In the twin races atop Allegheny County ballots Tuesday, candidates for county executive have had the challenge of trying to inspire voters with talk of retrenchment and belt-tightening.
And in the battle for public attention, candidates in the hundreds of municipal, judicial and school board contests have been vying with a state budget crisis, the first stirrings of the 2012 presidential race and a spring filled with dramatic international developments. The result has been a relatively low-key primary season, dominated by the realities of tighter budgets rather than the lofty ambitions and promises that animate campaigns in better economic times.
"You know, for an old gal I get around a lot; I'm on a lot of boards and committees," said former mayor Sophie Masloff. "I've never seen such disinterest in my whole life as in this primary ... they just tune this right out. It's very discouraging."
In the executive race, the perennial issues of property assessments and transportation have occupied a central role. While details of their plans differ, both Republican and Democratic candidates have pledged to enlist the governor and the Legislature in finding comprehensive statewide solutions to both. But a Harrisburg establishment struggling with its own daunting budget problems has shown no immediate inclination to come to the rescue.
Allegheny County Democrats also face a choice on their nominee in the controller's race. State Rep. Chelsa Wagner, D-Beechview, has the endorsement of the party organization in a three-way competition with Valerie McDonald Roberts, the county's real estate manager, and George Matta, a Rivers Casino executive who is also a former clerk of courts. Robert Howard, a former North Allegheny school board member, is unopposed for the GOP ballot spot.
County voters also will choose nominees for state and local judicial seats, and hundreds of municipal and school board nominations. In the city of Pittsburgh, five council races will test the clout of Luke Ravenstahl's administration along with the power of the party organization. All five council incumbents, four of whom are typically at odds with the administration, were denied the support of elected Democratic committee members.
The Democratic executive race also will be a test of institutional strength. Rich Fitzgerald, the former county council president, narrowly defeated Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty for the party endorsement. The businessman, an ally of incumbent Executive Dan Onorato, who chose not to seek re-election, also is supported by the Allegheny County Labor Council.
Mr. Flaherty entered the race with the benefit of the potent political name he inherited from his uncle, the late Pittsburgh Mayor Pete Flaherty, and his father, Jim Flaherty, a former county commissioner and Commonwealth Court judge.
In the final days of their face-off, both candidates maintained that they were leading in their internal polling. Aides to Mr. Flaherty said they enjoyed a solid, double-digit advantage. Mr. Fitzgerald insisted his polling showed him with a narrow lead along with a sizable bloc of voters still undecided.
The Republican race pits two atypical candidates. Chuck McCullough is the former county solicitor who emerged as a vocal critic of the Onorato administration from his seat on county council. In a stunning upset, he won that seat despite suspending his 2009 campaign to deal with a controversy over whether he had diverted an elderly widow's funds to make a series of political donations. He insists that one civil court already has cleared his stewardship of the former client's funds. But his oft-delayed criminal trial on the matter is now slated for the fall.
His opponent, D. Raja, is a relative newcomer to politics but has won the support of many senior Republicans. In part that's because of his own credentials as a Mt. Lebanon commissioner and an entrepreneur who built a successful high-tech business, and in part because of GOP officials' concerns about Mr. McCullough's legal jeopardy.
The county's assessment system, now under a court order to produce new valuations, has been a chronic and consistently controversial issue for more than a decade. This contest continues that trend.
Mr. Fitzgerald insists that if he were elected, he would not send out tax bills containing new assessment figures unless other counties were also forced to move to a similar regular assessment system. But that course would fly in the face of a decade of litigation. Asked what he would do if courts continue to insist on the new assessment regime, he said, "Then we'll have our own constitutional crisis."
Mr. Flaherty has said he too opposes the court-ordered assessments, but would make sure they were implemented fairly.
Mr. McCullough has proposed a detailed taxpayers' bill of rights, designed to protect property owners from unreasonable assessments. If the state or the courts provided no relief, he has threatened to appeal every assessment in the county.
Mr. Raja has joined the chorus against the new property valuation. Citing his endorsements from figures such as Gov. Tom Corbett, he has said he would be well positioned to lobby for statewide action. But the businessman has not offered any specific plans for how he would achieve that goal.
While emphasizing the need for environmental safeguards, all four candidates have embraced drilling for Marcellus Shale gas as at least a partial solution to the county's revenue needs. Despite the broader agreement on drilling, however, the shale issue has sparked some of the more heated exchanges in the closing days of the Democratic race.
Mr. Flaherty has proposed the general concept of a county partnership with drilling firms in an effort to increase its long-term proceeds from gas production on county land. Mr. Fitzgerald, who favors more typical leasing arrangements, has hammered that idea, insisting that it would place taxpayers at the mercy of the fluctuating energy market.
Mr. Flaherty and Mr. Fitzgerald also have clashed on the county's 7 percent drink tax. Mr. Fitzgerald defends the levy as an alternative to an increase in property taxes. Mr. Flaherty has opposed the tax throughout the campaign. But Mr. Fitzgerald has mocked that position, pointing out that the controller had not opposed it in the past and, in fact, had argued against legislation that dropped its rate from 10 percent to the current level.
Beyond the statewide solutions that are the shared elusive goals of all of the executive candidates, however, it's unclear how Mr. Flaherty would come up with the money to replace the levy. Similar questions surround much of the budget rhetoric of the campaign in general.
Mr. Flaherty has criticized the one-time revenue infusions that have helped to balance the county's budget. Mr. Fitzgerald regularly boasts that the county has not raised taxes for 10 years, but noting the budget pressure, he has acknowledged that he could not promise to continue to hold that line. In a replay of the last year's race for governor, however, the candidates have been understandably vague on exactly how the unpleasant fiscal medicine will be applied as the county enters the second decade of its home rule form of government.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.