As reelection campaigns go, Allegheny County Treasurer John Weinstein's last two were as easy as they get.

No Democrat challenged him in the 2015 or 2019 primaries, and Republicans didn't even bother fielding candidates in either general election. But despite running unopposed, Mr. Weinstein's campaign spent $1.2 million from 2014 through 2022 — tens of thousands of it in ways that raised questions for good-government advocates.

More than $120,000 for meals at some of the region's finest restaurants. At least $5,400 on membership dues at the posh Rivers Club in Downtown. Another $50,000 for monthly car payments and rentals — including $40,000 in years when he wasn't even on the ballot.

“It’s a striking sum to have spent over that period of time when you’re not facing an opponent,” said Patrick Christmas, chief policy officer at the good-government group Committee of Seventy.

Advertise with us

Mr. Weinstein is now a leading candidate for county executive. His chief rivals in the May 16 Democratic primary reported spending over the years that’s more in line with typical campaign activities. Take their spending on food: Generally, the money has paid for large fundraisers or meals for campaign volunteers and staff.

For Mr. Weinstein, the campaign paid tabs at high-end restaurants in sums that suggest more intimate gatherings.

At Scoglio’s Greentree, diners feast on Chicken Milanese, veal and peppers, pasta with slow-roasted Bolognese sauce and a bevy of other dishes inspired by northern Italian cuisine. Mr. Weinstein has spent nearly $7,000 of his campaign’s money there over about 60 visits, mostly for meals totaling less than $200 — far less than large fundraising events would cost.

He spent another $5,800 on meals at Rico’s Restaurant, a longtime fine dining fixture in Ross Township. And in more than 100 visits to restaurants in the Omni William Penn, Mr. Weinstein spent nearly $6,600, according to a Post-Gazette analysis of nine years of his campaign spending.

"In an era of political excess, this spending pattern is outrageous,” said Eric Epstein, a longtime government ethics reform advocate and founder of the prominent public watchdog group Rock the Capitol. “Once again we are reminded why we need campaign finance, and real spending guard rails."

Advertise with us

“It’s hard to govern like a Joe the Plumber when you spend like Kim Kardashian,” Mr. Epstein said.

Mr. Weinstein did not respond to an interview request or a list of questions sent by email.

Pennsylvania law gives candidates almost unfettered leeway when it comes to spending political donations. The law only requires that the money be spent "to influence the outcome of an election," a definition so broad that it has allowed politicians to use political donations for prime seats at major sporting events, trips through Europe with their families and even, in one case, a vintage pickup truck.

"We're at the top of the list for bottom feeders," Mr. Epstein said. "There's regular competition for which state is the most corrupt, and we're always in the Final Four."

Because of that leeway, Mr. Weinstein's spending likely doesn't break any laws, experts said. A $170 meal at Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse, like the one Mr. Weinstein charged to his campaign on July 31, 2015, could have been a meeting to woo a potential endorsement. Thousands in membership dues to the Rivers Club would have allowed him to rub elbows with some of the city’s top executives — and top donors.

Advertise with us

But such spending has drawn the attention of law enforcement in the past. When federal authorities prosecuted former Philadelphia District Attorney Seth Williams on bribery and corruption charges in 2017, his campaign’s payment of membership dues at luxurious private clubs was part of the indictment. Prosecutors later dropped that charge as part of a plea deal.

Around the country, laws governing how campaigns spend money generally prohibit using donations to pay purely personal expenses.

“When candidates and lawmakers misuse their supporters’ donations to pay their personal bills, trust and confidence in government suffers," said Patrick Llewellyn, director for state campaign finance at the nonprofit Campaign Legal Center in Washington, D.C. "Protecting against the personal use of campaign funds is a commonsense measure to ensure accountability in our political system.”

In Pennsylvania, it’s not just the law’s broad language that allows questionable spending; it’s the lack of enforcement, Mr. Christmas said.

“I don’t think we have proper oversight right now,” he said. “If no one’s enforcing the rules, people are going to bend or break them.”

Advertise with us

Restrictions on spending taxpayer dollars are far tighter — taxes are mandatory, campaign donations aren’t. But how a candidate spends donors’ money is one of the few windows available to the public to show how they manage an organization they control.

Mr. Weinstein has campaigned as a sound financial steward and a reliable guardian of taxpayers’ hard-earned money.

As treasurer of Pennsylvania’s second-largest county, he oversees the collection and investment of more than $1 billion in taxes and fees. His campaign highlights multiple investment policy awards from the Association of Public Treasurers of the United States and Canada. And during his decades running the office — which coincided with the internet’s growth into most facets of modern life — he has modernized the ways county residents can pay their bills by allowing online transactions.

But Mr. Weinstein’s spending of donors’ money suggests he’s "leading a gilded life with other people's campaign donations,” Mr. Epstein said.

Spending by his top opponents for Allegheny County executive falls more in line with typical campaign activities, records show. City Controller Michael Lamb’s food- and drink-related spending, for instance, comes to about $25,000 during those nine years, almost all of it to pay for seven fundraisers. State Rep. Sara Innamorato has spent less than $1,900 on meals since launching her first campaign in 2017, including pizza for campaign volunteers and staff lunches.

Advertise with us

Mr. Weinstein is alone among his rivals in spending campaign money on car payments and rentals, records show. That spending — $49,000 — is more than almost any other candidate for any office in Pennsylvania since 2000, according to the Post-Gazette’s analysis of state data.

Likewise, the volume of Mr. Weinstein’s spending on campaign meals — more than 1,100 individual expenses since 2014 — far exceeds others in the race. In fact, his annual average spending of about $15,000 puts him in league not with fellow county and local candidates, but with gubernatorial and statewide judicial campaigns — some of the largest and best-funded political operations in Pennsylvania.

Those races are also hotly contested. But Mr. Weinstein hasn’t faced any opponent since the 2011 general election, when he trounced the Republican challenger 67% to 33%.

“Weinstein is spending a hell of a lot of money to campaign against Harvey the Rabbit,” Mr. Epstein said.

"There have to be limits on how you can spend the money," he said. "We need to tighten the guardrails."

Mike Wereschagin: mwereschagin@post-gazette.com, @Wrschgn. Staff writer Neena Hagen contributed.