The Allegheny County Council continued its recent battles with County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and his administration Tuesday, voting to sue him and local court officials over a recently announced contract for an outside nonprofit to run a juvenile detention center.

Lawmakers voted 9 to 4 to direct Council’s solicitor to file the lawsuit. Councilmembers Sam DeMarco, Tom Duerr, Nicholas Futules, and Bob Macey voted no. Councilmembers Suzanne Filiaggi and DeWitt Walton abstained from the vote.

Earlier this month, the Fifth Judicial District — the county’s court system — said it would contract with Adelphoi, a Latrobe-based social services provider, to reopen and run the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center, which closed in 2021. The center, based in Lincoln–Lemington–Belmar, housed about 20 juveniles when it closed. Since its opening in 1974, its maximum capacity had been about 120.

The plan, which has sparked political opposition, is for Shuman to undergo an initial round of renovations, and then reopen next year with 12 beds. The number of beds would increase as further work is completed.

Advertise with us

Under the contract, the facility would undergo $4.7 million in renovations, the planning for which could begin as soon as early October. County officials have said bids for the project were due earlier this month. The contract will call for renovations to be completed by Dec. 3

On Tuesday, Council President Pat Catena and other lawmakers criticized the decision to reopen the center through a contractor. Councilwoman Bethany Hallam said before the vote that the decision wasn’t about how the juvenile justice system should be handled, or the history of Adelphoi as a company — it was whether or not the contract violates the county charter.

“This is about is the county executive and the courts conspiring together to attempt to supersede the authority that is given to us as council members under the county charter. ... That's all this is about,” Ms. Hallam said.

Kim Berkeley Clark, president judge of the Fifth Judicial District, said before the vote that it would be a mistake to sue the county.

Judge Clark said in many recent cases judges have to send juveniles home with ankle bracelet monitoring systems, and that many of them reoffend. Shuman would give the county a resource for children who need assistance, she said.

Advertise with us

“If we continue to delay, more children will be harmed, and our community will continue to be unsafe,” Judge Clark said.

Mr. Fitzgerald’s office didn’t comment Tuesday.

A few residents said during Tuesday’s public comments that allowing Shuman to reopen would set a bad precedent. That included Brad Korinski, who is former chief counsel to the county controller’s office.

But some lawmakers disagreed. They said it was within Mr. Fitzgerald’s jurisdiction to approve the contract with Adelphoi.

That included Sam DeMarco, who said it was akin to similar contracts and construction work done within county facilities. Mr. DeMarco likened it to when the county’s Board of Elections moved from the sixth floor of a nearby county building to the third floor after renovations had been completed.

Advertise with us

And Mr. DeMarco noted that it’s the court system, not Adelphoi, using the Shuman facility. He described the move to sue as a “food fight,” Council telling Mr. Fitzgerald’s administration how to use a county-owned facility.

Council’s move to sue Mr. Fitzgerald over the Shuman contract follows other legal and legislative battles between the county’s legislative and executive branches in recent months.

In June, Mr. Fitzgerald sued Council over its minimum wage increase legislation, arguing it violates the county charter and county law. Council had previously overridden his veto of the bill in a 10-5 vote. That case is still in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.

In August, Council was poised to vote on another veto override regarding legislation that would tweak the process for how lawmakers select the county's chief assessment officer. That position helps collect data and calculate property assessments and reassessments throughout the county — an issue that has been contentious in recent years, as some property owners in Downtown and the Strip District have disputed assessments.

Correction: An earlier version of the headline for this story misstated the action taken by County Council. Lawmakers voted to direct Council’s solicitor to sue County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and the Fifth Judicial District. They did not file a lawsuit.