In early summer 1998, the Allegheny Health Education and Research Foundation was sliding into what would become the nation’s biggest nonprofit health system failure. Even worse, the aggressive expansion of the health system at a time when insurers were slashing payments to hospitals had put the pensions of some 11,000 employees at risk.

Charles M. O’Brien Jr. saw opportunity in the pending bankruptcy. And a way to save the pensions.

Mr. O’Brien, then president and CEO of West Penn Hospital, and his executive team put together a bankruptcy court bid to combine West Penn and AHERF’s Allegheny General and four other hospitals into a new system. It worked.

In late summer 1998, the West Penn Allegheny Health System was launched, preserving competition and keeping any one provider from dominating the region’s health care market.

Advertise with us

West Penn Allegheny was acquired by health insurance giant Highmark in April 2013 and renamed the Allegheny Health Network, which has since grown to comprise 14 hospitals, 2,400 doctors and a workforce of 19,000 people.

And even though Mr. O’Brien’s team had the option of shedding the pension liabilities of former AHERF employees in bankruptcy court — an option that would’ve saved the new health system millions of dollars — he insisted on assuming the liability, said Jim Rosenberg, former West Penn chief operating officer and friend to Mr. O’Brien for 47 years.

“When that transaction was consummated, there was a lot of pressure to leave pensions out of it,” Mr. Rosenberg said. “And he did not ascribe to that. He didn’t think that was the right thing to do.”

Barbara McGinley O’Brien remembers her husband’s commitment to protecting the pensions rather than cutting them out of West Penn’s offer in bankruptcy court.

“He felt compelled that couldn’t happen” she said. “They were going to create a health care system. They weren’t going to let that happen.”

Advertise with us

Mr. O’Brien, 78, died unexpectedly due to a cardiac event on Jan. 6 at his home in Shadyside. Interment was private.

In addition to his wife, Mr. O’Brien is survived by daughters Emily O’Brien, of Los Angeles; and Maryellen Gibbons, of Asheville, N.C.; and son Duff O’Brien, of Mount Lebanon. He is also survived by stepsons Daniel McGinley, of Punxsutawney; Steven McGinley, of Greenfield; as well as stepdaughters Carolyn Evans, of Shaler; and Maureen Herbster, also of Shaler.

Mr. O’Brien was born on July 23, 1943 in Norman, Okla. After graduating from Norman High School, he attended Michigan State University, where a chance meeting with a hospital administrator on a train trip led to his career in hospital management. He earned an MBA at the University of Chicago and later in his career led turnarounds at Wheeling Hospital and Weirton Medical Center, both in West Virginia.

“A hospital is a microcosm of life,” Ms. McGinley O’Brien said. “Every socioeconomic level is in there every day, from the highest priced surgeons to people cleaning the rooms.

“He loved what he did,” she said. “He loved it.”

Advertise with us

Correction to Barbara McGinley O’Brien’s name at 10:16 a.m. Jan. 20.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699