By his reckoning, Charles McCullough is the only person who has taken oaths of office in both the executive and legislative branches of Allegheny County's government, under its decade-old incarnation.
After serving as solicitor under former executive Jim Roddey, he managed a stunning victory in the 2007 race for an at-large spot on county council. With four years as a goad and critic of the current administration under his belt, he resigned that seat to seek the top job for himself. But to fulfill that ambition, he faces two big challenges -- the voters and the courts. With a modest, grass-roots campaign, he will have to overcome better-funded rivals in the Republican primary and, potentially, the general election.
And then there's the 52-page grand jury presentment in which he's accused of diverting the funds of a 90-year-old widow to make political and charitable contributions without her knowledge. The Upper St. Clair Republican contends that one court has already given its imprimatur to his stewardship of the estate of the late Shirley Jordan. But the district attorney's office disagrees. And weeks after the primary, his oft-delayed trial on multiple counts of misusing the client's money is scheduled finally to go forward. So, in addition to making his political case on the issues, Mr. McCullough is asking GOP voters to choose a nominee at best distracted by, and at worst, about to be convicted of, criminal charges.
The accusations against Mr. McCullough, which first arose before his council election, have not deterred him from assuming an aggressive legislative role.
"I said to myself, 'I'm going to make this count,' " he said, describing his reaction after he won the at-large seat despite the fact that he had suspended his campaigning in the face of the reports that he had misused a widow's funds.
On council he's been the most outspoken critic of the administration of County Executive Dan Onorato on issues including assessments, the drink tax and transit funding. He's taken the administration to court and won in a challenge to the use of the drink tax revenue. Mr. Onorato had wanted to use the proceeds both for the Port Authority and for more general transportation purposes such as road and bridge repairs, but in a 2009 ruling, a judge accepted Mr. McCullough's argument that the proceeds should be earmarked strictly for mass transit.
He joined Braddock residents in protesting the UPMC decision to close the community hospital but was unsuccessful in legal challenges to the hospital plans. Mr. McCullough said he did not accept his stipend as a council member for his first 18 months in office but then decided to take it to help support the varied litigation he's pressed as a member. He was also rebuffed in a recent attempt to ask the court to halt the county's pending reassessment.
County Councilman Vince Gastgeb, a fellow Republican who says he is neutral in the GOP primary, offered a positive review of Mr. McCullough's performance on council.
"He brings issues to the fore that most people wouldn't think of," he said. "You might not agree, but there is a compelling logic to the thought process on these issues."
Rich Fitzgerald, the former council president who, like Mr. McCullough, resigned to seek the executive post, has a dimmer view of the McCullough tenure.
"He's ineffective," the Democrat said. "He can sound good on the surface, but he doesn't get things done."
Reminded of Mr. McCullough's success in the Port Authority revenue litigation, he said, "Yeah, but what did that do? He hurt the county; he kept us from using that money for roads and bridges."
Jim Roddey, now the chairman of the county Republican Party, chose Mr. McCullough as his chief legal adviser during his term as executive. He praised his performance in that post, but offered a more mixed review of his role on council.
"As solicitor he did an excellent job ... he was very knowledgeable about municipal law," Mr. Roddey said "He's well-informed, articulate, [with] the same aggressive style, sometimes to a fault. ... He generally has been sort of the person who's led the opposition and done it in an aggressive manner -- sometimes shrill, always well-informed."
Mr. McCullough promises a similarly aggressive style in the higher office he claims he's confident that he will win. He said he would right the county's budget ills by looking at options to privatize government operations including the airport, Alcosan and one or two of the county's Kane Hospital units. Despite the courts, he insists he would fight the orders to reassess the county by mounting every conceivable legal roadblock.
While he wishes the Port Authority had never been created, he believes that its budget ills make it a poor candidate for privatization in the near term. He said that rather than try to stretch existing funding over 18 months, he would precipitate a crisis, possibly including bankruptcy, to force a state solution to transportation funding.
But before having a chance to do so, he would first have to beat his indictment. Indeed, any consideration of Mr. McCullough as a candidate inevitably focuses on his legal issues. So far, his GOP opponent, Mt. Lebanon commissioner D. Raja, hasn't directly raised the issue, but he's noted that he is a candidate without baggage.
"I haven't run from this problem," Mr. McCullough told his Robert Morris audience at a candidates' forum. I consider it to be political bean ball ... they only throw bean balls at people they think are a threat."
"This problem" came to light just before the 2007 primary, when former Post-Gazette reporter Dennis Roddy disclosed that Mr. McCullough had distributed a series of $10,000 contributions, all drawn from the funds of Shirley Jordan, a widow for whom he held power of attorney, to Republican candidates. Mrs. Jordan's funds were also used for a $10,000 donation to Catholic Charities, which was then headed by Mr. McCullough's wife, Patricia McCullough, who has since been elected a Commonwealth Court judge.
In an interview with Mr. Roddy, who has since taken a job as an aide to Republican Gov. Tom Corbett, Mrs. Jordan denied knowing anything about the contributions. Mrs. Jordan repeated the same account in a subsequent interview with a district attorney's investigator recounted in the presentment.
Mr. McCullough maintained that he had discussed all of the contributions with his client, who had once been diagnosed with mild dementia. Mr. McCullough repeated that assertion in an accounting of the Jordan estate that was ordered by Orphan's Court after the reports came to light.
When asked about the case, Mr. McCullough is quick to produce a copy of the order from the Orphan's Court's August 2008 review that suggests that all of the estate's assets were in order. He maintains that the court order represents a full exoneration of his conduct. By the time of the court review, however, the controversial contributions had already been returned to the estate. Prosecutors will argue that the Orphan's Court's approval of the 2008 accounting of the assets is irrelevant to the criminal charges that he misapplied the assets in 2007 when he sought to distribute them to political allies.
Mr. McCullough is also charged with making a false report over a complaint he made to Upper St. Clair police accusing Mr. Roddy, the former reporter, of harassing Mrs. Jordan during the initial interview. The presentment says that an investigation found Mr. McCullough's accusation against Mr. Roddy to have been false.
Asked about that aspect of the charges, Mr. McCullough expressed confidence that it too would be dismissed.
If that seems optimistic, consider the history of his last race. While his name remained on the ballot, Mr. McCullough had suspended campaigning in the face of the controversy. The campaign of his opponent, Kevin Acklin, decided that there was no need to repeat charges that had already been the subject of abundant headlines. But on election night, to the shock of both camps, Mr. McCullough won, 25,677 to 19,517.
That lesson is unlikely to be lost on the campaign aides of his opponent, Mr. Raja, as they weigh their strategy, and the question of whether to go negative against his rival in the closing weeks of this campaign.
Through it all, Mr. Mc-Cullough says he will prevail.
And if he doesn't?
"If I don't win, I've got other things on my bucket list," he said. "I like the idea of being a community activist. It's applying my legal skills in a different way."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.