Sara Innamorato was elected Tuesday as the first woman to lead Allegheny County government, a historic moment that came after she ran on a progressive platform that promised a “county for all.”
Ms. Innamorato, the Democratic nominee for county executive, defeated Republican Joe Rockey, according to unofficial county results. With 99.7% of the vote counted late Tuesday, Ms. Innamorato had won about 51%, compared to about 49% for Mr. Rockey. In January, she will succeed term-limited Democrat Rich Fitzgerald, who has held the county’s top elected office since 2012.
“I stand here tonight in awe of the trust that you've placed in me,” she told supporters Tuesday night as she held back tears while celebrating her victory in Millvale. “And I am confident that we can build an Allegheny County for us all.”
Joined by her mother on the stage at Mr. Smalls Theatre, Ms. Innamorato noted the historic nature of her win.
“I stand here as the first woman Allegheny County executive, and I stand here because of the passion, faith and support of people who are around me — a lot of them women.” she said. “The women elected before me, I stand on your shoulder. Your strength gave me the fortitude to share my own story.”
After the latest in a series of political victories for progressive Democrats in Western Pennsylvania in recent years, Ms. Innamorato, 37, will now oversee the more than $3 billion county budget and thousands of government employees.
Her “county for all” campaign included a focus on increasing affordable housing and improving mental health services. Many of her plans involve collaborating with experts, labor unions and business stakeholders in what she calls a “co-governing” model of leadership.
Often defining herself as a “people-centered politician,” Ms. Innamorato, a former state representative, ran a grassroots campaign that prioritized door-knocking over raising money from deep-pocketed donors.
Facing a stronger than expected challenge from Mr. Rockey, a former PNC executive who ran as a moderate, she often emphasized national issues such as abortion and protecting democracy from supporters of former President Donald Trump. She promised to enact shield laws to protect abortion providers from out-of-state investigations and criticized Mr. Rockey for not taking a public position on an issue that has galvanized Democratic voters since the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade last year.
Addressing supporters Tuesday night at the Wyndham Grand Hotel Downtown, Mr. Rockey, 59, called his campaign’s close finish “a pretty impressive outcome.”
“We had a different message… but I want to tell you that message isn’t lost,” he said. “What we sent out to do was to make Allegheny County prosperous again, to address the public safety issues that we have in a manner that didn’t burden the taxpayers with a greater burden than they already have. It’s still there to be done and I ask all of you in the middle to hold the county accountable to accomplish those goals.
“It is important that all of you stand and support the next administration,” he added.

Prior to taking the stage in Millvale, Ms. Innamorato said she had received a concession call from Mr. Rockey. She thanked him for running a “strong campaign” and “keeping us on our toes until the very end.”
“Regardless of who you voted for, I’m honored to represent you,” she said.
Ms. Innamorato was joined Tuesday night at Mr. Smalls Theatre by other progressive Democrats, including Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey, who also made history in 2021 when he was elected the city’s first Black mayor.
Ms. Innamorato is the “type of leader we need in Allegheny County,” Mr. Gainey said, because of her lived experience and relationships with other elected officials.
Her victory will leave the progressive wing of the Democratic Party in control of both city and county governments.
“She cares,” Mr. Gainey said. “She will help us take this region to the next level.”
When Ms. Innamorato first won a state House seat in 2018 against an establishment-backed incumbent from the politically prominent Costa family, it was part of the first wave of progressive wins in Western Pennsylvania. That momentum has only continued to grow with Mr. Gainey’s victory and Summer Lee’s election to a U.S. House seat last year.
Ms. Innamorato resigned from the state House over the summer to focus on her campaign for county executive, after defeating multiple candidates with more party establishment backing in a crowded May primary. Another progressive, Democrat Lindsay Powell, won the Lawrenceville-based House seat in a September special election.
After Ms. Innamorato won 38% of the vote in a six-way Democratic primary for executive, supporters assumed she would cruise in the general election, given Democrats’ two-to-one voter registration advantage in Allegheny County.
But Mr. Rockey outraised and outspent Ms. Innamorato in the months before Election Day, doggedly campaigning as a centrist and painting his opponent as too liberal for Allegheny County. Political observers said he was putting up a decent fight and that the race would be close.
They were right.
No Republican ever came so close to defeating Mr. Fitzgerald. He won 62% of the vote in his first election for county executive in 2011. In 2019, he won a third term with 68% of the vote.
Mr. Rockey’s ability to mount a stronger challenge against a well-supported progressive Democrat could have implications for local Republicans running in future elections.
It was uncertain until the very end whether Ms. Innamorato’s history-making moment would come. An internal poll last month — paid for by a pro-Rockey group — showed Ms. Innamorato leading by a statistically insignificant one point. The only public survey of the race, released last week, showed her up by just three.
In the last weeks of the race, leading Democrats including Gov. Josh Shapiro and Sen. Bob Casey increasingly campaigned for her as the reality of a closer than expected race took hold.
And Ms. Innamorato increasingly focused her campaign on abortion — an issue that has galvanized Democratic voters since the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade last year and resonated with supporters who came to the polls for her on Tuesday.
Karon Hammond, 59, said abortion rights were top of mind for her after she voted for Ms. Innamorato Tuesday morning at Mindful Grandview in Mt. Washington. Asked about criticism that Ms. Innamorato had been more focused on social issues than kitchen-table local government issues, Ms. Hammond said, “Well, I’m very socially driven.”
“Especially being a woman,” she said, “it sadly plays into everything now.”
Ms. Innamorato’s staunchly progressive policies threatened to alienate more moderate voters amid significant concerns about crime and public safety. And at least in some cases, that appeared to happen.
Lynn Kramer, a 71-year-old retired nurse from Overbrook, said crime was one of the main reasons she cast her ballot for Mr. Rockey. Ms. Kramer said she hopes to see the creation of another juvenile detention center like the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center — which was shuttered in 2021 — as well as programs to counsel and rehabilitate youth offenders.
“Sara [Innamorato] just wants counseling. She doesn’t want any detention centers,” Ms. Kramer said. “One of my friend’s sons went to Shuman and he was so horrified by it he was good after that.”
But it wasn’t enough to push Mr. Rockey over the edge.
Both candidates accused each other throughout the election of being “extreme.”
Mr. Rockey’s campaign criticized Ms. Innamorato for her former membership in the Democratic Socialists of America. She distanced herself from the far-left group after its Pittsburgh chapter joined other DSA groups in doing little to condemn Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack against Israel. Facing criticism, she said publicly for the first time last month that she hadn’t been a member of the group since 2019.
And Ms. Innamorato’s campaign often tied Mr. Rockey to Mr. Trump and extremists in his party.
Looking ahead to competitive elections next year for president and U.S. Senate that will likely include another existential political fight against Mr. Trump, Ms. Innamorato told supporters to have fun celebrating their victory.
“It’s not long until 2024,” she said. “And we’ve got a lot of work to do.”
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com. Staff writers Megan Tomasic, Evan Robinson-Johnson, and Jacob Geanous contributed to this report.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.