Tonya Payne's pitch to a few dozen regulars at the Elder-Ado Inc. senior center in Knoxville started gently, with a call for more and better early childhood education. But the former Pittsburgh councilwoman who is fighting to seize fellow Hill District resident Jake Wheatley's state House seat didn't wear kid gloves for long.
By the time her son and a campaign aide were done passing out the cookies and punch, she was launching haymakers at scandal-plagued Harrisburg.
"Two hundred and fifty-three [legislators] in Harrisburg, and what do we get for it?" she asked the seniors. "Every dime that they spend and misuse and steal is money coming out of your pocket and your family's pocket."
Although state representatives rarely lose re-election bids, the resentment Ms. Payne is trying to tap is one factor that lends suspense to the May 18 Democratic primary in the House's 19th District. Others are her possession of the Democratic Committee's endorsement, and the presence of another challenger, Pittsburgh school director Mark Brentley, a Central North Side resident.
"This election, for me at least, is about who the citizens want in the room, at the negotiating table, to address the issues we have," said Mr. Wheatley, who is in his fourth two-year term. He's touting progress on nuts-and-bolts problems like the 21-year bureaucratic process by which a person living in abandoned housing can take possession of it. His bill to trim the timetable to three to seven years is before the House.
Harrisburg faces a cash crunch that's expected to worsen as ballooning pension fund payments become due. Worsening matters, the federal government has nixed a state plan to toll Interstate 80 to fund transportation improvements.
"You may be talking about gas tax increases, or personal income taxes, or sales taxes," said Mr. Wheatley, 38. He'd prefer to tax the fast-developing Marcellus shale natural gas extraction industry, and wants any other levy hike to last only until the economy improves.
He's leery of renewed proposals to sell the state liquor store system. "I was born and raised in Detroit, Mich.," where liquor stores are private. "In some neighborhoods in Detroit, there's a liquor store on every corner."
Ms. Payne, 46, wouldn't object to privatizing the liquor stores, as long as that doesn't hurt the state budget. She would also support saving money by slashing the state Senate in half, cutting the House less dramatically, and getting rid of what she called "all of those slush funds they have" in Harrisburg.
Mr. Brentley, 53, has faced financial problems, including bankruptcy and ejection from his former Perry South home, that he blames on repeated city efforts to fire him from the Department of Public Works for holding elected office. He has won court arguments that being an unpaid school board member doesn't violate a city home rule charter ban on city workers holding paid, elected office.
Those hardships give resonance to the question he places at the center of his campaign: "Why, why, why are certain people in certain situations?"
While admitting that he'd be "a student" for a term or two if sent to the House, he said he can start solving the problems of people in the district by turning the district office into a job-finding center. People with felonies or child support problems, he said, could get job-hunting help from his office, rather than turning to the streets.
Mr. Brentley and Ms. Payne aim pointed criticism at Mr. Wheatley's vote for a 2004 law that made it easier for utilities to shut off service when customers don't pay. But the campaign's virulence stems mainly from years of Hill District political strife.
Ms. Payne in 2005 ousted Pittsburgh Councilman Sala Udin, for whom Mr. Wheatley once worked. Last year, she was in turn beaten by new Councilman R. Daniel Lavelle, who had worked for Mr. Wheatley.
The campaign started with Ms. Payne, at a civil court hearing, claiming that some of Mr. Wheatley's nomination petitions, circulated by Mr. Lavelle, included forgeries. The Allegheny County Police are reviewing the allegation.
The district, which is entirely within the city, includes all or part of Allegheny Center, Allentown, Arlington, Arlington Heights, Beltzhoover, Bluff, Central Northside, Downtown, Hazelwood, Hill District, Knoxville, Manchester, North Side, Oakland and South Side.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.