A controversial state House candidate shunned by the Pennsylvania Democratic Party apparatus has dropped an emergency request to get her name on thousands of mailings sent to registered voters in Allegheny County.

It turns out that Heather Kass’ name was already printed on three of the 44 slate cards sent this week to more than 4,000 registered voters, meaning that regardless of any friction between her and the state party, the Carrick resident ended up getting what she wanted.

Ms. Kass’ lawyer, Ryan Mergl, said it was only after filing Tuesday for a preliminary injunction that he learned that his client’s name had been printed on the slate cards. He told Allegheny County Common Pleas Senior Judge Joseph M. James during a five-minute telephone conference Friday morning that he was withdrawing the injunction request.

“It’s my understanding that my client, at the accommodation of the county party, was included in a mailing that went out to the pertinent district. The state was not on board with that, but the county sent it out, so right now there’s no emergency. That is moot,” Mr. Mergl said.

Advertise with us

The dropped request had also sought access by Ms. Kass to a state voter database called VoteBuilder.

Despite the amicable tenor of the meeting, Mr. Mergl was clear that the lawsuit alleging breach of contract and unjust enrichment will continue. It seeks a jury trial and compensatory and punitive damages.

Mr. Mergl said his client had to spend money getting an alternate list of voters and paying for political consultants and attorneys to guide her through a situation that is “something an endorsed candidate a week before an election should not have to worry about.”

Ms. Kass claims that despite paying a $2,500 fee, following all party rules and winning an overwhelming endorsement — 49-19 — by the county committee in February, the state party chairwoman, Nancy Patton Mills, withdrew support because of old comments by Ms. Kass on social media that made her a pariah among members of her own party.

Ms. Kass voiced support of President Donald Trump prior to the 2016 election, criticized the Affordable Care Act and referred to “junkies” in mentioning the opioid crisis. She has since distanced herself from those statements.

Advertise with us

The endorsement of Ms. Kass over progressive rival Jess Benham prompted disbelief from others on the committee and top county Democrats, including Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto, Allegheny-Fayette Central Labor Council President Darrin Kelly and State Sens. Wayne Fontana and Lindsey Williams.

Ms. Kass’ lawsuit said Ms. Patton Mills issued a statement saying, “ ‘We do not and will not support her candidacy.’ ”

That withdrawal of support led to concern on Ms. Kass’ part about whether her name would ultimately appear on the slate cards mailed out to voters.

Clifford Levine, an attorney for the state party, said in an interview that Ms. Kass’ comments had put her “out of sync” with her party, which was frustrated that the county committee “would have endorsed a candidate who openly and regularly opposed core Democratic principles ….”

The state party “was concerned that Ms. Kass was on the slate card. They were not willing to pay for that,” Mr. Levine said.

Advertise with us

But, Mr. Levine added, the state party was willing to provide Raff Printing on the South Side with the names from the voter database for all the slate cards to be distributed throughout the county — with the proviso that the county committee pay for the mailing cost of those cards with Ms. Kass’ name.

Mr. Levine said it was the county committee’s decision to include Ms. Kass’ name on the slate cards.

“As it turned out,” Mr. Levine said, “Ms. Kass was included in the slate cards that went to the voters in her district. And so there was no different treatment of her in the end in terms of what she experienced.”

Albert Veverka, the county committee’s lawyer, said he had kept in touch with the Kass camp to apprise them of the status of the slate cards, including sending a mock-up with her name on it.

“We knew that we had done our part, and we were waiting for the state to approve and send them out,” Mr. Veverka said, “so the county wasn’t aware when it was going, or to whom it was going out, until after it was sent.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Mergl said the whole situation should have been addressed weeks ago. He claimed that texts and phone messages he left starting May 8 or so with Ms. Patton Mills and the county committee head, Eileen Kelly, in an attempt to sort out the situation were not returned.

“If someone would have just sent me a text message on my cellphone two weeks ago, we would have had the answer, and we wouldn’t be here,” Mr. Mergl said.

“Eileen Kelly and Nancy Patton Mills, both of whom have my cellphone number and who I called repeatedly, none of them returned my phone calls. It would have been a very easy matter when I started making phone calls saying, ‘Hey, guys, what’s going on?”

Both Mr. Veverka, the committee’s lawyer, and Mr. Levine said the mere fact that a candidate is endorsed does not confer any special rights.

“There is no list of things you get when you’re endorsed,” Mr. Veverka said. “There is no promise that you will get put on a slate card or a slate card will get mailed or passed out. There’s no written document that states, ‘This is what you get when you are the endorsed candidate.’ ”

Advertise with us

Mr. Levine took a similar position.

“There certainly is no legal or contractual obligation of a state party to support a local candidate in that way,” Mr. Levine said. “The legal question here was: Did the Allegheny County endorsement create any type of obligation? And there’s no obligation at all, there’s no connection with the state party in that legal sense.”

During the conference call, Mr. Levine said he hoped to get the state party removed as a defendant.

“The gist of the complaint really deals with the endorsement by the county,” Mr. Levine said. “At some point, we would be seeking to get out of the lawsuit itself.”

Mr. Mergl disagreed.

Advertise with us

He praised the county committee for working with him to sort out the matter of the slate cards and disputed the notion that the complaint is narrowly about the county committee’s endorsement.

“That’s not true. It is absolutely a state issue because the problem did not lie with the county. You have to go through the county to get to the state,” Mr. Mergl said.

Mr. Mergl said there is a decadeslong history of the state party providing cooperation and privileges to endorsed candidates who pay fees to be considered.

Now, Mr. Mergl claimed, the state party wants to refute that aspect of the relationship between it and a candidate. In that case, Mr. Mergl suggested, candidates should stop paying the fees because they aren’t guaranteed to get something in return. And that alleged breach of contract led his client to sue.

“When you have the chairperson of the entire state who is a member of the Democratic National Committee that all these subcommittees must answer to come out and say we don’t care if you follow the endorsement process, we don’t care and we’re going to interfere with the cooperation and the rights that you’re entitled to, there is some recourse there,” Mr. Mergl said.

Ms. Kass is running for the 36th Legislative District seat left empty with the retirement of longtime state Rep. Harry Readshaw. The district spans from Carrick and Mount Washington within Pittsburgh’s city limits to Baldwin Borough and Brentwood. Ms. Kass is running against Ms. Benham, Ed Moeller and Mark Johnson in seeking the Democratic nomination.