Candidates for Allegheny County executive discussed campaign tactics and Marcellus Shale gas drilling policies Wednesday as their primary campaigns entered the final two weeks.
All four candidates support the development of natural gas drilling in the county, but the two Democrats, county Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty and Rich Fitzgerald, the former county council president, clashed on the best way to exploit the resource to shore up the county's finances.
Before a meeting of the Rotary Club, Mr. Flaherty complained that Mr. Fitzgerald had aired an ad criticizing his call to partner with private companies drilling on county-owned land rather than pursue a more typical lease arrangement.
"I've been a firm believer in positive campaigning," Mr. Flaherty said. "Unfortunately my opponent began airing a negative ad just yesterday," he said.
Mr. Fitzgerald defended his tactics, saying that his criticism of Mr. Flaherty's proposal pointed to a substantive difference between them.
"It's important to talk about what we want to do," he said. While Mr. Fitzgerald called the controller's proposal, "a Republican idea to risk your tax dollars," he said, "I've made no personal attacks against Mark."
Chuck McCullough, the former county solicitor and councilman who is vying with D. Raja, a Mt. Lebanon commissioner, for the GOP nomination, vowed that he would not engage in negative attacks even to defend himself against such tactics.
"Not only do I believe it, I've lived it," he said. "Not only will I not run negative attacks, but I will not retaliate if it's done against me."
Mr. McCullough noted that he had been the victim of political attacks in the past, an apparent reference to the controversy over charges that he used the funds of an elderly client, without her knowledge, to make a series of campaign contributions. The former councilman contends that a civil court review has already exonerated his conduct in the case, but he faces a criminal trial shortly after the May 17 primary.
In answer to a question from the audience, Mr. Raja said that he agreed that campaigns have become too negative. He has yet to directly raise the charges against his opponent on the campaign trail. One of the questions hovering over the GOP primary is whether he will continue that reticence or whether his campaign will turn a spotlight on his rival's legal jeopardy in the campaign's closing stretch. Four years ago, after the controversy over the donations arose, Mr. McCullough still managed a comfortable victory for the council seat he resigned to pursue the executive job.
The latest dispute between the two Democrats centers on how they would structure any business deal to drill for shale gas on county property, such as the hundreds of acres surrounding Pittsburgh International Airport. Mr. Flaherty has suggested that by forming some sort of partnership with drillers, the county could reap a much higher return than would be available though a more standard drilling lease.
At the forum and in a new television ad, Mr. Fitzgerald contends that such an approach could make the county liable for drilling mishaps as well as leaving its eventual financial return vulnerable to fluctuations in energy prices.
Speaking after the event at the Omni William Penn Hotel, Downtown, Mr. Flaherty contended that Mr. Fitzgerald's approach might provide a needed short-term boost to county coffers but would shortchange taxpayers compared to the potential of a long-term partnership. His spokesman, David Brown, said the county would not necessarily have to come up with the money to invest in a partnership but could gain a better long-term stake in drilling returns by, for example, forgoing an upfront payment from the driller in exchange for a larger share of gas revenues over the life of the Marcellus drilling.
"Once our plan is in place," Mr. Flaherty's website states, "I will push to develop this asset either through a business coalition in which we will benefit as a primary stakeholder or as the landowner that will maximize our potential revenue from fees and taxes."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.