A new proposal outlining how much authority Allegheny County Council has over hiring and retaining the chief assessment officer has now been drafted by a few council members.

On Tuesday, the council introduced the measure, with its sponsors being Council President Patrick Catena and Council member Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis.

According to the legislation, the chief assessment officer would still be appointed by the county manager, as is current practice (with unanimous consent of the county’s Property Assessment Oversight Board). But under the new bill, the county manager would need consent from a majority of the seated members of County Council (eight out of the 15-member legislative body).

The bill also allows County Council to vote to remove the chief assessment officer, either for cause or lack of qualifications. The vote to remove would require a two-thirds vote (10 of 15 members), and before that, the officer must be allowed to participate in a public hearing before council to defend their job performance.

Advertise with us

Mr. Catena had previously introduced a similar bill tweaking the appointment process for the chief assessment officer, but that legislation allowed council to pick someone if the position sat vacant for at least 90 days. That provision was not in the new bill.

Council approved the first bill in a 9-6 vote, but Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald vetoed it. A vote for a veto override was scheduled in August, but Mr. Catena decided not to proceed, instead pursuing a different bill.

The chief assessment officer helps calculate reassessments for property owners in the county, which has been a focal point of debate, both legislatively and in the courts, for years. Many property owners in Downtown Pittsburgh and the city’s Strip District have contested the county’s reassessments in past years.

At one point, Common Pleas Court Judge Alan Hertzberg wrote in a decision that the county’s Allegheny County’s Office of Property Assessment had been “cooking the books” on common level ratio data it submitted to the state tax equalization board, a governing body that also helps determine reassessments.

The common level ratio is a metric used to help determine property assessment values in a given year, and are different for each county in Pennsylvania. Mr. Catena has said that the county’s “malfeasance” led to the judge’s opinion, but county officials have denied the court’s and opponents’ contentions, stating that the miscalculations were an honest mistake.

Advertise with us

According to the legislation introduced Tuesday, the chief assessment officer would also be required to provide quarterly updates to council, county executive, and county manager about information involving various data used in property assessments — including those used to calculate the common level ratio data.

Mr. Catena and Ms. Naccarati-Chapkis’ bill has been referred to council’s special committee on assessment practices, where it awaits further review.