Another member of Pittsburgh City Council is attempting to make the jump to the magisterial district court bench, going up against three other names that should be known to Grant Street cognoscenti.
District judge seats go empty relatively rarely, so when Squirrel Hill's longtime district judge Nathan Firestone reached mandatory retirement age, the field piled up quickly. It includes former council president Doug Shields, who is leaving the legislative body after eight years in office, and three attorneys: Dan Butler, Hugh McGough and Joe Weinroth.
Mr. Butler, 59, of Squirrel Hill, who works out of the Allegheny County solicitor's office, is a federally funded attorney representing disadvantaged parents. He was a magistrate in Pittsburgh Municipal Court for 11 years back when mayors Sophie Masloff and Tom Murphy were still in charge of appointments. It is now staffed on a revolving basis by district judges citywide.
In during his time at Municipal Court, Mr. Butler said, judges would not be considered "who were not an attorney. That is calculated for rural areas, not a major city" like Pittsburgh, where district judges can hear thousands of criminal, real estate, family, traffic and small claims disputes per year.
"Politics doesn't belong in the courtroom. Determinations should be made by independent, courageous standards rather than the vagaries of politics," he said.
Mr. McGough, 55, of Shadyside, is an attorney in private practice and court-appointed federal mediator whose firm represents the Citizen Police Review Board. He was an assistant solicitor for city government for nine years and has served on the Pittsburgh AIDS Task Force and other charities.
"It is important to ensure the East End continues to have a district judge who is a hard-working, experienced attorney, who is rooted in the community with a good knowledge of its many people and elements," he said in an interview.
Mr. McGough ran unsuccessfully for the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court bench in 2009. Speaking about the current race, he said, "just because it is a lower court legally does not mean it is a lower calling. It is as, if not more, important, because more people have contact with magisterial district judges than any other part of the court system."
With the statewide court system facing budget woes, Mr. Firestone's seat was briefly considered for elimination early this year, before local officials argued it would put too much pressure on the Municipal Court rotation. Once the seat was saved, Mr. Shields was free to run for it, attempting to follow former council colleagues Gene Ricciardi and Jim Motznik onto the district bench.
Mr. Shields, 57, of Squirrel Hill, worked for law firms for nine years as a litigation paralegal before starting work as then-Councilman Bob O'Connor's chief of staff in 1992. He took over the council seat in 2003. He became a vocal critic of the Ravenstahl administration, taking on the mayor on issues such as lost and stolen guns, electronic billboards and a city ban on Marcellus Shale drilling.
"I am the only candidate in the race who has conceived of, written and had enacted original legislation to the benefit of city residents, that has been tested time and again in courts of law," Mr. Shields said.
In response to questions about his lack of a law degree or his decades in notoriously rough city politics, he said the district court "is a very natural place for a former council member to go to ... What counts is dispute resolution capability and that's all you do [on council], and I've been doing it for 19 years. Every time the phone rings there's a dispute on the other end of the line."
Mr. Weinroth, 52, of Squirrel Hill, is a former Republican candidate for mayor in 2005 and the Common Pleas bench in 2007. He has been a lawyer for 28 years.
"I have the experience, the temperament and the ability to do the job as well, if not better, than the other candidates," he said.
"I have an open mind and will be listening to cases -- not automatically ruling one way because of what someone has done. I'll be a judge taking an interest in the people before him."
Mr. Shields is running solely as a Democrat while the other three candidates are cross-filed in both parties. Should Mr. Shields win the Democratic primary May 17, that sets up another contested battle against the Republican nominee in November. Alternatively, should Mr. Butler, Mr. McGough or Mr. Weinroth take both primary ballots next month, they will have easy sailing come the municipal election.
The seat oversees Park Place, Point Breeze, Regent Square, Shadyside, Squirrel Hill and Swisshelm Park.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.