Hey, Maude! Did you see the news? Suzanne Martinson died.

That’s a story that the popular Pittsburgh journalist would call a “Hey, Maude!” — one that compels many readers to share it with a relative or a friend.

Ms. Martinson wrote and edited hundreds of those as the food editor at The Pittsburgh Press and then the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette from the 1990s to 2005, when she retired. Her often personal stories and recipes live on in countless scrapbooks and recipe boxes of readers across the region, who became her extended family. Many of them remember her for popularizing the Pittsburgh cookie table.

Her food journalism earned two James Beard Foundation awards, one in 1998 for a story on children who are picky eaters, and one in 2005 for best newspaper food section. Writing in first person, as she often did, about going to New York City to accept the latter medal, she noted, “I believe one big hit with the anonymous judges was the wonderful reader response we got in our Best Butcher contest. In my book, part of the prize goes to our loyal readers.”

Advertise with us

She also won two Bert Greene Awards for food writing from the International Association of Culinary Professionals. The first was for a 1997 profile of mother and son Cambodian refugees who became restaurateurs, and the second was in 2005 for "To win a cook's heart, butter her up," a column about growing up on a farm with her own cow, a Guernsey named Fancy.

Suzanne Lynn Garner Martinson died in her sleep on March 4 at Heritage Hill Assisted Living in Caro, Mich., near that farm on Garner Road. She was 83 and had suffered for several years with the effects of Alzheimer’s disease.

A hearty fan of butter before, during and after the time it was thought to be bad for you, she considered herself always to be a cowgirl. She was, as her niece Kelsey Guthrie posted on Facebook, a “lover of all things fun, and perhaps the only person I’ve ever known to be agreeable to every single adventure, idea, or activity ....”

Born on Nov. 25, 1942, to Waldo and Annadell Garner, she was active in Girl Scouts as well as 4-H, and was a regular competitor at the Tuscola County Fair.

She graduated in 1961 as co-valedictorian of nearby Vassar High School, then earned a bachelor’s degree at Journalism Honors College at Michigan State University. She added to her love for horses (she rode with the Block and Bridle Club) a fierce devotion to the MSU green and white.

Advertise with us

Her first newspaper job was in Champaign-Urbana, Ill., where, in 1966, she married her high school sweetheart, Reg Ashmun. When the Navy transferred him to Pensacola, Fla., she worked as a home economics teacher but returned to journalism after they moved to Oregon.

The couple separated, but the two remained friends, even after she married fellow Gresham Outlook journalist Robert “Bob” Martinson. The Martinsons later joined the Longview (Washington) Daily News, he as an assistant city editor, or ACE, which became his nickname, and she as features editor.

On May 18, 1980, they helped cover the eruption of Mount St. Helens, for which the paper’s staff was awarded a Pulitzer Prize. He took to calling her “Ace,” too.

They moved around as she took features editor jobs at the Knoxville (Tenn.) News Sentinel and then, in 1988, at The Pittsburgh Press.

Retired reporter Steve Twedt, who now teaches writing at Carnegie Mellon University, says he “had the honor of having Suzanne as an editor, colleague and friend” in Longview and Pittsburgh. “She was always open to different ideas and approaches” and “had a knack for helping others produce their best work. Her impact goes well beyond the stories that appeared under her byline.”

Advertise with us

Her editing and mentorship uplifted many journalists. But her writing is what connected so strongly with readers, who weren’t shy about telephoning with questions while they were making a recipe published in that day’s food section.

One of her freelance writers-turned-friends Jane Miller recalls the time a recipe’s directions said to “add yogurt,” but that wasn’t listed in the ingredients. Sitting at her desk surrounded by a looming Mount St. Helens of cookbooks, the food editor started answering the incessant phone calls with, “This is Suzanne Martinson ... you will need one cup of yogurt.”

Ms. Martinson knew that people’s stomachs are very close to their hearts, so she wasn’t shy about sharing personal details about her love for and life with Ace and their daughter, Jessica, in the Ross development of Swan Acres.

She generously invited colleagues and sources and neighbors and their houseguests over for dinner parties frequently featuring some hearty preparation of salmon, and once she held a last-dinner-on-the-Titanic party — in part for, of course, a food story.

People clipped and kept her recipes and still prepare them, such as her great-for-Thanksgiving Feather Yeast Rolls, which contain a half cup of melted butter and an additional half cup of melted butter. (Ace, she wrote in the notes, “married me so he could be close to the baker of these rolls.” She’s the one who proposed.)

Advertise with us

Former reporter and copy editor Ervin Dyer, now a Ph.D. and adjunct professor in the department of Africana studies as well as an editor at the University of Pittsburgh, says his go-to still is Lotsa Lemon Cake, which he tested and wrote about in 1997.

“I loved her — as a food editor and as a special human being,” he says, thankful that she “always welcomed a foodie story allowing me to relive and share my adventures with readers.”

She knew those could be “Hey, Maude!” stories, and she shared many adventures of her own, including the six-course meal she made for her family devoted solely to artichokes.

Another time she and Akron, Ohio, food editor friend Jane Snow drove to the annual conference of the Association of Food Journalists in Baltimore with a 2.5-pound pot roast cooking atop the engine of her car. Then they ate it. Then they joined other food editors for an Italian dinner. Then dessert. She reported, “I gained 3 pounds.”

She still has food editor friends across the county in the AFJ Alums Facebook group, including Kathleen Purvis of Charlotte, N.C., who posted, “She was a pistol. Fearless, down to earth and a great spirit. I never remember her without a smile.”

Advertise with us

Karan Haram of San Antonio, Texas, says, “She was everything you want a journalist to be — bright, creative, curious, ethical, energetic and adaptable, and a great communicator. I loved talking to Suzanne at our annual conferences as she produced some of the best food articles in the country and always had wonderful ideas on ways to improve newspaper food sections.”

She could push the limits with some of the copy editors and page designers she worked with.

One of them, Karen Carlin, who still works at the PG, puts it diplomatically: "Suzanne always wanted to give as much as possible in every single story. She felt her readers deserved that. She would take that mission as close to deadline as she could. There was many a time she would say, just when we were putting the final touches on the Food section, ‘Did you leave me a little wiggle room?’ because she wanted to add just one more thing."

Her fellow award-winning food writer, Marlene Parrish, says that as loving and fun as she was, “she could be straight-talking and tough, too,” as on fundamentals such as not putting the most important part of a story too low. “I buried a lede once. Just once.”

Among Ms. Martinson’s claims to fame (noted in Alice Crosetto’s 2023 book “The Cookie Table: A Steel Valley Tradition”) is popularizing the “phenomenon” of the wedding cookie table, which she came to love “with the blind intensity of a convert.” She organized many dozens of cookies baked for the South Indian wedding of two reporter friends, and gave that couple all the recipes with handwritten notes.

Advertise with us

“The more I thought about it, a Cookie Table is kind of a marriage in miniature,” she wrote for the following Sunday. “You need variety (chocolate chips for the kids, something lighter for calorie counters), sustenance (gingersnaps from the PG's newest mother), and stick-to-the-ribs sweetness (no table has too many Mexican Wedding Cakes or heart-shaped butter cookies). Something old (Pittsburgh classics — beautiful ladylocks and nut rolls) would be balanced with something new.”

Ms. Miller, who worked with her later to start a cookie table cookbook, tells of making wedding cookies for the daughter of a friend in 2016. The friend pulled from a drawer Ms. Martinson’s epic cookie table section from 1996, when her daughter was 10. She’d saved it for 20 years for this occasion.

But Ms. Miller says her food editor’s favorite story was a long one she first told one Sunday in 1991 about the cook at the Frank Lloyd Wright home in the Laurel Highlands once owned by the Kaufmanns department store family. Ms. Martinson wound up turning that into a book: “The Fallingwater Cookbook: Elsie Henderson's Recipes and Memories.” Published by University of Pittsburgh Press in 2008, it still is in print and also available at Fallingwater and online.

“It’s a little touch of Pittsburgh history that will always be there. And Suzanne was the fire under it all,” says one of her co-authors, chef Robert Sendall of All in Good Taste Productions, who worked on it with Ms. Henderson, Jane Citron and two photographers.

“She just let us do our thing,” he says, noting that throughout the several-yearslong process, right up to the launch party at the home of Elsie and Henry Hillman, “she was always so engaging and wanting everyone to be a part of it.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Martinson’s daughter, Jessica Burton, recalls that her doting mom (and dad) never missed a North Hills marching band performance. “They always believed that family was first.”

They traveled to a lot to places besides Michigan — to Hawaii, Oregon, Puerto Rico and Paris. But “Suz” never stopped asking how the crops were doing on the family farm. That’s where one Thanksgiving her mom famously made her patented pecan pie with salt instead of sugar and reinforced another life lesson: It’s OK to fail. As her daughter puts it, “There was many a failed recipe in our household.... Let’s keep trying.”

Ms. Martinson and her husband retired to Kelso, Wash., though she still wrote a column for the Columbia River Reader called “Cooking with the Farmer’s Daughter.”

Otherwise, “she poured herself into volunteering with [Youth and Family Link], loving her [two] grandchildren, and savoring the simple joys of daily life,” according to her Michigan obit. “She was a lover of crafts and eclectic art, famous for her unique collection of earrings, and a devoted reader of mystery novels.” She was pro dessert — always, and preferably, first.

Her husband died in 2015 of complications from a rare leukemia. Their daughter Jennifer Ann had died in 1979 at age 3 weeks.

Advertise with us

In addition to daughter Jessica — she lives in Holt, Mich., with husband, Elijah, and two children — Ms. Martinson is survived by siblings Roxann Guthrie and Jon Garner of Vassar, Mich., and several nieces and nephews.

The family held a Michigan memorial service Saturday that featured a rousing recording of the Michigan State fight song (Jessica is playing in it) and two cookie tables. The family will hold another celebration next month in the Pacific Northwest, where Ms. Martinson will be buried next to Jennifer and Ace, whom she often referred to as “the editor I sleep with.”

The Post-Gazette’s Stephen Karlinchak contributed.