The Democratic candidates for Allegheny County executive disagreed Saturday on the wisdom of drilling a transit tunnel under the Allegheny River and the prospects of the Port Authority project.
County Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty said he had favored a different route for the costly and controversial light rail extension and remained concerned about its operating costs. Rich Fitzgerald, until recently the county council president, portrayed it as a key ingredient to a revitalized North Shore as well as an important first step to potential transit expansion.
The two Democrats discussed the Port Authority as well as their familiar disagreements on assessments and taxes at the culmination of a day-long candidates' forum sponsored by the Western Pennsylvania Black Political Assembly at East Liberty's Pittsburgh Obama 6-12 school. They followed separate panels of candidates vying for spots on the Pittsburgh school board, city council and county controller.
Organizers said the Republican candidates for executive and controller were also invited to the forum but none appeared. Representation was also sparse among the candidates of both major parties in the panels focusing on the school board and Pittsburgh City Council.
While noting that neither he nor his opponent had been among the decision-makers for the transit tunnel, Mr. Fitzgerald predicted that opinions on the much criticized project would change after its scheduled opening next year. And in the longer term, he said, the new beachhead for the light rail line would allow it to expand further north and west, enhancing both the region's transportation system and its overall approach to intergovernmental cooperation.
Mr. Flaherty said that at a time when the Port Authority was in such dire financial straits it was a mistake to talk about expanding the system further. Mr. Flaherty countered that riders and communities beyond Allegheny County's borders already profit from the system and that intergovernmental cooperation could lead to economies of scale to strengthen overall transportation finances
Mr. Flaherty repeated his opposition to the drink tax that Mr. Fitzgerald had supported, although he did not specify how he would have dealt with the transit revenue shortfall it was designed to bridge.
Neither Democrat, however, had any new prescriptions for the more immediate cash crunch that has led to Port Authority layoffs and a significant contraction of its route system. Mr. Fitzgerald said that a vote against the drink tax would have been an implicit stand in favor of an increase in property taxes. Both said that a more comprehensive solution to transportation funding would depend on action at the state level.
They also looked to Harrisburg for a solution to the property reassessment system that they have differed on. Both said that a statewide assessment would end a system in which Allegheny County is held to stricter standards than its neighbors. In the past Mr. Flaherty has said that while he opposes a reassessment in principle, court rulings have left the county no alternative and that it should proceed with a fair and transparent appeals system while the county continues to seek systemic change from the state. Mr. Fitzgerald reiterated his adamant opposition.
The executive contenders followed an amiable discussion among two of the Democratic contenders for controller, Valerie McDonald Roberts and George Matta, and Khari Mosley, who appeared as a surrogate for his wife, state Rep. Chelsa Wagner. They agreed on the need to strengthen contracting opportunities for women and minority owned business, although Ms. McDonald Roberts, saying that she would not pander to her audience, said it would be unrealistic to commit to a 50 percent target for such contracts.
Mr. Matta agreed but suggested that contracting equity could be encouraged by providing an internet calendar of every contract expected to be bid in the coming quarter.
The panel for council candidates was intended as a citywide forum, but it ended up focusing on the issues of District 9, which includes the East End communities surrounding the school. Council President Darlene Harris, who represents District 1, and District 7 Councilman Patrick Dowd were the only other contenders who showed up. District 9's Councilman Ricky Burgess defended his tenure against criticisms from challengers Lucille Prater-Holliday and Phyllis Copeland Mitchell, both of whom said that the district's next representative needed to seek more community input. Mr. Burgess said that the highlights of his first term included his support for the Pittsburgh Initiative to Reduce Crime and his successful push to revamp the way community development grant funding is distributed.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.