If the family court system in Allegheny County had been a for-profit venture, Judge Lawrence W. Kaplan would surely have put it out of business.
That’s because the 30-year veteran jurist in the county Common Pleas Court Family Division lived by the mantra of “mediation, not litigation.”
“There’s no question at all, he was the father of mediation in Allegheny County and probably in Pennsylvania as well,” said state Superior Court Senior Judge Eugene Strassburger, Judge Kaplan’s longtime friend and colleague. “It’s required in Allegheny County now and probably in most other places in Pennsylvania, and he was absolutely the reason for that.”
Judge Kaplan, 90, died at his Oakland home Monday from complications of melanoma.
A 1946 graduate of Uniontown Senior High School, Judge Kaplan earned a bachelor’s degree in English from the University of Pennsylvania in 1950. He served as a case editor of the law review at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law, graduating in 1953.
When he was pursuing his law degree, Judge Kaplan met fellow students Natalie Adler and her brother Larry.
“I actually knew him first,” said Larry Adler, a Shadyside cardiologist who met Judge Kaplan when they joined the same fraternity. “He and Natalie met on an elevator in the Cathedral of Learning. And as soon as he met her, he said, ‘That’s the woman I’m going to marry.’”
The couple did just that, in November 1952.
After school, Judge Kaplan enlisted in the Army and served as first lieutenant in the office of the Judge Advocate General for three years.
By 1957, Judge Kaplan had begun working as a trust officer at the former Western Pennsylvania National Bank before joining the private law practice of Kaufman & Harris, where he was a partner for 22 years.
In 1978, Judge Kaplan was appointed by then-Gov. Milton Shapp to fill a vacancy on the county Common Pleas Court. He was elected to a full, 10-year term in 1979 and served on the bench until 2008, when he reached the mandatory retirement age of 80.
For many years, it was proforma for new judges to gain experience in the trenches of Family Court, where the days were often long and the work, at times, heartbreaking.
Many saw it as a brief stopover on their way to more exciting assignments, said Judge Strassburger, who served alongside Judge Kaplan in Family Court for 15 years.
“Most of them wanted to get out as soon as possible,” he said. “But Larry changed that pattern and now a number of judges have followed in his footsteps.”
Daniel Butler, who served as his first law clerk in 1978, said Judge Kaplan honored his campaign slogan: “A family man for family court.”
“There are very few people who you meet who live up their billing or the principles they espouse,” said Judge Butler, now a district judge in Squirrel Hill and Shadyside. “He lived up to that.”
Not all judges shared his views about mediation, Judge Strassburger said.
“I was quite skeptical of it at first, but he pursued it and history has proven him correct,” Judge Strassburger said. “There is no doubt at all that what he did created a new standard view of the custody case as something that should be settled and not fought about.”
Judge Kaplan, who founded the Mediation Council of Western Pennsylvania, explained his philosophy in a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette story during the early years of his career.
“Just because somebody’s wearing a black robe doesn’t mean he knows more about a family’s problems.” he said in a July 1981 article.
And Judge Kaplan never lost sight of who he was, friends said.
“He was the same person off the bench as on the bench,” District Judge Butler said. “And that’s so unusual for someone who is a judge for a long time. He never let it get to his head, he had none of the arrogance that is such a frequent effect of ‘black-robe disease.’”
For example, Judge Kaplan sued the county commissioners and his then-boss President Judge Michael O’Malley in 1985 for implementing a policy that forced his 71-year-old tipstaff to retire due to his age.
Employee Austin Lacy continued working for the judge without pay until they won the lawsuit and he was reinstated with back pay.
“That whole situation is indicative of who our father was,” said Judge Kaplan’s son, Thomas Kaplan, of Delray Beach, Fla. “He always wanted to do the right thing.”
The judge was recognized with numerous awards and was also honored by the county Bar Association in 2004 with the establishment of the annual Lawrence W. Kaplan Lecture in Conflict Resolution.
To his children, Judge Kaplan was the ultimate fun dad who jogged every morning with his daughter for many years and passed on his love of music and humor.
“He was quite the punster. He really had an amazing sense of humor,” remembered his daughter, Ellen Teri Kaplan Goldstein of Point Breeze.
“My dad was the musical influence in our lives,” said his son, Jon Adler Kaplan, of Baltimore. “My dad and I took tap dance lessons together. He was just so much fun.”
After retirement, Judge Kaplan accepted a position specializing in dispute resolution with the firm of Rothman Gordon.
Partner Louis Kushner said he would remember Judge Kaplan for his legendary sense of humor and his contributions to the legal field.
“He was very funny and he cared a lot about people,” Mr. Kushner said. “He made an indelible imprint on the judicial system.”
Judge Strassburger agreed.
“He was really funny. He was bald and referred to himself at times as the bald eagle,” he said, laughing. “It was a pleasure to serve with him and pleasure to just be with him. He will really be missed.”
Along with his wife and children, Judge Kaplan is survived by three grandchildren. He was preceded in death by a brother, David Kaplan.
Visitation is at 9:30 a.m. Friday at Rodef Shalom Temple, 4905 Fifth Ave. at Morewood, in Oakland, followed by the funeral at 11 a.m. Interment will be at West View Cemetery of Rodef Shalom congregation.
Memorial contributions are suggested to the Carriage House Children’s Center Scholarship Fund, 5604 Solway St., Pittsburgh, Pa. 15217; UJF, 2000 Technology Drive, Pittsburgh, Pa. 15219; Rodef Shalom Temple, 4905 Fifth Ave., Pittsburgh, Pa. 15213; or Alpha House, 435 Shady Ave., Pittsburgh, Pa. 15206.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.