Allegheny County Treasurer John Weinstein forcefully denied any involvement in a secret attempt to return him to a powerful seat on the local sewer board that he lost last year, saying late Friday that his “goals never were and never will be to advance me.”  

In an article first published online Thursday, The Post-Gazette reported that County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam floated an offer last year to state Rep. Emily Kinkead: If Ms. Kinkead resigned her Alcosan board seat — creating an opening for Mr. Weinstein shortly after he had been removed — the politically powerful treasurer would stop supporting Ms. Kinkead’s opponent in the 2022 Democratic primary. Ms. Kinkead, D-Allegheny, rejected the idea, which raised legal and ethical questions. She won re-election and still serves on the sewer board.

In a blistering statement Friday evening headlined “Enough is Enough,” Mr. Weinstein said he could not have actually replaced Ms. Kinkead, because her board seat is “exclusively reserved for city-based appointees.” Now a leading Democratic candidate in the May 16 primary for county executive, Mr. Weinstein lives in Kennedy, not in the city of Pittsburgh, and had previously occupied an Alcosan seat controlled by county officials.

But there is no residency requirement for mayoral appointments to the body. One of the currently serving city appointees, Shannah Tharp Gilliam, doesn’t live in the city and didn’t when she was appointed by then-Mayor Bill Peduto in 2019 (she lives in Forest Hills).

Advertise with us

Mr. Weinstein’s campaign did not comment on those details Friday night. Ms. Hallam did not respond to requests for comment Thursday.

“I will no longer accept my more than two decades of service to our taxpayers being dragged through the mud on the basis of rumors, outright falsehoods and innuendos being slung by competitors,” Mr. Weinstein said in his statement.

“I look forward to this race moving away from deliberate smear tactics from my opponents and instead turning to a discussion of ideas about how best to move this region forward,” he added.

Earlier in the day, the growing questions surrounding Mr. Weinstein’s role on the sewer board took center stage in the high-stakes race for county executive, when an underdog candidate seized on news reports to suggest Mr. Weinstein abused official power for his own gain.

Dave Fawcett, a trial lawyer and former County Council member, cast big money in campaigns as potentially corrupting, tempting and dangerous, noting that the sewer board awards hundreds of millions of dollars in contracts to construction and other companies. And he highlighted Mr. Weinstein’s own fundraising as potentially problematic.

Advertise with us

“It’s not a big surprise that some people with bad motives might want to influence how that money is spent, just as it’s no surprise that people want to influence judges,” Mr. Fawcett, speaking during a news conference outside his law firm’s Downtown office, said of Alcosan spending that for years Mr. Weinstein helped oversee. “What is shocking and what is appalling is that a public official is willing to go to such great lengths to keep control and stay in the money game.”

The Post-Gazette has also previously reported that the FBI had approached Alcosan about Mr. Weinstein's activity as a board member there, and that a member of the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Pittsburgh had expressed concerns about Mr. Weinstein’s work there to county and city leaders.

Mr. Weinstein has not been charged with any wrongdoing or publicly identified as the subject of any investigation.

Mr. Weinstein served on the Alcosan board for a decade. But Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald removed him last year after the interest from federal authorities. That proved to be difficult, due to maneuvering by some of Mr. Weinstein's supporters on County Council. With the help of Ms. Hallam, a bare majority rejected Mr. Fitzgerald's first nominee to replace Mr. Weinstein, an exceptionally rare move that gave him another month on the Alcosan board.

Recent news reports, including by The Post-Gazette, suggest Mr. Weinstein has “engaged in a pattern of illegal activity in a number of contexts,” Mr. Fawcett said Friday. He called for limiting the size of campaign contributions in Allegheny County (there are currently no limits for county offices), and for more frequent disclosure of campaign fundraising and spending.

Advertise with us

Mr. Fawcett is among six Democrats seeking the party’s nomination for county executive in the May 16 primary election. He ended 2022 with roughly $308,000 in campaign cash — the second-highest total at that point, behind only Mr. Weinstein, according to financial filings. Mr. Weinstein’s campaign said more recently that it has raised more than $1 million total. Mr. Fawcett’s fundraising through 2022 included a $150,000 loan he made to his own campaign.

Democratic insiders generally regard Mr. Weinstein, state Rep. Sara Innamorato and Pittsburgh City Controller Michael Lamb as the leading candidates for the nomination to succeed Mr. Fitzgerald, who is term-limited. Mr. Fawcett is seen as a wild card who could surprise with a strong showing.

Ms. Innamorato and Mr. Lamb did not return messages seeking comment Friday.

Mr. Fawcett challenged coal giant Massey Energy in a series of court cases more than a decade ago, one of which established that judges should recuse themselves in certain circumstances when campaign contributions they have received pose a conflict of interest.

He said Friday that his opponents in the county executive race should voluntarily disclose their large campaign donations sooner than required by law — something he said he would be willing to do.

Advertise with us

“People need to be able to trust their elected officials,” Mr. Fawcett said. Allowing candidates and elected officials to accept unlimited campaign cash can lead to political corruption and abuse of power, he argued, accusing Mr. Weinstein of leveraging campaign money “to try to get people to do what he wants so that he can maintain his power.

If the proposal to Ms. Kinkead involved campaign money, that could have violated Pennsylvania law, said Delaney Marsco, senior legal counsel for ethics at the nonprofit Campaign Legal Center in Washington. It's illegal to offer something of monetary value to pursue “improper influence of an official’s action or judgment,” she said.

Responding to The Post-Gazette report Thursday on Twitter, Robert L. Byer, a former Commonwealth Court judge, said “it’s no surprise that [Ms. Kinkead] did the right thing here.  She is smart, honest and a dedicated public servant.” 

“As for the others,” he wrote, “we need a grand jury.” He tagged the Twitter handle for the state Attorney General’s Office.

In a statement Friday, Allegheny County GOP chair Sam DeMarco said the “seemingly quid pro quo alleged in news reports is exactly the kind of backroom politics Allegheny County cannot afford.” He called for Ms. Hallam to resign from County Council’s committee on government reform, and seconded Mr. Byer’s call for a grand jury.

Advertise with us

“I am not a lawyer and will not pretend to know all the nuances of the law,” Mr. DeMarco said, “but as a citizen and a member of Allegheny County Council, I know that the allegations raised against both Weinstein and Hallam call for a close examination.” 

The flurry of developments Friday also followed tension at a Thursday meeting of the Allegheny County Retirement Board. County Controller Corey O’Connor has pushed a measure to restrict political contributions from financial firms that invest the county’s pension money, which amounts to more than $1 billion, Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV reported.

Mr. Weinstein, who chairs the retirement board, said the measure wasn’t “in the bounds of the law correctly.” A committee will explore the matter, including how many fund managers the county needs, KDKA reported.

The crowded Democratic field for county executive shrank by one on Friday, when Olivia “Liv” Bennett withdrew from that race as well as her bid for reelection to County Council, David Voye, an Allegheny County Elections Division manager, confirmed. She won't appear on the primary ballot, but her withdrawal preserves her ability to run as a third-party or independent candidate in November. Ms. Bennett did not return a call Friday evening.

Mike Wereschagin contributed. Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz