Two businessmen-turned-politicians, one a veteran of county government, another a relative newcomer to politics, will battle to become Allegheny County's third chief executive.

Former county council President Rich Fitzgerald won a solid, surprisingly easy, victory over county Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty to win the Democratic nomination while D. Raja, a Mt. Lebanon commissioner, captured the GOP standard over Chuck McCullough, a former county councilman whose underfunded campaign was burdened by a pending criminal trial.

On a soggy, raw election day, a scant 23 percent of the county's Democrats turned out to vote while just over 20 percent of the Republicans cast ballots.

State Rep. Chelsa Wagner, D-Beechview, equaled the votes of her two opponents combined as she cruised to victory in the Democratic contest for county controller. She will face Robert Howard, a retired business executive who was unopposed for the Republican nomination.

Advertise with us

Darlene Harris, Pittsburgh City Council president, won a tight battle over Vince Pallus, a party-endorsed candidate strongly supported by Mayor Luke Ravenstahl's administration in the North Side district. The collective results of the five Democratic council contests were a disappointment for the mayor. His allies had hoped that the council contests, in which all of the incumbents faced challengers, would produce a more pliant legislative branch after years of tense relations on the fifth floor of the City-Council Building.

In a county with a Democratic tradition and a 2-to-1 registration edge, Mr. Fitzgerald starts the executive race to November as the clear front-runner. But Republicans have won Allegheny County before. In Mr. Raja, an Indian immigrant with an all-American success story as a high-tech entrepreneur, the GOP has a credible candidate to recapture the seat that Dan Onorato wrested from GOP Chairman Jim Roddey eight years ago.

Like Mr. Raja, Mr. Fitzgerald dipped into the personal funds he accumulated in founding a successful business to overcome the challenge from his opponent, the controller and heir to one of the most potent names in the region's political history.

Speaking to supporters shortly after 11 p.m., Mr. Fitzgerald said he felt like Jimmy Stewart in the movie "It's a Wonderful Life."

"When he got in trouble he found out he had so many good friends that stood with him."

Advertise with us

With him on IBEW Hall stage were family members, including his wife, Kathy, their eight children, and his parents, Pat and Dick Fitzgerald.

His Democratic colleagues from county council, members of Allegheny County's state House and Senate delegations and labor leaders were also on hand, many swinging their "Fitzburgh" T-shirts like Terrible Towels.

Mr. Fitzgerald said his plans were to "rest up for a day or two and then hit the trail again, unifying the party, unifying the region and going forward on efforts to hold down taxes and streamline government."

Campaign Manager Mike Mikus said that the first challenge the campaign had to overcome was the name recognition advantage that Mr. Flaherty had. Once the campaign was able to build up Mr. Fitzgerald's name recognition, it worked on "a good ground game."

"We knocked on thousands of doors, we made 150,000 phone calls, and we had the polls covered today," he said.

Advertise with us

Strong labor support was the key, Mr. Mikus said. Labor organizations that endorsed Mr. Fitzgerald had volunteers who were able to go out and help the campaign.

Mr. Flaherty had called his rival to offer his congratulations shortly after 10 p.m.

Speaking to supporters at the AE Stage on the North Shore, he thanked his family and said he planned to complete his second term as controller.

"Now we move on, God bless you all," Mr. Flaherty said.

At about the same time, Mr. Raja was speaking to his supporters at the Radisson Hotel in Green Tree.

Advertise with us

After his 9-year-old daughter, Isana, stood on an orange crate to introduce him, Mr. Raja said, "Tonight's victory is the next step in a long and difficult journey to bring a new direction to Allegheny County.

"We cannot sit idly and watch the legacy squandered by slow decline."

He contended the region's unemployment rate, the decline in flights out of Pittsburgh International Airport, the cuts in bus service and an increase in debt were evidence of the county's decline and the reason the historically Democratic county needs new leadership.

He framed the fall election as a "clear choice between the past and the future."

"It's a choice between an outsider who has spent his life creating jobs and solving problems and an insider who represents the politics of the past," he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Raja said his campaign would be focused on not just Republicans, but also Democrats, Independents and people who don't usually vote.

His wife, Neeta, is among the first Democrats he has persuaded.

"It took this campaign to get Neeta, who's a lifelong registered Democrat, to change to Republican."

Throughout the campaign, Mr. Raja did not take advantage by capitalizing on the criminal charges that Mr. McCullough is scheduled to face in a September trial. The overwhelming result in the GOP race demonstrated that he didn't need to.

Mr. McCullough, who watched the returns in private, could not be reached for comment. But there were intriguing suggestions that he might be the recipient of an unexpected consolation prize.

Advertise with us

Some conservatives circulated an email before the voting urging like-minded activists to write in Mr. McCullough's name for the nomination for district attorney, an office that no other Republican had sought.

It was impossible to immediately determine whether the insurgent email campaign had been successful, or, for that matter, whether Mr. McCullough would be interested in the nomination if it were available to him. With nearly all of the votes tabulated, the Republican prosecutor's spot had attracted more than 1,400 write-in votes -- more than four times as many as were recorded in any other countywide GOP race.

It would take at least 500 write-in votes to qualify for the nomination. Mark Wolosik, the county elections director, said it would be days before the write-ins are examined and fully tabulated. But the email effort creates the bizarre possibility that Mr. McCullough would have the opportunity of running against incumbent Stephen Zappala, the man whose office is prosecuting him on charges that he used an elderly client's funds to make political donations without her knowledge.

Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato, who mingled in the crowd at Mr. Fitzgerald's victory rally, said his longtime ally ran a flawless primary campaign. "He was organized, had a clear message and he got the vote out," Mr. Onorato said. "Rich worked his butt off. I've never seen anyone work as hard as Rich and his family."

The Democratic race for executive got off to a slow start as potential candidates waited for a signal on the intentions of Mr. Onorato. The incumbent had the option of seeking a third term in the courthouse after his overwhelming loss to Gov. Tom Corbett last November.

Advertise with us

He kept his decision making to himself until his mid-January announcement that he would not seek another term. By then, Mr. Flaherty had announced that he would seek the top job regardless of the incumbent's plans.

Mr. Fitzgerald's campaign had tested the value of the endorsements he enjoyed from much of the region's Democratic hierarchy. In a closely fought early spring skirmish, he narrowly defeated Mr. Flaherty in a vote of the party's committee members. He also won the support of the Allegheny County Labor Council, along with several major individual unions such as the United Steelworkers.