The race for the Democratic nomination for Allegheny County controller features three candidates who are willing to walk away from better-paying jobs to become the monitor of county government spending under the cloud of a potential multimillion-dollar deficit.
All three candidates -- Valerie McDonald Roberts, George Matta and Chelsa Wagner -- said they view the role of the county's chief financial officer as an opportunity to work with elected officials and department heads in ways that will benefit taxpayers. They differ, however, in how best to go about it.
Ms. Wagner, 33, who represents the 22nd District in the state Legislature, said she would champion transparency and collaboration, ensuring that the county is operating efficiently.
"All governments have major challenges," said Ms. Wagner, who lives in Brookline and is the daughter of 19th Ward Chairman Pete Wagner and the niece of state Auditor General Jack Wagner. "I see a trend from the national level on down, with more and more responsibilities being pushed down to the local level. It is a crisis, but I believe it's also an opportunity for us to develop new methods of collaboration and seek out efficiencies."
Mr. Matta, 54, of White Oak, is a former county clerk of courts and served two terms as mayor of Duquesne. A former businessman, he currently is an executive with the Rivers Casino, a combination of government and private service that he said makes him best-suited for the duty of overseeing spending.
"I'm the only one of the candidates who has been an executive in government, when I was the mayor of Duquesne. And before that I was the city controller," he said. "So I sat in a position in government very similar to what the county controller needs to do. Being the mayor of a small town, especially a distressed community, is extremely difficult because resources are not readily available."
Ms. McDonald Roberts, 55, of Churchill, is the daughter of the late 13th Ward Chairman Euzell "Bubby" Hairston, and has served as a city councilwoman, a Pittsburgh Public Schools director, elected county recorder of deeds and currently is manager of the county real estate department. She calls her campaign for county controller "a natural progression."
"I feel that I have made a difference in Allegheny County in this level of government, and I would like to continue to make an imprint," she said. "My mantra has always been 'excellence in government.' ... It's basically a combination of all my experiences. Legislative, administrative, private industry."
The job of Allegheny County controller has proven to be one of the most powerful and high-profile positions in the region. The past two controllers -- Dan Onorato and incumbent Mark Patrick Flaherty -- have used it as a platform to run for county executive.
The race is part of the May 17 primary. Bob Howard, 60, an activist and former PPG official, is unopposed on the ballot for the Republican nomination.
All three Democratic candidates embrace the county controller's role as a watchdog, yet while Ms. Wagner said she prefers to create a cooperative environment at the head of county government, Ms. McDonald Roberts stressed that her priority will be getting the job done.
"Temperament is important," Ms. McDonald Roberts said. "I understand how the office can facilitate government. But I also understand how it can cause friction and problems. Do you want to make a splash, do you want to be an advocate? Or do you go in there and do what the people elected you to do? You're not there to be the friend of everybody."
"You have to be a watchdog. It's the traditional role and it's very appropriate," Ms. Wagner said. "But you also have to be an advocate.
"The relationships I have forged in Harrisburg would be a real advantage. The role of the controller is to point out where there are inefficiencies in government. But you're also very well positioned to point out what is right. Most people are concerned about how each penny of their money is being spent. But they also want to know that different programs, different departments of government are working."
Mr. Matta said the independence of the office is crucial, but he believes there is plenty of room for cooperation in county government.
"It's not only the office of budgeting, it's how you deal with the other departments and how you deal with the interactions of them, the funding of them, and the fairness of them," he said. "The controller has to make sure that every dollar and cent is spent right, every contract that goes out is bid correctly, that it has provisions to protect taxpayers.
"And at the back end, the controller has to make sure the work is done in the time frame. The controller doesn't necessarily have to find what is being done wrong, but rather where there are better ways and techniques to do things. It doesn't have to be adversarial."
Mr. Matta said he would focus on the positive aspects of his audits -- that is, making improvements, rather than pounding away at what is wrong. And he would make the process an ongoing one, as opposed to something that only comes around every few years.
"What worries me the most is when after an audit is done, we don't hear any follow-up," he said. "If you just throw an audit out there and have no follow-up, it puts us in the position of coming back four years later and doing another audit. My audits are going to look at what the problems are and what dollars are involved in the solution. Correct inefficiencies, if they exist."
Ms. Wagner hopes to capitalize on new technologies and a growing cooperation between county and city governments. She also hopes to facilitate the relationship between government and businesses.
"I hear over and over again how painfully slow the contracting process is. Human service providers, civil engineers, and you even hear it from municipalities," she said. "I think timely payments to our contractors is very important to our taxpayers because it's an obvious inefficiency, and it's something that is going to prevent the kind of competition that we need."
Ms. McDonald Roberts agreed that the controller must improve "the process of good government with the county executive and county council," but she said the government roles are clear and do not need to be redefined.
"The controller watches the books and counts the beans, to make sure that tax dollars are being used according to their purpose and efficiently," she said. "The controller doesn't work for the county executive or the county council. He or she works with them.
"I would look for more documentation and some online initiatives. But it's a waste of time to re-invent the wheel. Look at what you have and what has been done. Establish short-term goals and keep track of whether your recommendations are being implemented."
The candidates also agreed that they could manage the office on the $6 million it currently gets.
"I would try to reduce it," said Ms. McDonald Roberts. "Can I live within that budget? Yes, absolutely. But the goal is to try to shrink it a little more, without sacrificing quality and without undue hardship on people."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.