With less than two weeks to go before their primary face-off, the Democratic candidates for Allegheny County executive are sharpening their attacks in person and on the airwaves.

In one new ad, county Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty criticizes his opponent, former county council President Rich Fitzgerald, for once supporting pay increases for county council members while questioning his overall budget policies. The former councilman, meanwhile, continues to run a commercial charging that Mr. Flaherty's proposals for Marcellus Shale development on county land would place taxpayers at risk.

Amid those exchanges, figures close to the Flaherty camp released internal poll numbers that depict the former controller with a substantial, double-digit lead in the race. A spokeswoman for the Fitzgerald campaign dismissed those figures, maintaining that the two-person primary remained a close race.

The new ad from Mr. Flaherty criticizes Mr. Fitzgerald for proposing raises for council members. The Fitzgerald campaign acknowledged the councilman once discussed the desirability of an increase in council's $9,000 annual stipend, but noted that the plan was never pursued and that council pay remains at the same level it was when Mr. Fitzgerald was first elected. The controller's ad also asserts that Mr. Fitzgerald "approved spending $55 million over budget" during his tenure as president.

Advertise with us

The Fitzgerald camp said that claim was simply wrong; every budget approved by council included, as required by law, balanced revenue and spending. Responding to that complaint, David Brown, Mr. Flaherty's press secretary, said the commercial referred to the accumulation of one-time revenue sources, such as funds earmarked for longer-term capital spending, to balance the county's core operating budget.

The Flaherty ad also boasts that he held his own controllers' office spending under budget for the last seven years. That's true as far as it goes, but the Fitzgerald camp pointed out that those budgets actually grew each year so that the office's spending increased from roughly $4.4 million to $6.3 million over that time.

Mr. Fitzgerald's attack ad focuses on a Flaherty proposal to partner with shale gas firms to increase the county's return from prospective drilling on county-owned land. The controller has suggested that by forgoing upfront fees, the county could, over the long run, enjoy substantially more revenue from gas drilling proceeds. The ad refers to the concept as "a Republican plan."

The Fitzgerald ad also contends that Mr. Flaherty would place the county at risk by borrowing more than $2 billion to subsidize gas companies. In an interview earlier this year, Mr. Flaherty did suggest that the county could borrow funds to invest in drilling operations on its land, but a spokesman said earlier this week that that was just one possibility for a public-private partnership. Rather than borrow money, he said the county might also reap more revenue over time by agreeing to forgo an upfront payment for a drilling lease.

The Flaherty campaign did not respond to the specifics of the Fitzgerald critique but did take umbrage at the ad's depiction of it as "a Republican plan."

Advertise with us

"Rich Fitzgerald shot a hole in his own credibility with an attack ad that calls Mark Patrick Flaherty a Republican," Mr. Brown, the press secretary, said in a statement. "The attack ad against Mark is the desperate tactic of an opponent who knows he's high double-digits down with the election right around the corner."

He alluded to internal poll results, disclosed by a figure allied with the campaign, which said that, as of last week, Mr. Flaherty enjoyed an 18 percentage-point lead over the former councilman. Mr. Brown confirmed the existence of the internal poll but would not release its full results.

Olivia Benson, Mr. Fitzgerald's press secretary, scoffed at the reported results.

"Mark Patrick Flaherty knows this is a very close race," she said in a statement. "Why else would he be running negative television commercials?"