WASHINGTON — More than three dozen Jewish clergy members from the Pittsburgh area are calling on U.S. Rep Summer Lee to more strongly denounce Hamas and support Israel in its war with the terrorist group that rules Gaza.

The 40 rabbis and cantors said in an open letter Tuesday that Ms. Lee, D-Swissvale, has made troubling statements in the wake of Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack against Israel, which left more than 1,400 dead and 200 held hostage. Their letter came less than a week after the freshman congresswoman joined a handful of other Democrats in voting against a resolution expressing support for Israel and condemning Hamas. She and other progressives also supported a recent ceasefire resolution, with Ms. Lee noting that Israeli retaliatory airstrikes have already killed thousands of civilians and forced even more to leave their homes.

The clergy wrote to express “frustration and anger over the ongoing actions of our congresswoman,” describing the ceasefire resolution as “grotesque.” The push for a ceasefire “asserts a false equivalence between victims of savage terrorist butchery and the tragic deaths of those Palestinians whom Hamas uses as human shields while Israel exercises its responsibility to defend its citizens,” they wrote.

“We call on Rep. Lee to exercise better leadership and join her colleagues in upholding the moral obligation for Israel to protect its citizens against Hamas, reflecting our nation’s strong and unwavering stance against terrorism,” they wrote. “We welcome the opportunity to speak with Rep. Lee.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Lee’s office didn’t immediately comment Tuesday.

Temple Sinai Rabbi Daniel Fellman, who shared the letter on behalf of the group, said Ms. Lee “continues to deliver troubling statements instead of helping Israel with the horrific attack of October 7.” He said the letter represents “every stream of Judaism,” and that the group needs a representative who will recognize that “Israel was brutally attacked by Hamas terrorists.”

The clergy members’ letter came during a tense time for the Squirrel Hill community that Ms. Lee represents. Hundreds gathered in the neighborhood Sunday to raise awareness of the 200-plus Israeli civilians who have been kidnapped by Hamas, including dozens of children. And Friday marked five years since a gunman stormed a Squirrel Hill synagogue and killed 11 worshippers — the deadliest antisemitic attack in U.S. history. Two rabbis who signed the letter are survivors of the shooting, Rabbi Hazzan Jeffrey Myers and Rabbi Jonathan Perlman.

Ms. Lee issued a statement Tuesday in response to reports of antisemitic property damage at Frick Park, saying she condemned the “actions in the strongest possible terms.”

“The vandalism and antisemitic targeting of a Jewish community member’s property is unacceptable and wrong as we commemorate five years since the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting,” said Ms. Lee, who noted she spoke with community members and city officials. “I will continue doing everything in my power to fight back against hate and ensure our Jewish community feels safe and protected.”

Advertise with us

She said it was more important than ever to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with Jewish communities to combat white supremacy and antisemitism, and that “these disgusting views do not represent the views of Pittsburgh communities, and only damage any calls to peace.”

The freshman congresswoman, who won her seat after facing $4 million in advertising against her by the American Israel Public Affairs Committee’s super PAC, joined a small number of progressives who voted against a resolution backing Israel this summer. 

That resolution, which said the U.S. “will always be a staunch partner and supporter of Israel,” and that Israel is not a racist or apartheid state, passed 412-9. House Republicans brought the measure up for a vote after Rep. Pramila Jayapal, D-Wash., who chairs the Congressional Progressive Caucus, called Israel a racist state. Ms. Jayapal later apologized for her remarks and supported resolution.

Ms. Lee did publicly condemn “Hamas’ horrifying attack on children and innocent civilians” earlier this month. She later expressed concerns for civilians in Gaza, where Israel has launched deadly retaliatory strikes and aims to eradicate the militant group. Officials in the Hamas-run territory say the death toll there has surpassed 7,000.

“The violence that continues to escalate in Israel and Palestine is devastating to watch,” she said last Wednesday. “I once again strongly condemn the violence, terrorism and hostage-taking by Hamas that tore away the lives of over a thousand Israeli civilians. But we cannot allow innocent civilians in Gaza — including children — to continue to be collectively and inhumanely punished for Hamas’ horrific actions.”

Advertise with us

Bhavini Patel, an Edgewood Borough Council member and former community outreach manager for Allegheny County, announced earlier this month that she would challenge Ms. Lee in next year’s Democratic primary.

Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com; @BenKail