Former President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning, a longtime figure on the Allegheny County bench known for his wit and command of a courtroom, has died.
Friends and colleagues confirmed the judge’s death Monday afternoon. He was 77.
Judge Manning served more than three decades in the judiciary in Allegheny County. He was appointed to the Court of Common Pleas in 1988 and won his first 10-year term a year later. He was retained three times, most recently in 2019. He served five years as president judge from 2013 to 2018.
He retired in 2021.
Before he was appointed to the bench, he worked as a prosecutor in the district attorney’s office and then in the U.S. Attorney’s Office, where he became a standout among an impressive staff of federal prosecutors that included future state officials and U.S. judges.
“I can say without reservation he was an extraordinary lawyer,” said Robert Cindrich, who worked alongside Judge Manning as a federal prosecutor and would later go on to become a federal judge. “He was a person who had a total command of a courtroom.”
Mr. Cindrich said the judge knew intricately the nuances of law and lawyering. But he was also witty, he said, and he used his sharp humor to cut through tense moments behind the scenes during trials. He kept that wit throughout his career.
“He was a consummate raconteur, a jokester,” he said. “He loved to entertain and amuse us. He kept us laughing.”
Indeed, said Common Pleas Judge Philip A. Ignelzi: “Two things Jeffrey had other than his [knowledge of law] were his wit and humor.”
Judge Ignelzi first worked alongside Judge Manning in the latter role in the 1980s. In the first two cases he worked, he said, he was “second seat” to Judge Manning, meaning Judge Manning was the lead attorney.
“My first two trials were sitting to the right of Jeff Manning,” he said. “He was probably the most talented trial lawyer in our office at the time.”
Their paths continued to cross in similar fashions. Judge Ignelzi left the U.S. Attorney’s Office in 1988 for private practice, and Judge Manning asked him to be his campaign treasurer during the 1989 election.
“Our paths just stayed together from when I tried my first case with him in January 1984 all the way to when I fortunate enough to be elected to the bench [in 2009],” he said.
Judge Manning was one of the presenters at his swearing in.
“As great as a trial lawyer as he was, he was an even better judge — he was our go-to judge,” Judge Ignelzi said. “Jeffrey handled all of the most difficult cases — not all the death penalty cases, but many of the most serious death penalty cases.”
Among the defendants whose cases he presided over were Richard Baumhammers, a spree killer who killed five people in 2000, and Richard Poplawski, who killed three Pittsburgh police officers in an ambush-style shooting in 2009.
“Jeffrey Manning was one of the most skilled and respected trial lawyers and judge of our time in Western Pennsylvania,” said Ken Gormley, president of Duquesne University, where the judge spent more than 30 years as a law professor. “From his early days as first assistant in the U.S. Attorney’s Office … to his time a president judge in the Court of Common Pleas, Jeffrey exuded competence, compassion and skill as both a prosecutor and a jurist.”
Mr. Gormley joined the university as a law professor in 1994, and he later served as dean of the law school. He said Judge Manning was a popular professor who was recognized numerous times by the student body with the Excellence in Teaching Award.
“He was a true lawyer’s lawyer and judge’s judge, whose presence in our legal community will be forever missed,” he said.
Sheriff Kevin Kraus said he’s known the judge for his entire career. He called him one of the most brilliant jurists in the country, noting that his legacy can be found in the work of his son, a commander in the sheriff’s department.
Judge Ignelzi said Judge Manning found great value in mentoring.
“He had a lot of talents,” he said, “and he shared them.”
Indeed, defense attorney Phil DiLucente said he learned more from Judge Manning that he did in law school.
“He taught me more about evidence and trial tactics that I learned in law school,” he said. “You just never left his courtroom without him teaching you something.”
Mr. Cindrich said the judge was an intelligent man who could, at a moment’s notice, quote case law or recall an historical anecdote to make a point in the courtroom.
“Most of us don’t have that gift,” he said.
He said he believes Judge Manning wanted a seat on the bench because he saw it as a public calling. After a successful career in the district attorney’s office and then U.S. Attorney’s Office, the next step is often private practice.
For Mr. Cindrich, the years of his six-decade career that stand out the most are those that he spent in public service. He said he suspects his longtime friend and colleague set his sights on the bench because he wanted to continue in a public service role.
The judge was instrumental to helping ease the massive backlog of cases that plagued the county court system in the mid- to late-2000s. As administrative judge for the criminal division, Judge Manning helped create what was dubbed the Phoenix Docket system in which two dedicated judges hear lower-level crimes that usually have no individual victims — things such as DUIs and retail theft cases.
The goal was and is to move those cases through the court system as quickly as possible, and prosecutors and defense attorneys often have a pre-negotiated plea deal in place early on in the process.
The backlog of cases fell from nearly 15,000 in 2009 to less than 8,000 in 2013.
Judge Manning said of the system in 2013: “We’re trying to be not just fast, but fast and fair.”
And he was just that, Judge Ignelzi said.
“As tough as a judge as he could be, and would be when he had to be, he was a very compassionate man,” he said.
He recalled Judge Manning’s response when a man convicted in his courtroom of second-degree murder — a charge that carries a mandatory life sentence with no parole, often called the felony murder rule — applied for clemency. He said the judge wrote a “very compelling letter,” and the man was granted clemency. He said he’s using Judge Manning’s as a model as he writes a letter on behalf of a defendant in a similar situation.
“It just shows you the type of person Jeffrey was,” Judge Ignelzi said. “He was a very a fair man. Looking back on it, he realized we probably should not have the felony murder rule.”
Former Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald said he had the privilege of seeing the judge near-daily during his time as county executive.
“His north star was always centered on ensuring that public safety was upheld and justice was served for victims and victims' families,” he said. “He was never afraid to take on the hard cases and make tough decisions — and over the course of his career, there is no doubt he had his fair share of them.”
It was a sentiment echoed by former Gov. Tom Corbett, who worked with Judge Manning in the DA’s office and in the U.S. Attorney’s Office. He recalled his longtime friend — who he likened to a brother ever since they met in 1976 — as a dapper dresser with a near-photographic memory.
He said it didn’t matter that he was a lifelong Republican and the judge a Democrat. Mr. Corbett said the judge didn’t carry a political philosophy when he was a prosecutor or judge — rather, it was about being fair.
“He had the courage to make tough decisions,” Mr. Corbett said. “They weren’t going to be popular decisions, but they were the right decisions.”
Steve Bohnel contributed to this report.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.