None of the four candidates for Allegheny County executive favors a full merger with the city of Pittsburgh. Which may be the only thing they agree on.

Attacks are growing among the candidates as the May 17 primary nears, with Rich Fitzgerald continuing his criticisms of fellow Democrat Mark Patrick Flaherty and Republican Chuck McCullough pointing barbs at everyone, including his opponent D. Raja.

Differences were also shown in their fundraising capacity, as the quartet released their last set of finance reports before the spring election. Leaning on $800,000 in loans to his own campaign, Mr. Fitzgerald spent $1 million to Mr. Flaherty's $712,000 the first four months of the year. Mr. Raja similarly used his $210,000 in self-loans to spend $245,000 against Mr. McCullough, who only put about $1,000 into the race.

On the issues, differences among the four were illustrated in planning for Marcellus Shale development, even though all four men support it as an economy driver.

Advertise with us

Mr. Fitzgerald this week has criticized Mr. Flaherty for a plan to co-develop natural gas sites with private firms, by possibly tapping into $2.5 billion in county borrowing ability. At a forum hosted Friday by the tourism agency VisitPittsburgh, Mr. Fitzgerald repeatedly contended interest on that full amount would come to $150 million annually and force the county into tax increases.

"I'm not going to have a property tax increase by taking on massive amounts of debt," he said at the start of the debate.

Mr. Flaherty, the county controller, called that a distortion, saying he wants to study all ways to wring extra money out of natural gas. "I'm not for investing $2.5 billion. I never said that, and it was a misquote if somebody did that. I'm for maximizing revenues for taxpayers," he said.

Mr. McCullough dismissed an idea by Mr. Raja to take Marcellus Shale proceeds from land at Pittsburgh International Airport, plow it into airport development and lower landing fees. That would mean the county's airport authority would oversee the proceeds, Mr. McCullough said, which "would be the same kind of mistake as using the drink tax to prop up the Port Authority. If we're going to prop up another failed operation like that ... we might as well not even do it."

Two years ago University of Pittsburgh Chancellor Mark Nordenberg released a study urging city-county consolidation, and both county Executive Dan Onorato and Mayor Luke Ravenstahl agreed to the concept. No longer: All four candidates on Friday said they did not support a full merger, though they favored saving money by sharing some services.

In the high-powered Democratic race, Mr. Fitzgerald spent $552,000 to Mr. Flaherty's $451,000 on television advertising. Mr. Raja poured out almost his whole self-financed piggy-bank -- leaving him with just $40,000 on-hand as of Monday -- to beat Mr. McCullough in the primary. Mr. McCullough raised no money, according to his report.