Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey’s pick to lead the city’s Planning Department addressed possible conflict of interests and his goals for the city in an interview with City Council members Tuesday afternoon.
In the nearly 90-minute-long interview, Jamil Bey started off by addressing some of the concerns that had been raised regarding his appointment and the work he had been involved with.
Mr. Bey is the founder and CEO of an organization called the UrbanKind Institute. The group — which Mr. Bey, described as a “think and do tank” — does research, consulting and community engagement to help communities understand the problems they face and how to fix them.
As part of the company, Mr. Bey helped develop the Equitable and Just Greater Pittsburgh organization, which brings together other organizations across Western Pennsylvania to work with city officials to alert them to issues in neighborhoods and how they believed they should be solved.
“Some of you saw this as potentially undue influence in my role as planner,” Mr. Bey said to council Tuesday.
Because of that, the Equitable and Just Greater Pittsburgh group has been moved outside of the UrbanKind Institute and now has a different fiscal sponsor.
Mr. Bey also has stepped down from “any administrative and executive roles at the institute.” Part of that is because the organization has consulting contracts with Allegheny County, he said.
As the planning director, Mr. Bey will oversee the creation of a $6 million comprehensive plan that likely will guide city planning for decades. The plan was heavily criticized by council members, particularly the price tag, which included $2.5 million for community engagement.
Included in the community engagement portion of the plan is $71,000 to be paid to Alyssa Lyons, an environmental justice advocate.
Ms. Lyons is also the director of Black Environmental Collective at the UrbanKind Institute.
“Our consultants are free to pursue contracts that didn’t conflict with our work,” Mr. Bey said. “With my blessing, Alyssa pursued that contract with the team that was doing the engagement. That was long before I had any role or any consideration for the role of planner.”
He said it was after Ms. Lyons’ contract had been confirmed with the city that he was approached for the director position.
As a precaution, Mr. Bey consulted the city’s ethics adviser to offer an opinion on this issue and his involvement on the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority Board.
The ethics adviser wrote an opinion, which was shared with council members Tuesday, that said no conflict of interest was present in either situation.
“There's no financial gain to me, or anyone in my immediate family,” he said.
It was also decided that should any contracts from PWSA go through the Planning Department, the deputy director would handle them.
Mr. Bey also said he would abstain from any votes on the PWSA board that related to city planning.
“There would be limited risk of conflict of interest, because there’s very little direct business between the Department of City Planning and PWSA generally,” said Councilwoman Erika Strassburger, who also serves on the PWSA board.
Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith said she was glad Mr. Bey shared the letters from the ethics adviser with council, because even though she called him a “great ethical person,” she wouldn’t have voted for him without them.
Mr. Gainey nominated Mr. Bey to the position, which pays about $125,000, at the end of March. Per city code, the mayor does not have the authority to nominate someone to fill this position, rather it should be done by the planning commission. But mayors dating back at least as far as former Mayor Luke Ravenstahl have made similar appointments.
Councilman Anthony Coghill introduced legislation shortly after the nomination that would change the code so that the director of city planning was the head of the department. As it is written now, the commission oversees the department, although it’s unclear if this would give Mr. Gainey the authority to pick a candidate for the position. No action has been taken on the legislation yet.
Mr. Bey has been serving as the acting director of the department since April 8 when former director Karen Abrams left.
One of the main focuses he outlined, not only for the comprehensive plan but for the department overall, is helping to facilitate conversations that will allow the city to pinpoint what problems it’s trying to solve.
“How do we think about a city that people see themselves thriving in?” he said. “For me, that’s the challenge. That’s the driver. I want to be here and be part of establishing and driving that space.”
Being a facilitator was a key role that Mr. Bey focused on.
“I don’t see my role or planning’s role as being the leadership or the visionary of the region,” he said. “That should come from council … from the mayor’s office, that could come from the county executive. … My role is to facilitate that comprehensive conversation and make sure that folks are heard in the process.”
Mr. Bey also said that he was interested in helping create a more robust workforce development program to make young people in the city want to stay in Pittsburgh.
“I think you have all the skills you need for this job,” Councilwoman Deb Gross said.
Council likely will vote on Mr. Bey’s nomination next Tuesday.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.