Allegheny County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam’s rival in next month’s primary election accused her Wednesday of dealing heroin about a decade ago, questioning Ms. Hallam’s fitness for office and slamming her record as a public official.

Ms. Hallam, an at-large council member, has been open about her struggle with drug addiction and identifies as a formerly incarcerated person recovering from an opioid use disorder. But at a morning news conference in Schenley Park, Joanna Doven alleged that Ms. Hallam went further, “destroyed lives” by dealing drugs and now uses bullying tactics in office.

“Her actions today as a County Council leader really are that of a drug dealer, to be honest,” Ms. Doven said, the fiercest attacks so far in the most high-profile county council race on the May 16 Democratic primary ballot. 

While drug addiction is “in many ways a victimless crime,” Ms. Doven said, “drug-dealing in our communities is not.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Hallam did not immediately respond to messages seeking comment Wednesday but told WESA she was not a drug dealer. Her criminal record does not include any charges for selling illegal drugs. Court records show she sold a narcotic treatment for opioid addiction to an undercover cop in 2014.

Her opponent called dealing drugs a high crime that should disqualify offenders from serving in elected office under state law. The Pennsylvania Constitution bars those convicted of “infamous crime” from holding “any office of trust,” but doesn’t specify every “infamous” offense.

Ms. Doven said that voters, including police officers, have urged her to spotlight Ms. Hallam’s background “as they observe her chaos antics on council and they connect the two together.”

“We have no room for unfit elected leaders at every single level,” she said.

Elected to council in 2019, Ms. Hallam was part of a wave of local progressive victories, including the 2018 state House elections of Summer Lee, now in Congress, and Sara Innamorato, now running for county executive. 

Advertise with us

Ms. Hallam has since solidified her reputation as a progressive firebrand and vocal adversary of outgoing County Executive Rich Fitzgerald. Much of her work centers on the Allegheny County Jail, which she monitors as a member of the Jail Oversight Board. Her sharp criticisms of jail operations — and her clashes with Judge Elliot Howsie, who chairs the panel — have become fixtures at the board meetings. After she publicly called him a “prick” in January, an effort to censure Ms. Hallam failed in a 10-3 council vote.

Ms. Doven, a small business owner who was a spokesperson for former Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl, is running as a more centrist, establishment-friendly Democrat. On Wednesday, she cited an outside report that linked Ms. Hallam to the board’s “very strained” relationship with the jail.

On the drug matters, Ms. Doven pointed to court records showing Ms. Hallam sold suboxone, a narcotic treatment for opioid addiction, to an undercover detective during an investigation by Hampton police and county authorities June 2014. It wasn’t clear why her charges in that matter did not appear to include drug-dealing. District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.’s office declined to comment specifically on Wednesday. But generally, the DA’s office has diverted cases involving non-violent drug offenses tied to abuse of controlled substances, said Rebecca Spangler, Mr. Zappala’s chief of staff.

Ms. Hallam told WESA that she had sold her “own suboxone to support my drug addiction” and that she had “never even been accused of selling heroin — ever.”

“I’ve been in recovery for seven years now, and I turned my life around and I have never shied away from my past,” she told the station. “It’s one of the unique experiences that guides me as a legislator.”

Advertise with us

In early 2013, West View police found more than 100 empty heroin stamp bags in a car where Ms. Hallam had passed out, according to a criminal complaint. Police said they also found a digital scale and other drug-related items in the car. Four of the empty bags were labeled “Justin Beiber” [sic], according to the complaint. 

Ms. Hallam was charged at the time with DUI and paraphernalia-related counts. She pleaded guilty to three misdemeanor counts and two summary offenses and was sentenced to time served plus four days in jail and six months probation, court records show. 

“I wonder who Bethany Hallam was selling drugs to with a name like Justin Bieber,” Ms. Doven said, referring to the pop singer, who was a teenager at the time.

She also highlighted reporting by the Post-Gazette that Ms. Hallam made a secret proposal to return County Treasurer John Weinstein to the local sewer board after his removal last year. County Councilman Tom Duerr has called for a county ethics investigation in that matter.

Ms. Doven said she was sharing her concerns with several county government leaders in the hope that they will become part of a state ethics review. Last month, Councilman Sam DeMarco, the county GOP chair, said he was looking to make a request to the Pennsylvania State Ethics Commission that would be similar to Mr. Duerr’s.

Advertise with us

Standing alongside Ms. Doven at the news conference were Carl Bailey, a local Teamsters president who represents officers at roughly 60 police departments; Gayle Moss, a former local NAACP president who serves with Ms. Hallam on the Jail Oversight Board; and Bob Macey, a County Council member supporting Ms. Doven.

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz