Allegheny County’s government ethics watchdog has said Councilwoman Bethany Hallam should be formally admonished for her attempt to broker a secret deal that would have returned a political ally to the powerful local sewer board in exchange for a political favor.
The Accountability, Conduct and Ethics Commission investigated allegations that Ms. Hallam had reached out to state Rep. Emily Kinkead last year and said that if Ms. Kinkead resigned her seat on the Alcosan board, creating an opening for County Treasurer John Weinstein to return to a position from which he had just been removed, Mr. Weinstein would stop supporting Ms. Kinkead’s opponent in that year’s Democratic primary.
The secret offer, which immediately raised legal and ethical questions, was first reported by The Post-Gazette in March. Ms. Kinkead, D-North Side, rejected the idea, won re-election and is still on Alcosan’s board.
Mr. Weinstein denied the allegations earlier this year, while Ms. Hallam didn’t respond to requests to comment on them at the time.
The ethics commission’s findings were disclosed late Thursday by County Councilman Tom Duerr, who had requested in March that the five-member panel investigate the matter.
“To say that these findings are disturbing would be putting it mildly,” Mr. Duerr wrote in a two-page letter posted on social media. “For someone to use their position as an At-Large Councilmember in this way flies in the face of every promise they made when they took their oath of office. Allegheny County deserves so much better than this. Through Councilwoman Hallam’s actions, she has broken the trust residents of this County placed in her, now twice, when they elected her as an At-Large Member of this body — and by doing so also damaged the trust the public has in this legislative body as a whole. Only time will tell if that trust can be restored.”
Ms. Hallam, a progressive Democrat who won re-election in November, declined to comment Friday. “I am not a crook!” she said in a brief text message to WESA.
The commission investigates ethics complaints about county workers and officials, and can recommend disciplinary action to Council. The county ethics code “protects whistleblowers and maintains confidentiality in its proceedings until and unless a final order is issued,” a county website says.
According to Mr. Duerr’s account of the ethics commission’s report, the panel concluded last month that Ms. Hallam violated provisions in the county Ethics Code covering prohibitions on certain political activity, dealing with honor and integrity, and requiring officials to “serve the best interests of the public at all times.”
In an ethics commission report obtained by WESA, the panel said it found Ms. Hallam’s “adamant denial” of the allegations to be “less credible than that of other individuals” who said Ms. Hallam spoke to them about the offer.
The Post-Gazette reported in March that County Executive Rich Fitzgerald had decided not to reappoint Mr. Weinstein to the sewer authority after the FBI approached Alcosan about Mr. Weinstein’s activities as a board member there. A member of the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Pittsburgh also expressed concerns about Mr. Weinstein’s work at Alcosan to county and city leaders, The Post-Gazette reported. The three-member Alcosan board makes contract recommendations — an influential role as the authority pursues a $2 billion-plus Clean Water Plan to control sewage overflows.
Mr. Weinstein was not charged with any wrongdoing or publicly identified as the subject of any investigation. In March, he dismissed reporting on the effort to return him to the board as “rumors, outright falsehoods and innuendos being slung by competitors.” The longtime treasurer is leaving office in January after he lost the May Democratic primary to succeed the term-limited Mr. Fitzgerald as county executive.
The ethics commission’s recommendation that Ms. Hallam be “admonished” in a letter from her County Council colleagues would amount to a formal censure if lawmakers do so, without any further consequences.
Mr. Duerr, while praising the commission’s investigation, said in his letter that the recommendation for an admonishment “falls far short of the remedy required to ensure this never happens again.”
“While I will be leaving Council at the end of the month, I will certainly be having conversations with my current and future colleagues about the best course of action [to] take given these findings,” Mr. Duerr wrote. “It [is] my hope that [Council President Pat Catena] and the majority of the members of this body will, like myself, grasp the severity of these transgressions and act accordingly, but if they do not, then it will fall upon the residents of Allegheny County to hold Councilwoman Hallam responsible for this egregious misuse of power and ethical dereliction of duty.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.