A candidate for Liberty council who withdrew her name from the ballot when she faced a life-threatening medical emergency in August can’t be put back on the ballot for the general election despite her return to health, a judge ruled Wednesday.
Candidate Jennifer Riley can, however, still run as a write-in candidate in the November election for a spot on the borough’s council.
Ms. Riley won both Democratic and Republican nominations for a four-year term on Liberty’s council during the May primary elections. But in August, she was diagnosed with a life-threatening condition that required “aggressive medical treatment” and caused her to believe her “life expectancy would be substantially shortened,” according to a petition she filed Monday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
In light of that medical emergency, Ms. Riley withdrew her name from the ballot.
Now, her medical condition has improved and is no longer “immediately life-threatening,” according to the filing. Her attorney, Jason Elash, asked the judge to return Ms. Riley’s name to the ballot and argued her earlier decision to withdraw was not “knowing, intelligent and voluntary” because of the duress she was under as she faced the dire medical diagnosis.
Senior Judge Joseph M. James rejected that argument during a Wednesday hearing and denied Ms. Riley’s petition. He did not return a request for comment, but Mr. Elash said the judge cited state election regulations in making his decision.
“Once you intend to withdraw and withdraw you can’t come back on,” Mr. Elash said. “It doesn’t matter that the circumstances that made you decide to withdraw have changed.”
The state’s election code states that candidates who withdraw from the ballot ahead of November elections can’t undo the action.
“No candidate may withdraw any withdrawal notice already received and filed and thereby reinstate his nomination,” the code reads.
Allan Opsitnick, assistant county solicitor, said Thursday that provision was a “sticking point” for Judge James.
“He felt he could not put her back on the ballot,” he said, adding that the judge emphasized to Ms. Riley during the Wednesday hearing that she could run as a write-in candidate. In general elections, write-in candidates are measured simply by the number of votes they get and don’t have to hit any particular quota or threshold.
“It’s whoever has the most [votes],” Mr. Opsitnick said.
Ms. Riley was one of three nominated candidates for three open spots on the Liberty Borough Council.
Barring a win from a write-in candidate, all three were essentially guaranteed spots on the council. There will now be two candidates on the ballot during the November elections for the three spots. Ms. Riley will likely run as a write-in candidate, Mr. Elash said. She was not immediately available for comment Thursday.
Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.