The 2010 death of West Virginia's longtime political icon, Sen. Robert Byrd, loosed a cascade of political upheaval on the state he'd represented for half a century. The next reverberation will be on Oct. 4, when acting Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin defends his seat in what appears to be the most competitive statewide election in the nation this year.
Mr. Tomblin is a political veteran who assumed the state's top job after 36 years in the West Virginia legislature. His chief challenger is Bill Maloney, a Morgantown businessman making his first run for political office.
In a state that overwhelmingly rejected President Barack Obama at a time when he was at the peak of his popularity, Mr. Maloney has done his best to link the acting governor to the White House. The Republican refers to "the Obama-Tomblin team." Mr. Maloney said he would join the multistate suit challenging the national health care law and criticized the Democrat for failing to make a similar pledge.
National parties have poured money into the contest that will, like recent special elections for House seats in New York and Nevada, inevitably be seized upon by national analysts as one more omen of the political fortunes of the White House. But the rhetoric of the campaign so far has been dominated by state issues, and local analysts and political figures describe this as very much a West Virginia race, rather than a referendum on national issues.
"It's much more local in my part of the state," said Gary Lee Corns, a member of the GOP executive committee in Mr. Tomblin's political base, Logan County, near the state's southwestern corner. "I do think it's going to be a lot closer than some people think, though," he added. "Earl Ray has done a good job of not doing anything extraordinarily liberal."
The Democrat has an array of endorsements, including the state Chamber of Commerce, its largest coal mining trade group, the National Rifle Association, the United Mine Workers of America, as well as the state AFL-CIO.
"I don't feel right now the voters in my part of the state are focused on national issues," said Tracy Dransfield, who chairs the Democratic Party in Monroe County in the state's southeast.
Ms. Dransfield said she had heard more discussion of the state's recent legislative redistricting plan, in which her county lost a delegate seat, than the gubernatorial contest that's attracted national money and attention.
Recent public polling in the state depicts a competitive contest. A survey earlier this month by Public Policy Polling, an independent but Democratic-leaning firm, showed Mr. Tomblin with a 6-point lead, down sharply from his margin in a survey the firm took shortly after the spring primary.
"It's definitely shaping up to be close race," said Tom Jensen, the company's polling director. "Obviously, the key for a Republican in West Virginia is to get 30 to 35 percent of the Democratic vote. Bill Maloney isn't there yet, but I think it's going to go right down to the wire."
The pollster said Mr. Maloney had solidified his Republican base in recent months and also led among the state's independents, a growing share of the West Virginia electorate, though still less numerous than in most states.
Mr. Jensen said one unusual feature of the contest was that while both campaigns have launched negative ads, the voters are not down on the candidates. Mr. Tomblin's approval rating remained at a fairly healthy 50 percent in the recent survey, relatively unchanged from the levels of earlier polls by the company.
"The reason that the race is getting close is that voters have gotten to know Maloney better. Benchmarked against the other states where we're polling, it's a really unusual race. Voters like both of the candidates; they seem to be deciding which candidate they like better."
"It's definitely the premier statewide race of 2011," he added.
Across the country, the only other major statewide elections this fall are governors' races in Kentucky, where Democratic incumbent Gov. Steve Beshear is favored over David Williams, the Republican leader of the state Senate; Louisiana, where incumbent Gov. Bobby Jindal is expected to prevail in an open, multi-candidate primary on Oct. 22; and Mississippi, where Lt. Gov. Phil Bryant, a Republican, is favored over Hattiesburg Mayor Johnny DuPree.
Haley Barbour, the incumbent who briefly explored a presidential bid earlier this year, is barred from seeking another term by the state's Constitution.
Mr. Byrd died on June 28, 2010. Then-Gov. Joe Manchin appointed an aide to fill the seat, then announced that he would run in the special election to fill the final two years of the late senator's term. Mr. Manchin faced John Raese, a businessman he had previously, and easily, defeated for governor. But in a free-spending race, the Republican mounted what appeared for a time to be a surprisingly tough challenge to the popular former governor.
Mr. Manchin ended up winning by a comfortable 10-point margin, after a campaign in which he conspicuously distanced himself from the White House. He said he would have voted against the administration health care bill, and, memorably, aired a commercial in which he fired a rifle bullet through a copy of the environmental legislation known as cap-and-trade that the state's traditionally powerful energy interests had strenuously opposed.
As the state Senate's president pro tempore -- West Virginia doesn't have a lieutenant governor -- Mr. Tomblin assumed the role of acting governor on Nov. 15. He survived a six-person Democratic primary to win the nomination to fill the balance of the original Manchin term. Mr. Maloney defeated a former state secretary of state to secure the GOP nomination.
"We've had so many elections recently that I think some people may be a little bit confused," said Ms. Dransfield, who said the unusual Oct. 4 date of the contest had added to the challenge of spurring voter turnout.
"There's a certain amount of voter fatigue," said Robert Rupp, a professor of history at West Virginia Wesleyan University. "Voter interest seems to be very low. Many people still think [the election] is in November."
"There's no strong ideological difference between the two candidates," he added. "Both are non-charismatic candidates, in contrast to Manchin, who was extremely charismatic."
Mr. Tomblin has a stronger fiscal situation to run on than many incumbents. But perhaps his greatest potential vulnerability is that he has been an incumbent for so long, 36 years in public office compared to the novice challenging him.
"If Maloney wins, it'll be for the simple reason that it's a non-incumbent mood," Mr. Rupp said. "This is a pale copy of the Manchin [versus Raese] race. ... Just like Manchin was late to realize he was in some trouble, Tomblin was late realizing he's in trouble."
He noted that the Democratic commercials had struck a similar theme to the attacks Mr. Manchin employed against his businessman challenger, with recent ads portraying the Republican as an outsider and questioning his Mountain State roots.
Mr. Tomblin presides over a government with a hefty surplus, in contrast to the fiscal situation in many surrounding states. The unemployment rate in August was 8.1 percent, down from a peak of 9.5 percent in October 2010.
National Republican candidates have been rewarded by the state's voters since 2000, when Al Gore fell to George W. Bush. Mr. Bush won again in 2004, and Sen. John McCain bucked the national Democratic landslide, carrying the state for the GOP yet again in 2008. And after the 2010 congressional elections, Republicans ended up with two of the state's three congressional seats in this once solidly Democratic state.
But the GOP has had less luck in local and state contests. In addition to the governor's office, Democrats retain large majorities in both legislative chambers. Mr. Rupp speculated that views on Mr. Obama would cast a longer shadow on state politics next year, when his name will share the ballot with Mr. Manchin and the candidates for a full term for governor.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.