Hailed for his accomplishments as a philosopher and logician, Nuel Belnap was a professor, author and researcher at the University of Pittsburgh, where he taught for nearly 50 years.

“He was just a great lecturer and explainer; he was teaching very complex material and these very abstract concepts and he had this gift of making it come alive,” said Anil Gupta, a former student and protege who now teaches philosophy at Pitt. “His intellectual honesty and integrity is something I found remarkable. I’d never seen anything like it. He wasn’t afraid to admit when he didn’t know something and this was an example for us as students.”

An Ivy League-educated professor at Pitt, Mr. Belnap also served as a programmer for the first mainframe computer to collect and process data for the National Security Agency in the early 1950s.

Mr. Belnap died June 12 of complications from dementia at his home in Whitefield, N.H., where he moved in 2020 to be closer to his family. He was 94.

Advertise with us

He grew up in Winnetka, Ill., the son of a lawyer.

“He had three older sisters, so I think he was bossed around a lot,” said his daughter Mary Jo Greene, of Easton, N.H. “I think he had a really good childhood.”

His family spent summers at a cottage in Marinette, Wis., “which was probably his favorite place in the world, which is where we are spreading his ashes,” his daughter said.

After graduating from the University of Illinois with a bachelor’s degree in philosophy, Mr. Belnap joined the Air Force, where he worked on the IBM 701 computer — known by the NSA as the “Defense Calculator.”

In the early days of computing, the system served as IBM’s first commercial scientific computer and its first series production mainframe computer, according to an IBM archive curated by the Wayback Machine.

Advertise with us

In 1960, Mr. Belnap went on to earn his master’s and doctoral degrees from Yale University, where he also met notable philosopher Alan Ross Anderson, who served as his adviser and mentor.

After graduation, he spent a year as a Fulbright Fellow in Belgium, where ideas about logic started to take shape in his mind.

Mr. Belnap landed at Pitt in 1963 and Mr. Anderson followed two years later as part of a mass exodus by many faculty members in the fractured philosophy department at Yale.

“There was upheaval at the time at Yale and in the early ‘60s a fantastic group of philosophers came from Yale to Pittsburgh, helping to make this department one of the best in the world,” Mr. Gupta said. “Belnap was one of the big reasons that Anderson came to Pitt.”

Mr. Belnap worked closely with his mentor in publishing and researching theories of philosophy, logic and truth that impacted generations of philosophers, Mr. Gupta said.

Advertise with us

Together, they wrote a two-volume book that expanded on the knowledge and theories that first took hold of Mr. Belnap in Belgium.

“He became one of the top experts in the field. He was well-known and admired,” Mr. Gupta said of his friend and mentor.

Her father was always an inquisitive person, Ms. Greene said, and working with Mr. Anderson seemed to unlock his more creative impulses.

“My father was a thinker and he would throw his ideas into the universe to be questioned and to question,” she said. “I think that he was driven to question and posit different ideas. He was very inspired by [Mr. Anderson].”

Until his retirement in 2011, Mr. Belnap served as the Alan Ross Anderson distinguished professor for philosophy at Pitt. Today, Mr. Gupta holds that title.

Advertise with us

Mr. Belnap served as a mentor and dissertation director for Mr. Gupta and later went on to co-publish a book with him about the concept of truth called “The Revision Theory of Truth,” published by MIT in 1993.

“It was wonderful to work with him on this,” Mr. Gupta said.

An original thinker, Mr. Belnap wrote several other books and publications and earned a reputation as a generous collaborator to younger colleagues and junior researchers, a quality sometimes found lacking in academia, Mr. Gupta said.

“He gave credit where it was due and even greater than was due in some circumstances,” he said. “It was a rarity.”

Mr. Belnap was a good friend as well.

Advertise with us

“I was a grad student and I didn’t have much money,” Mr. Gupta recalled. “I invited my parents to visit me from India and they didn't have much money either. We had saved money for a long visit and they applied for a tourist visa. The [American] embassy demanded proof that I had something like $800 in my bank account. I didn't have that kind of money because I had just paid for the plane tickets. Belnap asked me what was going on and when I told him, he pulled out his checkbook right there and wrote me a check for $800. That’s the kind of person he was.”

“He did stuff like that all the time but he didn’t talk about it,” Ms. Greene said about her father’s kindness to Mr. Gupta. “He knew how hard the students worked.”

Mr. Belnap often lectured throughout the world and was singled out for prestigious honors and accolades, though they meant little to her father, his daughter said.

When he was awarded a fellowship from the Guggenheim Foundation — he’d also received fellowships from the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities — he did little more than shrug.

“It wasn’t a big deal to him,” she said. “I found the Guggenheim award stuffed in the top drawer of his dresser. He was humble, he wasn’t elitist. He wanted everybody to call him Nuel, not Dr. Belnap.”

Advertise with us

An enthusiastic and talented photographer, Mr. Belnap excelled at his hobbies too, loved ones said.

“He had a dark room in the basement,” Ms. Greene recalled. “He also loved tinkering with anything electronic. He built a radio and stereo by himself.”

“He took me whitewater rafting once and we liked to play ‘Go’ together,” Mr. Gupta said, laughing at the memory. “I’ll miss his presence. I liked being with him. The world is missing something with him gone, something important and good.”

Along with his daughter, Mr. Belnap is survived by his sons Nuel Belnap III, of Burney, Calif., Christopher Belnap, of Arlington, Vt., Tyler Belnap, of Chicago.; 10 grandchildren; and one great-granddaughter.

A private funeral service is planned for late summer.

Advertise with us

In lieu of flowers, contributions may be made to the University of Pittsburgh in support of the Alan Ross Anderson Distinguished Professor of Philosophy, PO Box 640093, Pittsburgh, PA 15264-0093.

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.