The Allegheny County Board of Elections voted Saturday to process several hundred provisional ballots that had previously been challenged while the county was reviewing and counting eligible ballots.
Of the 17,000 provisional ballots cast, the Board voted on three issues that had impacted those 600-800 provisional ballots that had been flagged.
The first two involved missing signatures on different parts of the form — in one case, voters signed on one line but not the other and vice versa. The board had to decide if one signature was sufficient for the ballot to be processed. The third issue involved voters who used a provisional ballot because their mail-in ballot did not include the required “secrecy envelope.”
On all three scenarios put to a vote, County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and council member Bethany Hallam voted yes, to process the votes, while council member Sam DeMarco voted no, to reject those ballots.
At Saturday’s hearing, the board listened to arguments from each political party that brought the challenges as well as testimony from voters who used provisional ballots.
One voter said she originally applied for a mail-in ballot but was worried it wasn’t correct since she had recently moved. So, she went to the polling place to use a provisional ballot. Another said he requested a mail-in ballot but remembers that, in a “moment of carelessness and stupidity,” did not use the secrecy envelope. A poll worker told him he could vote using a provisional ballot instead.
Read More
Yet another said he requested a mail-in ballot but it never arrived. He voted using a provisional ballot and said he does not remember signing on line 4, one of the disputed places on the form. He asked the poll workers if there was anything else he needed to do and they said no.
Representatives for both political parties stuck to similar arguments regarding the various reasons a provisional ballot may have been challenged.
Attorney Russell Giancola, representing the Republican party, argued the election code should be strictly followed, meaning ballots that lacked all the designated signatures or lacked the proper envelopes, should be thrown out. “Where the legislature uses the word shall, it means shall,” he said.
Michael Healey, representing the Democratic party, argued that voters should not be disenfranchised on “technical grounds.” Furthermore, he said, the two signatures in question signified similar things, so signing in one place should be sufficient.
“If you would disqualify them from voting, it is perhaps at best a technical defect,” he said. “We should error on the side of caution. These voters should be allowed to vote.”
Appeals to the Board’s decisions on Saturday are due to the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County within two days. Hearings on those appeals, if there are any, will be held on Tuesday.
As of Saturday, the county had counted about 14,000 provisional ballots, according to Allegheny County elections division manager David Voye.
Lauren Rosenblatt: lrosenblatt@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1565.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.