Atop a piece of crusty bread, used as a cracker topping, or simply seared with salt and pepper — the delicacy of foie gras appeals to a slew of diners, but with a ban on the dish pending in Pittsburgh, it might soon be hard to find.

Foie gras, the fattened liver of a duck or goose, is known to be rich and buttery. Its distinction from other liver dishes comes from the fattening of the organ, which is done through a process of over-feeding the animal. In some instances, the fowl are force-fed through a plastic tube to achieve the enlargement of the liver, a practice that critics call unethical and cruel.

Pittsburgh City Council members Bruce Kraus and Erika Strassburger are among those critics, which is why they introduced legislation two weeks ago to ban the dish in city restaurants.

“The practice of force-feeding birds for foie gras production is widely considered by veterinary professionals to be inhumane,” the legislation said, adding that the process can also cause animals “significant injury and illness.”

Advertise with us

The ban received preliminary approval during a vote last week, and could be finalized as early as Monday afternoon. If approved, it would go into effect 11 days after Mayor Ed Gainey signs the legislation into law.

But that could just be the beginning of a long legal process.

Marcus Henley, the vice president of Hudson Valley Foie Gras, a New York-based duck farm, said that his company will sue the city if the ban is passed.

“We have clear legal arguments to challenge the legislation,” Mr. Henley said in an email. “We will definitely file suit against the City of Pittsburgh. Based on our track record and understanding of the law, we are confident of success.”

In 2019, New York City Council approved a similar ban that was supposed to go into effect in 2022, but was held up in legal challenges. Just last week, state courts in New York issued an order that prevented the implementation of the ban.

Advertise with us

“While the New York State decision is not directly applicable to out-of-state farmers and the City of Pittsburgh, the concepts are the same,” Mr. Henley said. “If Pittsburgh can ban the sale of a USDA-inspected agricultural product based on misinformation or special interests, a terrible precedent is established that has broad implications and applicability.”

Similarly, California enacted a law banning the in-state production and commercial sale of foie gras in 2004, but the law has seen a see-saw of legal battles since it went into effect in 2012. Currently, it’s legal to purchase from an out-of-state retailer.

Despite the numerous restaurants in Pittsburgh proper, foie gras is a rarity, with fewer than 10 restaurants in or near the city limits currently serving it. Some industry workers said that banning an ingredient that isn’t currently in high demand — and is often avoided by diners — felt unnecessary.

“Foie is easy to go at because it’s not a super popular ingredient here. It’s a low hanging fruit,” said Joey Hilty, chef and co-owner of The Vandal in Lawrenceville. “There are a lot of food items that could or should be banned if you’re looking at animal welfare.”

Local restaurant owners and chefs said they were surprised by the proposal and weren’t contacted to determine how a ban would affect their business.

Advertise with us

“This is the first I’m hearing about it,” said Chris Frangiadis, executive chef and partner of Spork in Bloomfield.

Mr. Hilty and Mr. Frangiadis currently have foie gras on their menus. They said they work with suppliers who hold themselves to high ethical standards, such as allowing the geese to roam free rather than living in a contained environment.

In an email to council members, which included Ms. Strassburger and Mr. Kraus’ chief of staff Bob Charland, Mr. Henley invited the members to come visit the farm “any day, unannounced” and offered to travel to Pittsburgh to “discuss our farming practices” with council.

Hudson Valley Foie Gras replicates the “natural forgoing process of migratory waterfowl,” according to its website, and they use a “special hand-feeding process” rather than the tube force-feeding. Each of their ducks is “individually evaluated by a US Department of Agriculture Inspector under strict guidelines for wholesomeness.”

Nevertheless, the chefs say they see the complexity in the debate about raising and selling foie gras.

Advertise with us

“It’s pretty delicious and adds a luxurious touch to a meal. But I also understand the other side of it,” Mr. Frangiadis said.

Humane Action Pittsburgh, a local nonprofit focused on animal rights, called the legislation “groundbreaking.” The legislation — along with two other bills that seek to ban the sale and manufacturing of furs and the use of horse-drawn carriages — help protect animals while advancing “larger environmental, health, and public safety aims,” the group said.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com; Hal B. Klein contributed.