A well-known orthopedic surgeon who took up the mantle to defend doctors accused of malpractice, Dr. Scott Nettrour was as adept with a scalpel as he was admired for knowing when to exercise restraint.

In the competitive and challenging field of orthopedic medicine, Dr. Nettrour remained a humble professional who didn’t succumb to an elevated ego, said his longtime friend and colleague Jim Wood.

“He was a genuinely nice guy — there was nothing fake about him,” said Mr. Wood, a retired medical malpractice attorney who got to know Dr. Nettrour when he called upon the surgeon as an expert witness to defend medical malpractice lawsuits. “He was a very well-respected orthopedic surgeon. He was very confident, not arrogant, and there’s a very fine line there between confidence and arrogance. He was a genuinely nice, noble person.”

“Everyone he met felt appreciated and valued by him. He had a wonderful way of making you see that he was glad to meet you,” said Dr. Kelly Agnew, physician executive administrator of the Tri Rivers Musculoskeletal Centers, a practice co-founded by Dr. Nettrour, along with his brother and father, in the early 1970s.

Advertise with us

“There aren't many people I've met in the surgical practice who have his generous, kind heart. We all tried to emulate him.”

An orthopedic surgeon for more than five decades, Dr. Nettrour, of McCandless, died Nov. 15 of complications from type 2 diabetes. He was 86.

Growing up as the namesake and son of Dr. Walter Scott Nettrour, a general surgeon, Scott Nettrour didn’t necessarily dream of following in his father’s footsteps, at least not at first.

“I think it was after he graduated from college that he decided to go into medicine,” said his wife, Carol Nettrour.

Once he made the decision, Dr. Nettrour established a deep affection for the medical arts, she said.

Advertise with us

“He loved medicine, he really did.”

And that wasn’t the only love Dr. Nettrour found in college.

A serendipitous introduction awaited him shortly after he graduated from the University of Pittsburgh, his wife said.

“I met him when I was on a date with someone else,” she said. “After that, he asked me to play tennis.”

Bedecked in a gown of white silk organza with a Swedish crown of matching lace fastened to her silk illusion veil — as noted by society pages of the day — Mrs. Nettrour, nee Davidson, married Dr. Nettrour in the Heinz Memorial Chapel in June 1962.

Advertise with us

“He was a great guy,” she said. “We had a lot of adventures together.”

During the Vietnam War, Dr. Nettrour served two years as a physician in the Navy medical corps at the U.S. Naval Academy in Annapolis, Md.

He went on to earn a medical degree at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine in 1964, and completed his residency in orthopedic surgery at the school.

In the early ‘70s, Dr. Nettrour and his brother Lewis, also an orthopedic surgeon, joined their father in establishing Tri Rivers Musculoskeletal Centers in the North Hills.

Not long after UPMC Passavant-McCandless relocated from the Hill District to the North Hills, the Nettrours moved their practice to the hospital’s campus.

Advertise with us

The move helped to lend a bit of prestige to the burgeoning hospital by contributing to the specialty care that was available, such as orthopedic medicine.

In fact, after they retired, Dr. Nettrour and his brother were honored by Passavant Hospital Foundation for their role in establishing and building Passavant’s prominence and reputation within the community during its early years.

“The two of them, they were young — they worked hard to establish an orthopedic facility there that met the standards that Passavant was trying to reach,” Mrs. Nettrour recalled. “They worked really hard those days. Eventually they brought in more partners and started a consulting practice to extend the reach and influence of the group for years to come.”

In the ‘90s, Dr. Nettrour and his brother sought to expand the practice with Tri Rivers Consulting Services, a medicolegal division that focused on providing expert assessments in malpractice lawsuits.

“He did it because he wanted to defend doctors who hadn’t done anything wrong,” his wife said. “He only did it if he felt the case was worthy of defense. He loved the legal world as well as the medical.”

Advertise with us

Before he retired in 2003, Dr. Nettrour testified in dozens of malpractice cases, Mr. Wood said, and it was easy to see why he was awarded the “Golden Apple” by orthopedic residents as the best teacher among the medical school faculty at Pitt.

“He was highly intelligent, well-spoken and very light on his feet, particularly during cross examination,” he said. “He was a very formidable witness.”

One of Dr. Nettrour’s other great loves was caring for his family’s 16-acre homestead, including a house built by his parents in 1954.

“We've lived here ever since — it’s just been great fun,” his wife said. “He really did love this place. He knew every tree's botanical name on the property and he loved to mow the fields. As he grew older, he spent more of his time outside caring for the world around us.”

Her husband was especially proud of his stand of oak trees, many of which he planted, Mrs. Nettrour said, and gardens that featured a wide variety of flora.

Advertise with us

“He was more into planting trees than anything else. He loved the details of their leaves, their patterns of behavior in the different seasons. We planted every kind of garden you can imagine. He was always up to something.”

Mr. Wood said he would miss the easy rapport in the courtroom that turned into an enduring friendship with Dr. Nettrour.

“I knew him for over 45 years,” he said. “He was one of my very best friends. He was a man of integrity. He was an impeccably honest, moral, and transparent person who treated all people with decency and respect.”

Along with his wife, Dr. Nettrour is survived by a daughter, Elizabeth Carney; siblings Dr. Lewis Fairbank Nettrour and Mary Nettrour Angus; and nine grandchildren.

He was preceded in death by sons Dr. Walter Scott Nettrour IV, and James Stuart Nettrour; and a sister, Sally Jane Nettrour.

Advertise with us

The family is planning a private funeral.

In lieu of flowers, contributions may be made to the Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources  in care of the Keystone Tree Fund at: ATTN: Rural & Community Forestry 400 Market St., 6th Floor, Harrisburg, PA 17105