No one ever accused Jerry Weber of being a shrewd businessman.

He loved records too much. Not only did he buy way more than he needed, he also sold them far below market value.

That’s only part of what made Mr. Weber a beloved figure in Pittsburgh for five decades.

His enthusiasm, bigger-than-life personality, unabashed love for music and generosity were the drivers for Jerry’s Records, a vinyl empire in Squirrel Hill that ranked among the best record stores in the world.

Advertise with us

He died Friday at his Swissvale home at age 73. A cause of death was not immediately available.

“I always had this voracious appetite for listening to music,” he told the Post-Gazette when he semi-retired in 2017. “I used to beg my mom to stay up late and watch ‘[Your] Hit Parade.’ It was on at 10 o’clock on Saturday, I think. ‘Mom, please, please.’ ‘OK, whatever.’ I was born with it, both a blessing and a curse.”

After a stint in the Army from 1969 to 1971, Mr. Weber came home and took a job as a mail carrier. On his route was the Doo Dah Shop on South Bouquet Street in Oakland, opened by Dan Charny, which stocked science fiction and horror books and was just getting into records.

Intrigued by the idea, Mr. Weber paid $75 to take over the store room above a bar near the corner of Forbes Avenue and Craig Street and, in partnership with Jim Petruzzi, a friend from the post office, turned it into the Record Graveyard in 1978.

They acquired records from promo men who sold them extra copies, libraries that were unloading collections and people trading in their albums for a variety of reasons, ranging from needing rent money to making the switch to CDs.

Advertise with us

In the early 1980s, Mr. Weber went solo above the McDonald’s on Forbes Avenue in Oakland with Garbage Records, which became Jerry’s Records in the late 1980s, and then moved to Squirrel Hill in 1994.

When customers walked up that long, narrow staircase, getting that exciting whiff of vinyl and musty cardboard, they would often find Jerry at the top, squatting on a box, sorting through some overwhelming stack that he had just acquired. Or he would be at the counter, buried behind more stacks, playing an Ella Fitzgerald record or one of his favorite blues guys.

Unlike just about every other vinyl vendor on planet, he was selling them mostly for $3 to $7, and when you’d take a stack to the counter, he’d often round the figure down even more. A trip to the basement would usually get you any old Moody Blues or Chicago record for $1.

A few times a year, customers would line up along Murray Avenue for one of his free boxes of 100 miscellaneous records, providing the same thrill as opening a pack of baseball cards. There would usually be a few gems among the eight Billy Ocean albums, the Helen Reddy collection and the choral groups from Scandinavia.

He would then have to deal with people trying to sell those right back to him.

Advertise with us

In 2011, the National Geographic show “Taboo” featured him as part of a “Hoarders” segment, somehow oblivious to the fact that he was in the business of selling records.

Jerry’s became a mecca for artists on tour, with everyone from Robert Plant to Ben Folds to Mike Ness (of Social Distortion) making the pilgrimage.

In 2012, Mr. Weber came across a 78 rpm copy of Robert Johnson’s “I Believe I’ll Dust My Broom” (on Vocalion) in a box of water-damaged records. The amazing find was in good condition, one of only two he had ever seen. A year later, Jerry and his son Willie came across a rare Bogus Ben Covington 78 that they managed to trade to the legendary illustrator Robert Crumb for a pen-and-ink drawing of “Juice Jar Jerry” and “Whistlin’ Willie.”

In 2017, when Mr. Weber was about to undergo knee surgery, he sold the business, with it a stock of about 500,000 records, to Minnesota native Chris Grauzer, who maintained the store name for its stellar reputation.

After recovering from the surgery and getting himself in leaner shape, Mr. Weber continued to sell records out of his Swissvale warehouse, where he had another half-million records and his own prized personal collection of about 20,000.

Advertise with us

Far from the stereotype of the snotty or arrogant record store owner, Mr. Weber was a true people person who loved to share stories and talk about music.

As one family member put it, “Jerry was the life of the party even if it wasn’t a party.”

Asked once about what drove him, he said, “Without a doubt, and I’m not making this up, making people happy, including myself, by finding people records. Rescuing records is the noblest thing you can do. If you’re driving home, if you see someone putting records out on the street, a box of records, take them home. Because you might not need them, but you can always give them to Goodwill or something. So many records get ruined and, honestly, that really bothers me.”

News of Mr. Weber’s death spread on social media Saturday, with friends and customers sharing stories.

Anthony Lamonde, of The Borstal Boys, related one that spoke volumes about Mr. Weber.

Advertise with us

“So sad to hear a friend and beautiful soul has left us,” he wrote. “Jerry always was a kind soul. Here’s just one story about him. My best friend [Tommy] Osh passed away and I helped his mother go through his things and we got all his albums together to take to Jerry. Now of course we took the good ones out that we wanted and brought the rest up. Jerry knew the money was for Patty so he gave me way more than they were worth and told me to tell Patty that he’s there for her if she needed anything.”

He is survived his son Willie Weber, daughter Johnna Weber-Clark and grandchildren Woodrow, Zach, Jade, Tyler and Sophia.

Funeral arrangements are pending.