Responding to Rich Fitzgerald's criticisms of Mark Patrick Flaherty's Marcellus Shale policies, the Flaherty campaign spotlighted a January email in which Mr. Fitzgerald appealed to campaign contributors by portraying himself as the better friend of the drilling industry.
While all of the candidates for Allegheny County executive favor the growing industry's development along with plans to allow drilling on county land, Mr. Fitzgerald has recently stepped up his attacks on a Flaherty proposal to form some sort of investment partnership with gas firms in an effort to reap a higher return for drilling on county property. Mr. Flaherty and Mr. Fitzgerald are running for the Democratic nomination.
A new Fitzgerald television commercial contends that a Flaherty administration would place taxpayers at risk through its drilling policies.
"Favoring gas companies over taxpayers -- that's Mark Flaherty," the television commercial charges.
Suggesting hypocrisy in the attack, the Flaherty campaign supplied reporters with a copy of a fundraising appeal that Mr. Fitzgerald sent to Kathryn Klaber, the president of the Marcellus Shale Coalition, an industry trade group. In the Jan. 27, email, Mr. Fitzgerald portrays himself as the better friend of the drillers while complaining that industry figures had not contributed adequately to his campaign.
In addition to quoting Mr. Fitzgerald's fundraising appeals, the Flaherty campaign noted that Mr. Fitzgerald's campaign manager, Mike Mikus, is also the vice president of a Colorado-based public relations firm whose clients are drawn from the energy industry.
"Twice in a debate on Monday, Mr. Fitzgerald said he would keep the Marcellus Shale industry at 'arm's length,' " David Brown, Mr. Flaherty's press secretary, said in a statement. "His email and actions suggest he has a fuzzy definition of arm's length."
In the email, Mr. Fitzgerald complains about the paucity of contributions he had received from the industry despite his record of support for drilling in the county.
"If you want the leader of this region to be someone who is clueless about natural gas and your industry, continue to sit on your hands. That is exactly what will happen," Mr. Fitzgerald wrote.
"My campaign has gotten next to nothing from Range [Resources], next to nothing from CNX/Consol, next to nothing from Atlas, next to nothing from U.S. Steel. And absolutely nothing from [Chesapeake], Cabot, Talisman or anyone else," Mr. Fitzgerald wrote, referring to some of the more prominent firms in the burgeoning shale exploration.
"I love going to your wine and cheese receptions to hear what a great advocate I am for the natural gas industry, how as a CMU engineer I understand the benefits of natural gas for the environment, global warming, national security, jobs, regional growth, our trade deficit, etc.," he continued. "Well if you like that, stand up for me now. Because if you don't I will be gone in a few months, and the voices you hear won't be your friends."
Ms. Klaber confirmed the authenticity of the message.
"I did receive this unsolicited email from Rich Fitzgerald," she said in an email to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. "The [Marcellus Shale Coalition] receives many solicitations for funds, but has never made a donation to political campaigns. We look forward to working with our next County Executive in Allegheny County, regardless of who that may be."
Campaign contribution reports show that at least some industry officials appear to have responded to Mr. Fitzgerald's heated plea. Mr. Fitzgerald received more than $56,000 from natural gas-related committees and individuals this year -- with several larger contributions received just after the Jan. 27 email. Mr. Flaherty took in about $20,000 from drilling interests during the same period.
The Fitzgerald campaign responded with a statement reiterating its criticism of Mr. Flaherty's concept.
"Flaherty's shrill press release will not change the fact the both candidates are supportive of natural gas drilling that is safe and protects the environment," Olivia Benson, Mr. Fitzgerald's press secretary, said in the statement. "The difference on this issue is that Mark Patrick Flaherty wants the taxpayers to borrow $2.5 billion and pay higher property taxes so he can he can give the money to the drilling companies."
In one discussion of his private-public partnership concept, Mr. Flaherty did suggest that the county might use its lower-cost borrowing ability to invest in drilling on county land. More recently, Mr. Brown, his press secretary, has suggested that the county's investment might come from an agreement to forgo an upfront lease payment in exchange for higher lease payments later on. The campaign has never offered a detailed blueprint of how the idea might be implemented.
Responding to the criticism of Mr. Mikus' energy industry ties, the Fitzgerald camp noted that he is a veteran Democratic operative who played a key role in the campaigns of other Democrats, including U.S. Reps. Mark Critz of Johnstown and Jason Altmire of McCandless. The Fitzgerald release also returned fire on the issue of divided loyalties by pointing out that the Flaherty campaign had employed a fundraising firm that normally deals with Republican clients.
"It's not surprising that Mark Patrick Flaherty shares staff and a P.O. Box with Gov. Tom Corbett, because he fights for gas companies and the taxpayers lose in the end just like Corbett," Ms. Benson said. "Mark Patrick Flaherty's risky scheme to subsidize natural gas companies and his attacks on Rich Fitzgerald are just more examples that he's taking a page out of Tom Corbett's playbook."
The candidates for the Republican nomination for executive, Mt. Lebanon Commissioner D. Raja, and former county Councilman Chuck McCullough, also support the development of gas resources within the county and on county land.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.