What it means to be a “proactive” state lawmaker is at the center of the race for Pennsylvania’s 20th legislative district, as Democrat Adam Ravenstahl faces a primary challenge from an attorney and former Commonwealth Court clerk who questions the incumbent’s leadership style and ideological consistency.
Emily Kinkead, who wants to deny Mr. Ravenstahl a sixth term by beating him in the June 2 primary, said residents of the district — which snakes from Lawrenceville and the Strip District up through Riverview Park to Bellevue and Avalon — deserve a representative who is going to define their own agenda, straight from the voices of constituents to the halls of power.
To Ms. Kinkead, that kind of legislator is one who introduces bills even if they don’t necessarily think they’ll pass — because “it’s important to get the conversation started.”
“We don’t have to win every battle, but we do have to fight it,” Ms. Kinkead said, offering what she deems a progressive platform built on more than 15 years of policy experience.
Mr. Ravenstahl, first elected in 2010, said he’s proud of his record and warned that asking any member of a minority party what they’ve passed legislatively is not a meaningful metric — though he pointed out that his ideological bonafides show through the more than 100 bills he’s co-sponsored.
Instead, it’s about collaborating locally, bringing in state funding and connecting constituents with resources, he said.
Read More
“In my opinion, it’s not always the loudest person that gets the results,” Mr. Ravenstahl said. “I’ve found in my tenure that you get results and get things done forming relationships with people and a level of trust with people.”
The biggest difference between his approach and Ms. Kinkead’s, he said, is that he’s been doing the job for a decade, has the experience and has built the relationships — which will be key going into a post-pandemic Pennsylvania, or “new territory for all of us.”
“I think it’s critical to have somebody in office ... who’s battle tested, who’s been there, and who has the relationships and accrued this seniority to get things done,” Mr. Ravenstahl said.
But Ms. Kinkead points to her own experience in working on issues from gerrymandering reform to reproductive justice — work that’s led her from the legislative policy office of the National Institutes of Health, to a legal aid clinic in Kenya and to clerking in the Commonwealth Court.
Ms. Kinkead said she’s the one who can form the necessary relationships with local, state and federal officials, and insisted she’ll meet constituents where they are, and not simply expect them to come to the office for help. Ask them now what their state lawmaker has done, she said, and they won’t be able to name anything.
Like that of other incumbents, Mr. Ravenstahl’s campaign literature highlights the millions of dollars he’s garnered in state funding — $10 million in 2019, he said, which has been used to improve parks from Ross to Bellevue and fund infrastructure development for purposes like managing storm-water.
Ms. Kinkead said that’s not enough, and that while his grants go mostly to parks, places like the Brighton Heights senior center get largely ignored, even though its first floor has been “unusable” for a decade.
“A lot of the grants he claims [to have gotten] are grants that were applied for by the city and municipalities in the district that he largely didn’t have an impact on,” Ms. Kinkead said.
Mr. Ravenstahl said the money he’s brought has impacted a wide range of entities, and noted that in 2019, he helped bring in a $100,000 grant for the senior center in particular — which, according to a press release, would “be used to renovate the center’s main floor that is used for senior events and programs.”
Beyond issues of style and finances, Ms. Kinkead takes issue with Mr. Ravenstahl’s ideology, and specifically, how he’s seemingly changed his opinions over time. She said constituents know where she stands, while in the incumbent’s case, he was once pro-life, for example, and now says he’s pro-choice.
She alleged that it was a matter of political convenience for Mr. Ravenstahl, now facing a pro-choice woman for the first time.
Mr. Ravenstahl said he’s “adapted’ with the district, and that on the issue of abortion in particular, he changed his opinion after meeting with doctors and advocates from Planned Parenthood. He denied that it was a politically convenient decision, and said he made the switch a few years ago — well before facing this primary challenge.
But then there’s the issue of marriage equality. Ms. Kinkead alleged that Mr. Ravenstahl was once opposed to marriage equality and then evolved his stance when it was convenient.
Asked about this, Mr. Ravenstahl said he’s always been in favor of same-sex marriage and has never cast a vote against it — though in 2012, he responded to a questionnaire from the Steel City Stonewall Democrats and said that although he supported domestic partnerships and civil unions, he was “opposed to same sex marriage.”
“To clarify, though I do not favor same sex marriage, I also do not favor an amendment to the commonwealth’s constitution that would ban it,” Mr. Ravenstahl wrote in the 2012 questionnaire.
Given another term, Mr. Ravenstahl said he would focus on how to bring more investment to Pennsylvania’s schools so students have access to the right equipment. He also said the COVID-19 pandemic has shown the need to raise the minimum wage.
One of Ms. Kinkead’s first priorities would be to advocate for an independent redistricting commission.
No Republicans are filed to run in the general election.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.