Mary Ann Fenio never seemed to do anything halfway, whether creating a chocolate treat, tying a bow, baking for a celebration or organizing a community fundraiser.
Friends say she had a gift for turning ordinary moments into something meaningful and beautiful, and for making people around her feel cared for through the small details.
Mrs. Fenio, 80, of Kennedy, who spent her life blending creativity with service via teaching and ministry as well as community fundraising and even candy-making, died Jan. 25.
Mrs. Fenio, born July 5, 1945, graduated from Mount Mercy College and was a Sister of the Holy Family of Nazareth for 14 years, teaching first grade at Holy Family School in Lawrenceville and later serving as an art coordinator specializing in ceramics at Holy Family Manor in Ross. She also worked as an art teacher at St. Augustine Academy in Lakewood, Ohio.
Sister Maria Kruszewski, who attended college with Mrs. Fenio, remembered her as a gifted artist.
Sister Maria recalled a lasting gift Mrs. Fenio created: a handcrafted silver medal with a depiction of the Holy Spirit, a gift intended to celebrate taking her final vows in 1967. Sister Maria still wears the medal.
Read More
After leaving religious life, Mrs. Fenio worked at Allegheny Valley School, where she supported individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities. She later returned to Holy Family Manor as activities director.
“She wasn't afraid to work,” Sister Maria said.
In retirement, Mrs. Fenio worked part-time at Applelicious, a Carnegie candy shop. Veronica Godleski, who worked with her there, said Mrs. Fenio became a beloved figure among customers and coworkers.
She became known for her signature Buckeyes, a peanut butter and chocolate candy associated with Ohio. “We called her our Buckeye lady.”
Mrs. Fenio topped each one with a beautiful peanut butter swirl.
“Oh my god, those Buckeyes!” Sister Maria exclaimed, while remembering them.
They also were a favorite of customers, many of whom would ship them to distant friends and family.
She brought that same precision to other candies, like the caramel, chocolate and nut confections known as turtles.
“And I swear she would go through the nuts [and] when that turtle was done, it looked like four turtle legs sticking out,” Ms. Godleski said, laughing. “They just had to be perfect.”
Mrs. Fenio’s attention to detail extended beyond candy. Ms. Godleski said she became the shop’s go-to gift wrapper. Her hand-tied bows were legendary.
Mrs. Fenio served for years as vice president of the Kennedy Township Garden Club and became a key organizer of its annual Spring Festival, which raises money through plant sales, baked goods and raffles.
Judy Fritzges, the club’s past president, said Mrs. Fenio helped transform the festival into a major fundraiser.
The Spring Festival, she said, includes selling perennials dug from members’ yards, annuals purchased from nurseries, and a bake sale. But the raffles became the festival’s centerpiece under Mrs. Fenio’s leadership.
“I think at one point we sold 1,800 tickets,” Ms. Fritzges said. “And that is a testament to Mary Ann. Let me tell you that no one could resist her sales pitch.”
Ms. Fritzges described her friend as someone who was constantly in motion and deeply connected to her community. Even tasks like posting signs promoting the festival became an event. The duo would drive around town to post the signs and be greeted by friends and neighbors at nearly every stop. “Mary Ann knew everybody,” she said.
Mrs. Fenio also brought her artistic talent into the garden club’s work: she was unrivaled at tying elaborate bows for gifts and décor.
“Now, when I say bows, I mean, these bows were ginormous, and they were just beautiful,” Ms. Fritzges said. “They were literally works of art.”
Mrs. Fenio endured a difficult series of health setbacks in recent years, including uterine cancer, a serious car accident and subsequent complications, friends said.
“The past five years have not been kind to her,” Ms. Fritzges said. Despite the challenges, she remained steady and upbeat.
Sister Maria will remember Mrs. Fenio’s gift for making everyday moments meaningful. “It's the simple things,” she said. “You know, the tasks that take time, they take love, they take commitment, and they bring forth beauty.”
Mrs. Fenio is survived by her husband of 38 years, Thomas M. Fenio, as well as nieces, a nephew, great-nieces and great-nephews, extended family and her yellow Labrador retriever, Gracie. She was preceded in death by her parents, Stephen and Mary (Tkacik) Rusnak, and brothers Stephen “Jack” Rusnak and William Rusnak.
Contributions in Mrs. Fenio's memory may be made to Sisters of the Holy Family of Nazareth, 310 North River Road, Des Plaines, IL 60016 or www.nazarethcsfn.org.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.