HARRISBURG -- The escalating ad war between two Republican state Senate candidates went too far this week for Allegheny County GOP chairman Jim Roddey, who called on the candidates to drop their attacks for the remainder of their campaigns.

In response, state Rep. Mark Mustio of Moon -- whose negative ads Mr. Roddey described as "not in good taste" -- announced Friday that he would be replacing his negative television spots in the 37th Senatorial District race.

Those ads had resurrected several claims against Indian-born software executive D. Raja that also were raised during his county executive bid last year.

They correctly stated that his company outsourced jobs to India and sued workers who broke their contracts, but the accompanying images of the Indian flag and fliers using his full name drew cries of racism from some supporters and others.

Advertise with us

Mr. Raja also responded with his own negative ads, pointing to Mr. Mustio's vote for the 2005 legislative pay raise.

Mr. Roddey said that as the intra-party fighting ramped up days before Tuesday's primary, he heard concerns from local committee chairmen and others.

"I became very disappointed and very distressed at the way things deteriorated" on both sides, Mr. Roddey said. "However, the negative ads by Mark Mustio were slanted so that if you had any prejudice against Indian-Americans, it would be inflated."

The party chairman said he asked both camps to spike their negative ads by 3 p.m. Friday.

The intervention of Mr. Roddey comes after weeks of public brawling between the two candidates, who are polling near-even heading into Tuesday's balloting. A third candidate, Sue Means of Bethel Park, has little funding and has avoided the ad battle.

Advertise with us

As the two camps were responding to the request for a cease-fire, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette's editorial board took the unusual step on Friday of rescinding its endorsement of Mr. Mustio.

In an editorial that runs today, the newspaper cited a flier from the Mustio camp using Mr. Raja's full first name, Dakshinamurthy, which he does not use, as an attempt to play into racial prejudices that went too far.

Mr. Roddey said he does not believe Mr. Mustio is racist, but he said the tone of the advertisements was "inappropriate."

"There's negative ads, and then there are things that are just not in good taste," Mr. Roddey said.

In its release Friday morning, the Mustio campaign said it would be removing the television and radio ads as soon as they could be pulled from the stations' rotation.

Advertise with us

"While I still believe that the records of public officials and candidates for public office should be subject to a certain degree of scrutiny during a campaign, that scrutiny should be balanced with an equal degree of decorum and respect," Mr. Mustio said in a statement.

"I believe the campaign for this seat has become imbalanced and for that reason I have decided the only thing I will be communicating to voters is my experience as a local businessman and my accomplishments as a state legislator."

The alternative Mustio ad responds to an attack over his pay raise vote and points to his support for repealing it. It also notes his endorsement from retiring GOP state Sen. John Pippy.

The Raja campaign said Friday afternoon that they are continuing to air an ad responding to Mr. Mustio's claims. The spot concludes by referring to their opponent as one of the "midnight pay raise gang."

The campaign also has another positive piece on air, according to a consultant.

Advertise with us

Several Republican officials who have endorsed Mr. Mustio or offered him financial support declined to comment on the tone of the ads or did not return requests for comment. A spokeswoman for the state Republican Party also did not respond to a request for comment.

Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, a Jefferson County Republican who leads his caucus's campaign efforts, said the state Senate Republican Campaign Committee is not involved in the primary contest.

He did say that many people he talked to during a recent trip to Pittsburgh mentioned the contest's ads and viewed the tone as "very nasty." He said the advertising could turn voters toward Ms. Means.

"The race card, the ethnic card is not a good card to play in a country where we've elected a black president and the Republican Party is stereotyped as a bunch of curmudgeonly white men," Mr. Scarnati said of referring to a candidate's background.

A consultant for the Mustio campaign said they did not refer to Mr. Raja's ethnic background, and that the references to India -- which includes shots of Mr. Raja with an Indian flag behind him and fliers with a map of India -- were because "that is the country to where Mr. Raja has outsourced jobs."