Few things disturbed Judge Michael J. O’Malley as much as seeing frazzled mothers at the Allegheny County courthouse, trying to calm their frightened children and change diapers on the hallway floors.
He was determined to do something about it.
The creation of a children’s room in the 1980s, staffed by volunteers from the Jewish Federation Women’s League, was one of the many lasting courthouse improvements made by Judge O’Malley, who served as president judge in the county Court of Common Pleas for 11 years.
“He used to say, ‘I don’t want those little kids remembering what is was like coming to court,’ ” said his daughter, Susan O’Malley. “He wanted it to be a positive thing and he was intent on finding a place for a nursery. It meant a lot to him because he had kids.”
Judge O’Malley, 95, died in his sleep June 17 at the Scott home he shared with his daughter.
The son of immigrants from Galway, Ireland, Judge O’Malley grew up in Oakland and went to Central Catholic High School, where he graduated in 1941.
He enrolled at the University of Pittsburgh but left after the fall term to enlist in the U.S. Army Air Corps and join the World War II effort.
Hoping to serve as a pilot, Judge O’Malley earned his flying wings but was asked to re-train as a navigator, where qualified candidates were most needed.
A second lieutenant, Judge O’Malley served until 1946, taking part in numerous night bombing missions in the Pacific theater.
On the night of Aug. 6, 1945 — just hours before his 22nd birthday — Judge O’Malley’s B24 Liberator was returning from a routine overnight mission as the Enola Gay was setting out to drop the atomic bomb on Hiroshima.
“They were working nights so they lived opposite of everyone else,” his daughter said. “They were told the next day that the Enola Gay was in the air when they were coming back.”
After the Japanese surrender, Judge O’Malley was reassigned to cargo planes. He was awarded five Battle Stars for his service.
During a visit home on leave from his training, Judge O’Malley met Mary Alice Dempsey at a dinner with family and friends.
They began dating, but he was concerned about what would happen once he shipped out, his daughter said.
He secured her affection in a way only her father could, Ms. O’Malley said.
“He sent two dozen yellow roses — not to her — but to her mother, with a note that said ‘Thank you for having such a wonderful daughter,’ ” she said, laughing. “He was so slick.”
The couple were married in September 1947, and Mrs. O’Malley died last year.
After the war, Judge O’Malley resumed his education, earning a bachelor’s degree in 1948 in transportation from Pitt.
He went to work for several years as a traffic manager at H.J. Heinz before enrolling in Pitt law school, where he graduated in 1954.
Judge O’Malley worked in private practice for many years and became an expert in property law and eminent domain, serving as a special assistant attorney general in the early 1960s and as chairman of the county Board of Viewers for several years.
He was appointed to the bench in 1972 by then-Gov. Milton Shapp and quickly won over his colleagues with his low-key but personable approach to the job.
The following year, he secured the top slot on the Democratic slate and easily won election to a full, 10-year term.
In 1977, his peers chose him as president judge. His ascension as top jurist was the first election in a process that had long been decided by seniority.
His term as president judge was fruitful, but had its share of controversies, like the time he had to mediate a dispute over a parody purported to be written by one judge about another.
Judge O’Malley also found himself snared at times in the middle of political jockeying between state and county government over funding for the courts, including in 1985, when he threatened to close the courts down unless funding was restored.
Judge O’Malley was drawn into the dispute when then-county commissioners provoked a standoff with the state by agreeing to fund just $6 million for the system, which required $24 million per year to operate.
“I became a county commissioner in 1980, shortly after he became president judge and I had a lot of dealings with him,” said longtime friend Cyril Wecht, a renowned forensic pathologist. “I always found him to be fair and patient, and never arrogant.”
“He was a good administrator,” said his friend of more than 50 years, Judge Michael Della Vecchia of the county court’s Civil Division. “He was my closest friend in public life.”
Judge O’Malley continued serving, including as a senior judge, until his retirement in 2003.
But retirement didn’t last long, his daughter said, and before long, her father found himself pulled once again into the fray to help quell a conflict among judges in Lawrence County, where he was appointed as administrative judge.
His calm, easygoing manner was always a balm when it was needed most, friends and colleagues said.
“I really thought the world of him,” Judge Della Vecchia said. “There’s an old expression — firm but fair. That’s pretty much him. When he was in the courtroom, there was no question who the judge was.”
“He had a great sense of humor -- he was just so relaxed and comfortable to talk to, and at the same time you appreciated his legal acumen and judicial temperament,” Dr. Wecht said. “I think he was one of the most respected and admired judges that I recall dealing with in all those years.”
Her father, who later in life served as president of the board at the Philip Chosky Charitable Educational Foundation, was a character who never forgot his roots and remained thankful for everything in his life, Ms. O’Malley said.
“He loved to recite poetry, tell jokes, discuss politics and give advice,” she said. “He taught me something every day.”
Along with his daughter, Judge O’Malley is also survived by his son, J. Michael O’Malley, of Scott. He was preceded in death by his children Maureen, Joy and Michael Joseph O’Malley; his sisters Mary Anfang, Geraldine Fichter, Theresa "Teady" Johns, Eileen O’Malley; and his brother, Bart O’Malley.
His funeral was June 22.
Memorial contributions may be made to Central Catholic High School: https://www.centralcatholichs.com/pages/ways-to-give.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.