David F. Weiner, who made a name for himself as a pioneer in employment law in Pittsburgh, died on June 7 at his Oakland home. He was 86.
The cause was cancer, his daughter, Bentley, said.
After turns working as a lawyer in Washington, D.C., for the Interstate Commerce Commission and in New York as an attorney for NBC, Mr. Weiner returned to his native Pittsburgh in 1973 with his wife, Barbara (née Bentley). They soon welcomed their daughter, Bentley.
Mr. Weiner made his Pittsburgh career fighting for employees and against both small companies and multinational corporations.
This choice of specialty was a matter of happenstance, said his longtime legal partner, Robert Gallo, now a retired Allegheny County judge. It began with a Sharpsburg resident named Lillian Sundo.
At the time, Mr. Gallo was a Sharpsburg councilman. Constituents would come in to his office there ask for his advice, including Ms. Sundo, a “saintly lady,” according to Mr. Gallo. She worked at the front desk of a local Kmart and was known as “the Kmart lady.”
Read More
She told him she had been terminated for failing to report a suspected theft. Mr. Gallo replied that Pennsylvania law allowed employers to terminate employees at will, for any or no reason at all.
Nevertheless, he told Ms. Sundo to consult his partner, Mr. Weiner.
“He interviewed her and he comes back, he says, ‘We can go to court in this case,’ ” Mr. Gallo recalled.
Despite Mr. Gallo’s doubts, they took the case to trial and won for wrongful discharge, with $43,000 in compensatory and punitive damages.
According to his daughter, Mr. Weiner believed this was the first jury verdict in Pennsylvania for wrongful termination.
For the next year, Mr. Gallo said, the bar would refer all its employment cases to their firm “because no one did this kind of law. And that’s how we got started.”
They had a fruitful, partnership, lasting a dozen years.
Mr. Gallo contrasted their different backgrounds. Mr. Gallo at one time worked in a steel mill and went to college late, while Mr. Weiner attended Mercersburg Academy, a the private boarding school in Franklin County, and the University of Pennsylvania, where he earned a varsity letter in soccer.
Friends and family recall that while he was living in New York, Mr. Weiner enjoyed taking friends to well-known restaurants of the time, such as the celebrity haunt Elaine’s, Le Pavillon and Luchow’s; he and his wife relished Bobby Short performances at the Café Carlyle.
A longstanding friend, Peter Tynberg, recalled shopping with him at Brooks Brothers in New York, and noted his honed sense of style.
Despite Mr. Weiner’s advantaged background, friends, colleagues and even adversaries recall him as modest, gentlemanly and humorous.
Terry Murphy faced Mr. Weiner in court several times in the early 1990s. Though employment law can be adversarial, Mr. Murphy said, Mr. Weiner stood out for his courteous manner.
“Dave was insightful, knowledgeable about the law, a strong advocate, but always a gracious advocate,” he said.
Later, Mr. Weiner and Mr. Murphy were part of a group of lawyers, engineers, doctors and others who would meet on Tuesday nights at the Duquesne Club — the group called themselves “the Harrumphers” — where they would discuss everything from sports to politics to business.
At these meetings and elsewhere, Mr. Weiner, an avid sports enthusiast and pop culture buff, would often quiz people about their favorite athletes, movie stars or movies. Mr. Weiner had strong opinions.
“He and I had, I don't know how many conversations where he would ask, ‘Terry, who would you put on your all-time NBA team?’” Mr. Murphy recalled. “And he always included Bill Russell at center.” Mr. Murphy, on the other hand, spoke up for Kareem Abdul-Jabbar.
Mr. Weiner’s former partner, Mr. Gallo, said that they never argued — except about movies.
Mr. Weiner not only regularly followed Pittsburgh sports teams but also was an amateur athlete himself, well into his senior years. He played squash and tennis, participating in doubles tennis matches in his 80s.
His daughter, Bentley, now a senior vice president of sports documentaries at HBO, said that she got her love of sports from her father. He was particularly tickled when she interviewed his fantasy all-star center, Bill Russell, early in her career.
Her father would never miss any of her athletic matches when she was a child, she said.
“No matter how hard he was working, as a father, he dropped everything for me,” Ms. Weiner said. “I never doubted how much he loved me.”
Mr. Weiner was predeceased by his wife, Barbara, in 2024, after a marriage of 52 years.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.