Patrick John Foy, a restaurateur who helped shape the arc of Pittsburgh dining in the 1960s and ’70s, died March 23 due to complications from vascular dementia. He was 88.
Mr. Foy was born in Cleveland in 1937 and graduated from Ohio University in 1958 with a degree in journalism.
He worked in advertising for a little less than a decade before pivoting into a second act that would help change the face of dining and drinking in Downtown Pittsburgh and, later, the suburbs.
In 1967, Mr. Foy and another former advertising executive, Bill Millar, opened a franchise location of the small Cleveland-based chain Pewter Mug in Market Square, making Pittsburgh the sixth location. Neither Mr. Foy nor Mr. Millar had any experience in the hospitality industry, deepening the risk to launch a new restaurant in what the Pittsburgh Press described in 1968 as “one of the less auspicious downtown locations … where an established totally qualified restaurateur gave up.”
The 70-seat spot was, as Mr. Foy told the Press, a place “where businessmen could get together and talk over what businessmen like to eat.” The Pewter Mug offered a limited menu, with dishes such as roast beef, fish and chips and half-pound hamburgers, with Canadian beer and martinis as popular drink items.
It was a swift hit. In 1973, the Post-Gazette offered praise for Mr. Foy’s work in transforming Market Square, giving a nod to Pewter Mug’s authentic double-level London bus.
By 1970, Mr. Foy and Mr. Millar ran three Downtown establishments.
Building on the success of Pewter Mug, Mr. Foy, Mr. Millar and musician Walt Harper opened a dancing and after-dinner drinks spot, Walt Harper's Attic, in Market Square in 1969. The move continued to help the revival of Downtown by bringing a new spur of nightlife to a part of town that typically wound down shortly after the work day. Mr. Foy had previously told the Press how happy he was to be able to close up shop at Pewter Mug by 10 p.m.
The trio then partnered on 3 Lions in the Law & Finance Building on Fourth Avenue. Mr. Foy at the time also served as president of the Market Square Association, which lobbied for Downtown amenities such as 18 gas lamps to illuminate the square; according to the Post-Gazette, the association spent $5,000 of its own money to pay for the lamps.
In 1971, Mr. Foy and Mr. Millar took over Coach and Eight in Shadyside, turning that spot into a dining and entertainment destination.
Then, in 1974, Mr. Foy and his first wife, Carol, purchased the primary building of The Hyeholde Restaurant in Moon from its founders, William and Clara Kryskill. The Kryskills, then in their 70s, were ready to retire from the restaurant they had opened in 1937.
“It became much more cosmopolitan under Pat and Carol,” the Kryskills daughter, Barbara McKenna, told the Post-Gazette in 2022.
Mr. Foy revised the simple but elegant Continental menu toward a fine-dining concept, but kept Hyeholde’s signature sherry bisque, a dish still on the menu today. He oversaw the addition of a blockbuster wine list, too. For the effort, he earned Western Pennsylvania’s first-ever four-star rating from the Mobile Travel Guide in 1980.
The Foys purchased Hyeholde's second building, “The Round Room,” in 1986. They connected the two spaces via an underground tunnel, rebuilding a portion of The Round Room as a jazz club, The Hyeholde Cabaret.
The Foys later acquired two adjoining acres with the hope of building an inn on the property. However, the proposed expansion and a challenging location to run a jazz club led the Foys to overstretch their finances. Ms. McKenna would, in turn, repurchase the Hyeholde from the Foys in 1991. She sold the establishment to its longtime chef, Chris O’Brien, in 2023.
“The Hyeholde is deeply saddened to hear of the passing of Patrick Foy,” co-owner Jennifer O’Brien said. “Mr. Foy's dedication to the culinary community helped to bring Hyeholde to the forefront of fine dining in the Pittsburgh area. His spirit and legacy will forever be a part of our history. As we reflect on Mr. Foy's contributions to Hyeholde, we will continue to build on his legacy and love for our castle on the hill.”
Mr. Foy continued to develop restaurants after he left Pittsburgh. He and his second wife, Jane, opened Reynard's Grill and Hunt Country Inn in Middleburg, Va., later working as a restaurant consultant in Charlottesville, Va.
Mr. Foy retired from restaurants in 2005, launching a second career as a fitness instructor. He was diagnosed with vascular dementia in 2013 and lived under skilled nursing care at Monroe Health and Rehabilitation Center in Charlottesville from 2021 until his death last month.
Mr. Foy is survived by his wife, Jane Sweitzer Foy, of Charlottesville; and four children — sons Charles Foy of Aliquippa; Daniel Foy of Orinda, Calif. and daughters Carolyn Foy of Apopka, Fla., and MaryJean Bretton, of Denmark, Wis. He is also survived by five grandchildren, 10 great-grandchildren and many nieces and nephews.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.