City Council is launching an investigation into the recently released police staffing study commissioned by Mayor Ed Gainey’s office, bringing scrutiny to a report that said Pittsburgh has enough cops but should redeploy some patrol officers.
Council President Theresa Kail-Smith said Friday that lawmakers would review the study, “including the procurement process, and a thorough and detailed review of the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police staffing study itself.” She said in a statement that the review would begin “immediately” under the direction of Councilman Anthony Coghill, who chairs the public safety committee, and Councilman Ricky Burgess. She said lawmakers would keep the public informed throughout their review.
The Council review comes amid questions about how the Gainey administration chose the firm Matrix Consulting to conduct the study, which was commissioned for $180,000.
All city contracts have to be approved by Council before any work begins. Council gave final approval to the contract with Matrix in June of 2022. But Matrix’s report states that “the project began in March 2022.” A Matrix vice president also told the Post-Gazette editorial board, which operates independently from the newsroom, that preparatory work had begun on the study that March. Legislation approving the contract did not appear on Council’s agenda until June 7.
A so-called Waiver of Competitive Process, which eliminates a requirement for other contractors to competitively bid on a project, had been filed. It said Matrix was the “only known company” to do this type of work, and that Matrix already was a consultant for the city on “police-related litigation.”
But in the contract, which ultimately was signed on July 12, 2022, the consulting group said it had not provided services to the city in the last three years.
Mr. Gainey’s office declined to comment Friday on Council’s new investigation.
Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt said the department “has spoken with Council President Kail-Smith and informed her that, as always, we welcome any inquiries and we will provide any information that they would like to review.’’
When the study was released last week, Bob Swartzwelder, the president of the local police union, said it was either “invalid” or the department was being “severely” mismanaged.
He cited a 2005 study by the International Association of Chiefs of Police, whose findings conflicted with the Matrix report.
The Matrix study found that the city had adequately budgeted for the correct number of Pittsburgh Bureau of Police officers. The IACP study recommended that the city have 414 patrol officers. The Matrix study suggested 263.
“I don’t know who Matrix people are, I don’t know where they’re from; I don’t know the backgrounds,” Mr. Swartzwelder said when the study was released. “But I do know, and everybody knows the International Association of Chiefs of Police.”
Newly appointed police Chief Larry Scirotto has already indicated that he won’t follow some of the new study’s recommendations, including moving more than 100 patrol officers to different units.
“This blueprint is a recommendation, and it’s not a directive,” Mr. Scirotto said during a news conference last week. “There are things that I strongly agree with, and there are a few things that I disagree with.”
The full staffing study, which is more than 170 pages long, has still not been made publicly available, despite promises from the Public Safety Department to do so.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.