The race for Allegheny County executive will be a competition to project guilt by association.

Before the last primary ballot was counted, D. Raja's campaign was already portraying Rich Fitzgerald, the 12-year veteran of county council, as the heir to an outdated political machine.

"It's going to be easy to show that Rich Fitzgerald is more of the same ... the same old Allegheny County politician," said Mark Harris, Mr. Raja's campaign strategist.

Mr. Fitzgerald's allies were equally intent on tying the Republican Mt. Lebanon commissioner to a governor whose popularity, only months after his landslide victory, has been buffeted by the gale of the state budget crisis and his controversial proposals to solve it.

Advertise with us

"Raja says he's the outsider, but he just spent hundreds of thousands of dollars telling people about the Republican insiders who are backing his campaign," said Mike Mikus, the Fitzgerald campaign manager. "He's allied himself with Tom Corbett and the Tom Corbett policies which are going to result in higher property taxes for the people of Allegheny County."

The political arithmetic is daunting for any Republican running countywide. But despite a two-to-one registration deficit, the GOP has won in two of the last four elections. Jim Roddey, now the county chairman, won the first election for the county executive post in 1999.

In 1995, in the last election under the county's old form of government, the Republican team of Larry Dunn and Bob Cranmer captured the majority on the three-member board of commissioners. Former Commissioner Mike Dawida actually got the most votes in that race, but the GOP couple, who would later have a bitter "divorce," finished second and third to freeze out Mr. Dawida's running mate, Collen Vuono.

Bitter Democratic primary fights helped set the stage for both upsets. Mr. Dawida and Ms. Vuono split the party in wresting their nominations from incumbents Tom Foerster and Pete Flaherty, the uncle of Mr. Fitzgerald's opponent, county Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty.

After a home rule referendum established the executive system, Mr. Dawida was on the ballot again in spring 1999, but was unsuccessful in fending off a challenge from Dr. Cyril H. Wecht.

Advertise with us

That primary wasn't the only source of Democratic tensions. As Mr. Roddey pointed out in a memorable television commercial, Dr. Wecht had feuded with any number of other Democrats in his feisty years in local government. But the primary didn't help.

One of the first questions surrounding this general election is how successful the Democrats will be in avoiding lasting scars from the blows Mr. Flaherty and Mr. Fitzgerald exchanged.

"There's a lesson to be learned there," said Jim Burn, the county and state Democratic chairman. "The party was not able to come back together after those races, and, as a result, the Republicans captured the courthouse."

There were plenty of tough exchanges in a Democratic campaign that seemed to get rougher as it wore on. But both candidates at least paid lip service to unity in their election night remarks. And Mr. Flaherty was quick to post a conciliatory message about his former fore on his campaign website.

"Now as Democrats, we must rally behind him, help him win in November, and move on towards a better tomorrow," it said in part.

Advertise with us

Mr. Burn said the primary was sufficiently divisive that both sides would have to work at restoring party amity. But Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, a Fitzgerald supporter, said he didn't think the race set any new standards for sharp elbows.

"There wasn't that much acrimony ... this was typical of what you get in a competitive race. Both sides have money. They spend it; they go negative. But I don't think there's any problem.''

Mr. Raja also faced a primary opponent, former county councilman Chuck McCullough. But Mr. Raja was never forced to go on the offensive against his underfunded rival. In particular, he resisted the temptation to overtly capitalize on the legal jeopardy Mr. McCullough faces on charges that he used the funds of a former client to make a series of political contributions without her knowledge.

Mr. Harris, the Raja strategist, said the Democratic campaign produced ample openings for the Republican to exploit in the fall, pointing in particular to "the shale shakedown," his term for a fundraising email broadcast by the Flaherty campaign, in which Mr. Fitzgerald issued a call for campaign contributions from the Marcellus Shale industry.

"It got ugly at the end ... . There's plenty out there to paint him into a box," he said of his new opponent. "[And] his campaign is broke, which is helpful."

Advertise with us

Mr. Harris said that while Mr. Roddey's countywide victory was an encouraging omen for any Republican, he viewed the pattern of Mr. Corbett's votes in the county in November as a closer template to the Raja strategy. Mr. Roddey made inroads into Democratic areas such as Pittsburgh's Shadyside and Squirrel Hill areas. Mr. Harris sees more opportunity for his candidate in suburban communities such as Carnegie, Collier and Bridgeville, which helped the governor carry the county over Mr. Onorato in November.

"Raja just looks and is a different kind of candidate," he said.

"That's going to help open doors -- 'Who is this guy?'-- that's going to open up some doors. I think that's going to get us a hearing."

Referring to Mr. Raja's Indian background and his rise to financial success as a businessman here, he said, "The other thing that's fascinating is his immigration story. The country of origin may be different, but it's a classic Western Pennsylvania story."

The novelty of that story, the Republican contends, will reinforce a contrast with a figure whom they will try to portray as an old line, establishment Democrat.

Advertise with us

Mr. Mikus insists that that's a gambit destined for failure.

"There's no way they're going to be able to label him as some kind of tax-and-spend Democrat," he said.

He pointed to Mr. Fitzgerald's identification with issues such as holding the line on property taxes and promoting row office consolidation as credentials that the Democrat will be able to use to project himself as an agent of reform. That policy background, he said, would allow Mr. Fitzgerald to make his own cross-party inroads.

"This isn't a campaign that will concentrate just on certain areas," he said. "You'll see that Rich will do better in some Republican areas than other Democrats have."

Both sides see a big money race though neither shared financial specifics.

Advertise with us

"We're still figuring our budget and it's going to be a very expensive race," said Mr. Mikus.

"I'm confident that one way or another ... we will have the resources to win," said Mr. Harris. "We're not going to get massively outspent by anyone."

Emboldened by Mr. Corbett's robust showing in the county, Rob Gleason, the state Republican chairman was already calling Allegheny County one of the GOP's top 2011 priorities even before the primary got under way.

Mr. Burn predicted that the county race would attract a statewide spotlight.

"The race in the fall will be the marquee race in Pennsylvania," he said. "Mr. Raja is going to have everything he needs. Allegheny and Erie are the only consistently performing Democratic counties left in the west," he said. "They want to flip Allegheny because they're thinking about next year. It's also about knocking out Barack Obama and Bob Casey in 2012."