While each portrayed himself as an advocate of fiscal austerity, the two Democratic candidates for Allegheny County executive conceded Tuesday that they could not guarantee that county taxes would not increase during the next administration.

Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty cites his record as a fiscal watchdog as a core qualification for the county's top job, and Rich Fitzgerald, until recently the county council president, has made a campaign mantra of the fact that county property taxes have not gone up for 10 years. But each of them acknowledged that continuing cuts at the state and federal level could cast a cloud over a budget heavily dependent on those outside revenue streams.

"No, I couldn't make that promise because you have to see where the revenues come from," Mr. Fitzgerald said when asked whether the county could be certain of continuing its record of holding the line on the realty tax. But, he emphasized, "My consistent attitude and my consistent policy within county government has been to lower property taxes."

Mr. Flaherty contended that he would be a more vigilant guardian of the tax line.

Advertise with us

"This is where we differ," he said. "Instead of looking at the revenue end first, you need to look at the expenditure end first ... so we don't have to raise taxes."

Speaking to Post-Gazette editors and reporters, the two Democrats also clashed over another fiscal issue, the drink tax enacted during current Executive Dan Onorato's administration.

Mr. Flaherty repeated his criticism that the tax falls too heavily on one industry, and said that it should be replaced as part of a broader agreement on transportation funding at the state level. He stopped short of calling for an immediate repeal of the 7 percent levy on poured drinks, however, noting that the county needs the revenue it provides until a more comprehensive solution for transportation is achieved.

Mr. Fitzgerald defended the tax, contending that without it property taxes would have had to be boosted to provide the local match for Port Authority funding.

The former council president, who had to resign his seat to run for the executive post, characterized Mr. Flaherty's vocal opposition to the tax as a campaign conversion. He noted that the controller had never spoken out in opposition to the levy at the time it was enacted. In fact, he said, Mr. Flaherty had opposed the 2008 decision to lower the drink tax rate from 10 percent to 7 percent.

Advertise with us

Mr. Flaherty defended his stand.

"At the time I thought it was the wrong solution to the problem, that we should have stayed up there until a more broad-based solution was enacted," he said. "I think it was a quick fix."

Mr. Fitzgerald also sniped at his opponent's credentials as a budget cutter, pointing out that he had sought a major increase in controller's office funding in the county's 2010 budget. Mr. Flaherty countered that his department had taken on new duties after the consolidation of the county's row offices.