Allegheny County Councilwoman Denise Ranalli Russell of Brighton Heights and her District 13 challenger in the May 21 Democratic primary, Liv Bennett of Northview Heights, agree that one of the biggest problems facing county council and its potential candidates is that no one knows what county council is or what it does.
“Some people don’t even realize they have county representation,” Ms. Ranalli Russell said.
“They’re like, ‘Oh, you’re running against [Pittsburgh City Councilwoman] Darlene Harris?’ People do not recognize that there is a county council, so then they don’t really know what to ask,” Ms. Bennett said.
District 13 is almost entirely within the city of Pittsburgh — along the Allegheny River to Morningside, through Downtown and south to Beltzhoover, and the whole North Side, plus Bellevue — so the district’s representative inevitably will compete for oxygen with Pittsburgh’s sometimes-controversy-courting council and high-profile Mayor Bill Peduto.
But the two women’s prescriptions for fixing the county council’s low profile differ.
Ms. Ranalli Russell, 52, has held the seat since winning a close primary race in 2015. For her, continuing the work the council does, while prioritizing constituent services and education, is the path.
Read More
“I am always available for anything I can do to help [my constituents]. If they have a question, if I don’t know the answer, I will find it for them,” said Ms. Ranalli Russell, who owns an Etna barbershop.
She highlighted concrete improvements.
“I’m on the Public Works Committee, and we’re always fighting for funding so that we can increase our paving. We’ve done it by at least 10% each year since I’ve taken office,” she said.
Her challenger, Ms. Bennett, 40, thinks the council should follow the lead of its city counterparts more often, and views advocacy on issues outside its mandate as part of the job.
“I want to be an advocate and a voice for those who may not know how to use their voice or may not know how to advocate certain situations or issues,” said Ms. Bennett, an administrator at the University of Pittsburgh who will begin a master’s program at the university’s Graduate School of Public and International Affairs this fall.
On some issues before the council, the two agree — at least to an extent. Ms. Ranalli Russell is a co-sponsor of pending legislation to ban conversion therapy for sexual orientation and gender identity, which comes more than two years after Pittsburgh passed a similar bill.
“I don’t believe in the shock treatment and stuff that I was reading about. That’s insane,” she said.
Ms. Bennett agrees, saying: “I absolutely agree with [the ordinance], and I honestly couldn’t believe it was still legal!”
But Ms. Ranalli Russell doesn’t think the county should follow the city down every path it takes.
“Things need to be done with guns, but you know right now it’s not really a city or county issue. I don’t know how much we would be able to do. It’s a state issue.”
“I’d like to see the county mirror the city,” Ms. Bennett said.
Last week, Mr. Peduto signed three gun-control ordinances that gun rights groups said they will challenge in court.
Ms. Bennett also wants the county to follow the city’s lead and set a $15-an-hour minimum wage for its employees.
Ms. Bennett’s initial interest in politics comes in large part from another issue where she would like to see the county follow the city.
“Why I decided to run for county council is, I’m usually out in the street advocating, and one of the recent ones was the Antwon Rose trial. And out of those protests came the realization that there was a need for a civilian police review board, which would be directly under Allegheny County Council to enact.”
There is pending legislation to create such a board before council, although only Allegheny County Police would be automatically covered by the board. By state law, municipalities would have to opt in. Ms. Bennett said she would like to work with state legislators to change that.
Ms. Ranalli Russell voted last summer for a series of public hearings on a civilian police review board, but she has not attached her name to the ordinance that came out of it. Most of the district already is covered by the existing Pittsburgh board, she pointed out, while Bellevue officials have told her they would not opt in, she said.
“It still needs a lot of work to be done on it yet before anything comes to the table,” she said.
Both candidates said they’re concerned about issues at the Allegheny County Jail, which is plagued with complaints by both incarcerated people and employees.
“We need to find a way to make the environment better for both the inmates and the guards. That’s important to me,” Ms. Ranalli Russell said.
“If I have this seat on the council, which has some authority over the Allegheny County Jail, I’d like to use that seat to make sure we’re paying attention to the jail and having their needs and rights met,” Ms. Bennett said.
For example, she said, that means “advocating for separate housing for transgender incarcerated people. That’s because especially transgender women are being housed as their assigned gender at birth. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to get to the end result of these incarcerated people being sexually assaulted not only by other incarcerated people but also by guards.”
Ms. Bennett also has said she wants the district attorney to do away with cash bail for nonviolent offenders.
“Our society of treating rich and guilty people better than poor and innocent people has to be changed,” she said.
She said that would not be something council could do, but she believes council should push for others to make changes. She also has universal health care in her platform but admits that would mean working with state or national legislators.
Ms. Bennett also wants to increase enforcement and transparency regarding major polluters, to expand the East Busway into the Mon Valley and to make bus transfers free.
Both candidates spoke of the need to protect and build affordable housing, Ms. Bennett pointing to land trusts as a tool, while Ms. Ranalli Russell preferred the use of affordable housing mandates as part of development tax incentives. The district includes Lawrenceville, the center of many of the region’s conversations about development and affordable housing, including a recent city council proposal for a neighborhood-wide inclusionary zoning mandate.
Ms. Bennett, with her background in activism, said she was proud of her endorsements from prominent local activists, including Leon Ford, the police shooting survivor who sued the city, and Brandi Fisher, president of the Alliance for Police Accountability.
Ms. Ranalli Russell touts endorsements from the Allegheny/Fayette Central Labor Council and the Allegheny County Democrats.
Ms. Bennett appears to have almost $20,000 in tax liens against a house she co-owns in Elliott. The liens are for unpaid city, county and school district property taxes as well as Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority bills, under a previous name from a marriage.
Ms. Bennett said in response to initial questions and documents showing the tax liens on the Elliott address, "Yes, I am working class and it's no secret. I have been openly campaigning around the fact that I live in public housing. It's on my campaign website and printed on my campaign literature and has been since day one. Frankly, it's absurd that our county council is made up almost entirely of wealthy people."
In response to further questions about the address in question, Ms. Bennett's campaign manager Arielle Teer said, "Some of the documents that you sent over are new to Liv. I'm not sure if she's seen them before.."
Ms. Teer explained via text, "There is a bankruptcy filing she is attached to that's at least around fifteen years old."
"Liv has overcome much adversity which is a large reason why she is focused on creating a more equitable Allegheny County and campaigning on being a voice for the most marginalized," Ms. Teer said.
This story has been updated with information about Ms. Bennett’s taxes. Christopher Huffaker: 412-263-1724, chuffaker@post-gazette.com, or @huffakingit.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.