 2022, and then had been hired to perform “coordination services” for the farmers market.

The Department of Parks and Recreation, for which Askhar was working, will often pay for services like balloon artists or face painters for events through the p-card. That doesn’t violate the city policy because those individuals are considered vendors, Jake Pawlak, the director of the office of management and budget, told council Wednesday morning.

Advertise with us

Mr. Pawlak said that Ashkar’s main role was working with sellers and customers at the farmers markets to “improve the experience,” and handling the coordination of “some of the ancillary services.”

City-run farmers markets generally operate between May and November, although one winter market a month was hosted between January and April of this year at senior centers across the city.

There are still a number of outstanding questions that the controller is awaiting answers on from the administration, she told council Wednesday morning.

Her request includes employment records for Ashkar, time-stamped documents detailing when Ashkar was notified that their work would no longer be continued with the city and documentation detailing how it was determined that Ashkar would be paid via PayPal rather than a check.

Ms. Heisler has requested that this documentation be returned by 10 a.m. Friday.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com