In a couple major areas, incumbent Republican state Sen. Camera Bartolotta and Democratic challenger James Craig agree: Pennsylvania needs to become more business friendly and encourage drilling companies to expand the extraction of natural gas reserves from the Marcellus Shale play.

But beyond that, the candidates for the state’s 46th Senate District seat seem to disagree on most issues in the Nov. 6 election. The widely diverse district covers all of mostly rural Greene County and parts of more heavily populated Beaver and Washington counties.

In his effort to knock out his one-term incumbent opponent, Mr. Craig, 29, of North Strabane is relying heavily on his personal story of overcoming a rough childhood and the deaths of his mother and a brother as victims of the opioid crisis and an addicted father who died of cancer. As a child, he lived with a variety of family members and friends before rising above all that to attend college, earn a law degree and create a business as a real estate attorney.

Now, to help people in similar family situations, he’s making his first run for political office.

Advertise with us

“The message is universal,” Mr. Craig said. “It’s had a very broad reception. Some people forget a vast swath of the population grew up like I did. They know I know what it’s like to be on food stamps.”

With limited campaign resources —  the last campaign reports filed at the primary election showed Ms. Bartolotta with nearly three times as much money — Mr. Craig is relying on a door-to-door campaign to spread his message. He claims he’s been to some 50,000 residences.

“We’ve knocked on doors that have never been knocked on before,” Mr. Craig said. “The message I have is, ‘We may have problems but they’re not too big to fix.’

“I’m trying to be the voice that makes [other legislators] pay attention.”

Mr. Craig has been critical of the incumbent in two specific areas — the amount of money she has accepted as reimbursement for expenses and her vote against a recent bill on domestic abuse.

Advertise with us

In her first campaign, Ms. Bartolotta said she would refuse per diems available to legislators, but Mr. Craig said she instead billed more for actual expenses of more than $153,000 over four years, which he said turned her campaign promise into “an absolute lie.” The district needs “politicians who are going keep their word to voters, and not play games with taxpayer money,” he said in an Oct. 10 news release.

Ms. Bartolotta said her opponent “pulled some ridiculous number out of the clouds” and “doesn’t know math very well” because he double-counted many of her expense items. Over her nearly four years in office, she said, she has been “very frugal” and her total expenses are $44,960, which she said is substantially lower than most legislators. She also noted she won’t take a state pension.

Mr. Craig also questioned Ms. Bartolotta’s vote against a recent bill to strengthen requirements for those facing a protection from abuse order to turn over their weapons, saying she was one of five senators to vote against it. Ms. Bartolotta countered that she voted in favor of the original Senate version of the bill but after a series of amendments in the House it had too many “loose ends” and “unanswered questions” for her to support it.

But she said her sponsorship of a Senate bill known as Tierne’s Law to provide district judges more background information on defendants facing protection from abuse orders shows her commitment to protecting victims. That bill was approved last spring.

Ms. Bartollota, 54, of Monongahela, said her plans for a second term include encouraging vocational education to replenish the state’s dwindling pool of skilled trade workers and fighting the opioid crisis. In addition to her Senate office, she owns the Duke of Oil quick-lube shop started 30 years ago by her late husband.

Advertise with us

Ms. Bartolotta said she is working with Sen. Art Haywood, D-Philadelphia, to create a justice reform caucus that will concentrate on finding ways to treat opioid abusers without giving them extensive criminal records that make it hard for them to find jobs when they get out of prison.

“We need to take a look at what really is rehabilitation,” she said. “We make a two-year sentence a life sentence when someone becomes unemployable because they have an opioid conviction. We’ve got to do better.”

Ms. Bartolotta criticized Mr. Craig for possible forged signatures on nominating petitions he filed to get on the ballot in the primary election. Beaver County District Attorney David Lozier said Friday there is “an on-going investigation” into the petitions but declined additional comment.

“This is about the integrity of the electoral process,” Ms. Bartolotta said. “His entire campaign is frauight with deception.”

Mr. Craig said he wasn’t involved with collecting any fraudulent signatures and had more than double the amount of signatures required to be on the ballot. He called the issue “really just a distraction.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Bartolotta also had strong words for state Attorney General Josh Shapiro and the state House after they criticized Senate Republicans this week for not passing legislation to extend the time sexual abuse victims can file lawsuits against organizations such as the Catholic church. The Senate had passed legislation more than a year ago, she said, and House amendments in recent weeks didn’t address two of the four grand jury recommendations for reforms, she said.

“[The criticism] was despicable to me,” she said.

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1470 or on Twitter @EdBlazina.