Gustave Diamond had something that money couldn’t buy and power couldn’t corrupt.
The retired U.S. District Judge for the Western District of Pennsylvania earned the respect and admiration — and even love — of many who entered his courtroom, from staff members to litigants to lawyers.
“Judge Diamond represented the highest standard in the legal profession, and I admired him,” said David Hickton, former U.S. Attorney for the district. “I loved him to death. He was like a second father to me.”
Judge Diamond, who also served as the district’s top federal prosecutor before his appointment to the bench by President Jimmy Carter in 1978, died Oct. 30 of congestive heart failure at his Peters Township home. He was 93.
His impact on the federal judiciary was felt far and wide, colleagues and friends said.
“His best attribute was that he loved the law intellectually and had great respect for the rule of law,” said lawyer John Gismondi.
“I was his very first law clerk, from 1978 to 1981, and it was an extremely close working relationship,” Mr. Gismondi said. “He was a tremendous mentor and that turned into a lifelong relationship. As a judge, he was everything you could ever ask for -- his only agenda was to know the law and apply it correctly to whatever situation was in front of him. I have long said that he was the ultimate umpire, calling balls and strikes with no agenda.”
Judge Diamond also felt the gravity of his position — which he maintained as a senior judge until he was nearly 90 years old — said his grandson, Elias Diamond, of Peters.
“For my grandfather, his pursuit of the law was never something done for reasons as mundane as money or power,” his grandson said about his “papou” in a eulogy delivered Wednesday during his funeral service at Holy Cross Greek Orthodox Church in Mt. Lebanon. “It was something that for him was always tied to these higher virtues, these God-given transcendent virtues, like truth, and justice, and reason, and liberty.”
A native of Burgettstown, Judge Diamond was the son of a Greek immigrant who operated a diner in the small town.
“During summers, he worked picking coal off of conveyor belts and at a local grocery store,” said his wife Emma Scarton Yoney Diamond, who married Judge Diamond in 1972, after the death of his first wife, Athena.
Judge Diamond loved playing football and received a scholarship to Duke University, where he studied for a year, before enlisting in the Navy during the post-World War II rebuilding of Europe.
“When he joined the Navy, he said that was the turning point in his life,” his grandson said. “He learned to sit still and concentrate and he did better in school.”
After serving in the military, Judge Diamond returned to Duke, earning a degree in 1951.
He got a day job at an insurance company to pay for his studies at Duquesne University School of Law, where he graduated in 1956.
Judge Diamond was first drawn to the Federal judiciary through his clerkship for U.S. District Judge Rabe F. Marsh.
By 1961, he joined the U.S. Attorney’s office in the Western District of Pennsylvania.
Within two years, Judge Diamond was appointed U.S. Attorney for the Western District by President Lyndon Johnson.
In 1969, he left office to pursue a private practice until 1978, when he was tapped by Mr. Carter to return to District court, where he also served for a time as chief judge.
“I worked for him as a law clerk at the beginning of my career, and he had a tremendous positive influence over me,” said Mr. Hickton, who is now the director and founder of the University of Pittsburgh Institute for Cyber Law, Policy and Security. “It was very special being a clerk for Judge Diamond. He took the training of his law clerks very seriously. The lesson was always respect — for the law, for the process, the role that we played in the legal system — and the gift he gave us was his generosity. He went the extra mile with us professionally and personally.”
He was both revered and respected by his colleagues on the bench.
“I really loved that man. He was the best,” said Senior U.S. District Court Judge Donetta Ambrose. “He had a distinguished career and he was somebody who everybody else tried to model their conduct after. I know I certainly did. He was brilliant and passionate about his work, and I was so proud to work with him.”
“When I shared the news of Judge Diamond's passing ...there was just a wave of reply-all email messages with reminiscences of Judge Diamond. The most frequently used words were ‘kind’ and ‘kindness,’” said Chief U.S. District Judge Mark R. Hornak. “His life was instantly remembered for his genuine kindness to other people. Judge Diamond was a friend to all, and a special mentor to both new judges and especially to young lawyers, and his wit, gentle chuckle and genuine kindness were the partners of the mighty intellect and profound wisdom he brought to his official duties.”
Judge Diamond presided over a number of high-profile cases, but perhaps his most famous came in 1985, when a Philadelphia caterer was charged with selling drugs, including cocaine, to several Major League baseball players.
The spectacle drew national attention and became something of a media hoopla.
“This case is, hopefully, one in a lifetime,” Judge Diamond said in The Pittsburgh Press in September 1985, when he also predicted it would the most remembered case of his career.
“A lot of famous baseball players testified,” recalled federal law clerk Kristie Woffington. “He reserved half of the courtroom for the media and it was always full.”
The judge’s personal life also set a good example for his colleagues, said Judge Ambrose, recalling social events she and her husband attended over the years with Judge Diamond and his wife.
“We became good friends with him and Emma,” she said. “They were clearly devoted and in love with each other. They served as a model to my husband and I, and we used to talk about that after trips we took with them. It was our goal to be more like them.”
“He was an extraordinary judge, but he was an even better person and that, I think, is very uncommon today,” Ms. Woffington said. “I learned a lot from him, and on a personal level, he treated me like a family member. I think the world of him. He was the epitome of what a judge should be. He was the most intelligent person I ever met and he had extreme common sense.”
Along with the law, Judge Diamond had a passion for reading and other cerebral pursuits. The lessons his grandfather taught him never ended, his grandson said.
“He often told me that his favorite class at Duke University was his philosophy class,” his grandson said. “He introduced me to Plato, quoted Hamlet to me, and would often read passages from a thick book he loved, called the ‘Book of Virtues.’”
In 1994, Judge Diamond became a senior judge, a commitment he maintained until his retirement in 2017.
“I mean, most people want to retire as soon as possible,” his grandson said. “But, he wanted to keep working all the way up nearly to the end of his life. That is truly the mark of someone who had found their vocation, found the thing that God had called them to do.”
Along with his wife and grandson, Judge Diamond is survived by his daughter Margaret Ann Diamond, of Peters; and his brothers Nicholas, of Kyle, Texas, and Stanley, of Washington, Pa.
In addition to his first wife, he was preceded in death by his stepdaughter Jo Anne Yoney and his sister Helen Diamond.
Memorial donations may be made to Holy Cross Greek Orthodox Church: https://www.holycrosspgh.org/donate or Duquesne University School of Law: https://www.duq.edu.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.