Oakland stakeholders disagreed over the contested redevelopment proposal slated for parts of Central and South Oakland during a community meeting Tuesday with Mayor Ed Gainey.
The Walnut Capital plan was first proposed to the City Council by former Mayor Bill Peduto in September and would include rezoning parts of Central and South Oakland to allow for the building of more than 1,000 apartment units and other amenities.
On Tuesday, the Oakland Planning and Development Corporation, which has publicly spoken out against the proposal, held a community meeting over Zoom with Mr. Gainey and various Oakland residents, landlords and other interested parties.
Many raised concerns about the process in which this proposal has come about.
“It feels very top down when I believe that planning in the city should be community driven,” Kathy Gallagher, a North Oakland resident said during the meeting.

The legislation for the development was proposed by Mr. Peduto in September and then later amended by City Council prior to being submitted to the planning commission.
Read More
Typically, zoning changes like this one are initiated by the planning department or community groups. They would then go to the planning commission and then to council.
Wanda Wilson, the executive director for OPDC, also raised concern that there had been no public meetings during the zoning legislation’s early phases.
“There really was no public process around this and our public planners, our city planning staff, weren’t involved in drafting it,” Ms. Wilson said.
Moving forward, Mr. Gainey will hold a “public community listening session” on Feb. 2 at 6 p.m., over Zoom and Facebook Live to hear from Oakland residents on the proposal.
During Tuesday’s meeting, Mr. Gainey said his “main goal is just to listen,” to “find out how residents feel about things.”
“I just want to thank everybody for coming out, because I think this is what it’s about,” Mr. Gainey said. “I think this is how we begin to learn what the priorities are.”
Residents also raised concerns about contents of the legislation, particularly its lack of a commitment to affordable housing and potential displacement of current residents.
“Every time we tear down houses and build more expensive houses or tear down houses and build other buildings that aren’t even houses … we displace people,” said Randy Sargent, a South Oakland resident.
Mr. Sargent also said he was concerned about the affordability of the apartments in the development.
According to the plans, 10% of the units must be designated as “walk to work,” which means they cannot rent for more than 30% of a person’s gross income.
“If we’re building even more expensive things, we have to be able to say there’s an income limit on who’s going into these and making sure it’s affordable for people at lower incomes,” Mr. Sargent said.
Some other points of contention that were raised during the meeting involved the actual plans for the development, such as the height of the building and whether or not the green space would be public or only for the building’s residents.
However, some residents said they were happy with the idea of a new development coming to the area.
“This would do good for the people of Oakland,” said Nick Casciato, a lifelong Oakland resident who also owns property on Halket Street near where the development would be.
The plans for the redevelopment include a grocery store, which Oakland does not have, along with an expansion of green spaces and a way to “eliminate blighted properties.”
Another resident said he viewed this proposal as “evolving and progressive” for the Oakland community.
Ms. Wilson said that the OPDC isn’t against new development in Oakland.
“We believe that we could have new development and redevelopment and maintain the character of our community with better zoning legislation that could be written,” Ms. Wilson said.
Mr. Gainey said a planning commission public hearing is scheduled for Feb. 8. That public hearing had originally been scheduled for earlier in January, but Mr. Gainey requested a 30-day continuance “in order to provide clarity in the technical language and ensure equitable development is prioritized” by the city.
City Councilman Bruce Kraus, whose district contains the proposed development, was also on the Zoom call but did not comment.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.