There were cookies for poll workers in Point Breeze, an education in civics for two Pittsburgh children, and plenty of party loyalists and party switchers.

The hard-fought local races in Allegheny County were possible harbingers of what to expect a year from now in Pennsylvania, the most populous swing state in the nation, where races for president and U.S. senator, not county executive and district attorney, will lead the ballot.

On Tuesday, though, voters were choosing a successor to term-limited Democratic County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, as Democrat Sara Innamorato faced Republican Joe Rockey.

They also were deciding whether to return District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. to office — albeit as the Republican nominee this time — after he lost the Democratic primary to Matt Dugan but won the GOP nomination as a write-in candidate.

Advertise with us

The county reported no major issues with voting, the vast majority of mail ballots were counted before polls closed at 8 p.m., and polling places were adequately staffed with election judges.

"Without people working the polls, it makes elections difficult,” said one of them, Trish Hooper, at the Ohio Township Nature Center. “It's two days out of the year, but it's an important two days."

When voters went to the polls, national — and even international — issues sometimes figured into their decisions of which local candidates to support.

People congregate at a polling location in Sterrett 6-8 school near the end of election day on Tuesday, Nov. 7, 2023, in Point Breeze.span> (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Democrat Khari Mosley, running unopposed for Pittsburgh City Council, spent part of his morning bringing chocolate chip cookies and other snacks to election workers at the Sterrett Classical Academy in Point Breeze. Mr. Mosley got out of the back of a black Cadillac Escalade limousine to make the delivery.

David Charles, 67, a lifelong Hill District resident, said he’s voted in every election since he was 18 — and never looked at the candidates' names all that time.

Advertise with us

“I vote straight Democrat every year,” the retired engineer said as he cast his ballot at the Grace Memorial Presbyterian Church. While indicating he has lost a lot of faith in politics and doesn’t pay much attention anymore, Mr. Charles said that for him, any Democratic candidate always will be better for Allegheny County than any Republican.

Not so to Dan Peden, 69, a retired paramedic, who said he wasn’t enamored with either candidate for county executive — but sided with Mr. Rockey in the end.

“I’ve never voted for a Republican in my life and I’m not going to do it again, but I did it for him,” Mr. Peden said of the former PNC executive who campaigned as a moderate. “He understands the way the city works.”

Some voters cited abortion, the Hamas-Israel war, or former President Donald Trump as their top concerns when they went to polling places.

Poll workers and lawn signs stand in front of McCormick elementary school in Moon Township on Tuesday, November 7, 2023.span> (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Republican opposition to abortion access and the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision overturning Roe v. Wade energized Democratic voters in 2022, dissipating an expected GOP wave.

Advertise with us

Karon Hammond, 59, and her husband, David, 45, a director for the Pittsburgh Ballet Theatre, voted at Grandview Lofts in Mount Washington for Ms. Innamorato, who campaigned on protecting abortion access.

“Especially being a woman,” she said, “it sadly plays into everything now.”

At North Hills Middle School in Ross, April Brouwer said she has counseled friends against abortion, which she opposes as a Catholic. But she also said she wants women to have access to medically safe abortions.

“I served in the Peace Corps in Africa, where I watched women drink clothing detergent to get rid of unwanted pregnancies,” Ms. Brouwer said, as her two children ran around the school parking lot wearing “I voted” stickers.

Ms. Brouwer said she brought along her daughter, Zetta Francine, 9, “to “see all of the women on the ballot,” and both Zetta and her son, Jude Hendrik, 7, “to know about voting.”

Advertise with us
April Brouwer and her children, Zetta Francine, 9, and Jude Hendrik, 7, at the North Hills Middle School in Ross on Election Day. span> (Courtesy of April Brouwer)

Abortion also was an important issue to Matt Shelley, 43, in McCandless, but for a different reason.

“We’ve adopted two kids,” he said. “We believe in adoption over abortion.”

The war between Hamas, designated a terrorist group by the U.S., and Israel drew plenty of attention even in local elections.

At the Environmental Charter School at Frick Park in Regent Square, Erik Lux, 56, a Democrat, said he crossed party lines to support Mr. Rockey.

“I’m a big supporter of Israel and I don’t think Sara Innamorato is,” said Mr. Lux, who lives in Regent Square and works in financial aid at Pitt.

Advertise with us

Chezky Rosenfeld, a 36-year-old rabbi from Squirrel Hill, said he voted a straight Democratic ticket at the Jewish Community Center — except for Allegheny County Council at-large incumbent Bethany Hallam, a Democrat who ran unopposed. He said he backed a last-minute write-in candidate, David Knoll of Squirrel Hill, because he was troubled by her “disturbing” anti-Israel postings on X, formerly Twitter, following the attack by Hamas.

“It’s all very much on the top of all of our minds,” he said. “She’s had plenty of time to retract it.”

Mr. Trump, the front-runner for the 2024 GOP presidential nomination,  weighed heavily in the minds of Kristy Love, 39, and daughter Sarah, 20, both of the North Hills, who said their votes were motivated by opposition to the former and perhaps future president.

“I like to vote to be able to change the community and to have an effect,” Sara Love said.

Mike McKinley, a retired math teacher, said at the First Baptist Church in Oakland that he voted straight Democratic because of the Republican Party's relationship with Mr. Trump.

Advertise with us

“Even if there is a moderate Republican, they’re still associated with the people on the fringe,” he said.

Others felt differently.

Anthony Antario, 68, of Point Breeze, said he backed Mr. Rockey over Ms. Innamorato for Allegheny County executive, branding the Democratic nominee as “too liberal for me” and “not my cup of tea.”

Mr. Rockey and Mr. Zappala highlighted crime as a major issue — and a “Support Our Police. Vote Republican” sign stood outside the polling place at the Brookline Recreation Center. Polling before Election Day showed crime and public safety to be the top issue for Allegheny County voters.

“It seems to be getting worse in the city and we want the city to be safer, especially for our kids,” said Rockey supporter Sandra Moffatt, 61, of Brookline, a stay-at-home mother of three. “I have one [child] with special needs who would talk to anyone, go with anyone. I would like to see her safer in our neighborhood.”

Advertise with us

Lynn Kramer, 71, a retired nurse from Overbrook, also named crime as a main reason for backing Mr. Rockey. Ms. Kramer said she wanted a new juvenile detention center like the Shuman facility that was closed in 2021, as well as programs to counsel and rehabilitate youthful offenders.

“Sara [Innamorato] just wants counseling. She doesn’t want any detention centers,” Ms. Kramer said. “One of my friend’s sons went to Shuman and he was so horrified by it he was good after that.”

For Rob Kania, who has worked as a consultant Downtown since the 1990s, one issue was tops on his mind: public safety.

“I saw the resurgence of Market Square,” he said. “And I’ve been here for the decline. It’s frightening. It’s sad.”

Mr. Kania, 51, of Upper St. Clair, brought along his 18-year-old daughter, Julia, to cast her first-ever ballot. Both voted for Mr. Rockey and Mr. Zappala, the GOP candidates.

Advertise with us

“He didn’t tell me what to do,” Ms. Kania said with a grin. “I just happened to agree with him.”

Mr. Zappala’s 25 years of experience as DA were important to Dayle Logan, 63, a retired Pittsburgh native. She said Mr. Dugan was a step too far for the city she grew up in.

“Cities need change, but he’s too much,” she said.

The wife of a police officer, Ms. Logan said she worried that Mr. Dugan, the county’s progressive former chief public defender, would be too lenient with criminals.  She was also struck by a sign that one of Mr. Dugan’s aides in the public defender’s office had in an office that said, “F— the Police.”

“It left me with my mouth open,” she said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Zappala’s campaign featured the sign in a TV ad. Mr. Dugan said he had the sign removed as soon as he learned of it.

But Mr. Zappala’s record turned out to be a liability for other voters.

Some casting ballots at the Grace Memorial Presbyterian Church said they were irritated by how Mr. Zappala handled the case of Jim Rogers, a 54-year-old homeless man who died in 2021 after being taken into custody by Pittsburgh police.

Mr. Rogers allegedly was shocked by a Taser between eight and 10 times — even though he was unarmed and presented no physical threat. No criminal charges have been filed, even after Mr. Zappala said a year ago  that he hoped “to have something soon” to share about a grand jury investigation into Mr. Rogers’ death

“Zappala won’t release the bodycam footage from that night, and that’s why I don’t like him,” said Parris White, a resident of South Oakland for more than 50 years and a retired window service provider. “Sometimes you get angry, but you don’t Tase a person five or 10 times.”

Advertise with us

Matthew Goodnight, who is self-employed, said Mr. Zappala mistreated the Black community during his tenure as DA. “He should’ve been out of office a long time ago,” said Mr. Goodnight, a Hill District resident.

And David Auth, of Oakland, said at the First Baptist Church that he wanted a change.

“Zappala’s been making all these statements about how Matt Dugan’s going to ruin the city,” said Mr. Auth, a University of Pittsburgh law student and Carnegie Mellon University graduate student. “But he’s the one that’s been in power for all these years, and hasn’t done anything.”

Maddie Aiken, Joshua Axelrod, Steve Bohnel, Laura Esposito, Jacob Geanous, Kris Mamula, Neena Hagen, Evan Robinson-Johnson, and Mary Ann Thomas contributed to this report.

Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant