For more than 30 years, Ann Sunseri was a familiar face at her sons’ Italian food market and wholesale business in the Strip District. A cashier when Nino and Jimmy started their namesake store in 1985, she eventually did everything from manage the books to act as general secretary for the Penn Avenue institution.

Yet what she loved more than anything was talking with shoppers about matters that didn’t necessarily have anything to do with food. In addition to telling stories of years past, she was famous for the “pencil test” she did on expecting female patrons to predict the gender of their unborn babies. She also lent a sympathetic ear to customers’ problems.

She was so famous for doling out sage advice, said her son Gus of Fox Chapel, that any time she was in the  building, staff would joke, “The doctor is in.”

“People would come in and climb the stairs to see her,” he said of the woman affectionately known as “Big Ann.”

Advertise with us

Mrs. Sunseri died last Dec. 10 from lung cancer. She was 86 and in hospice.

The oldest of five children, Ann Mary Graham was raised in East Liberty. Her father, Howard, was a dispatcher for the Port Authority, and her mother, Mary, worked as a hostess for Contis Restaurant on Penn Avenue.

Athletic and outgoing, she loved to ice-skate as a girl and also delighted in dancing, said her son Nino of Monroeville. It was on the dance floor in a hall above the Original Hot Dog Shop in Oakland that she met the man who would become her husband. She was only 18. But she liked the way that Anthony Sunseri moved to music, and she could tell that the Millvale native who had left school at age 12 to help his widowed mother run Pennsylvania Macaroni in the Strip District was kind.

“She knew my dad’s eyes were eyes of love,” Nino said.

They were married by the time she turned 20, and in 1953 they moved from their home on Larimer Avenue in East Liberty — known at the time as Pittsburgh’s Little Italy — to Greenfield, where they raised four sons and a daughter.

Advertise with us

It wasn’t easy for someone of Irish ancestry to assimilate into an Italian family, but Mrs. Sunseri’s sweet and gregarious personality won people over. And she immediately conformed to be one of the best Italian cooks, Nino said, learning to make everything from pasta to stuffed artichokes to beef braciole at a moment’s notice.

Many of those meals were akin to the miracles of the loaves and fishes of their Roman Catholic faith. Two of her sons played football in high school and college, and they often brought home hungry teammates for an impromptu meal. She always managed to send them home well-fed.

“She went to Giant Eagle every day,” Gus said with a laugh, often buying 40 pork chops or steaks at a time.

Not that she relegated herself to the kitchen. After whipping up one of her legendary meals, she would sit around the supper table to talk with football players who included Rickey Jackson, Terry Totten and Dan Marino.

“Everybody who came through our front door immediately became part of the family,” Nino said. “They left with their bellies full and feeling good about themselves.”

Advertise with us

Comical and a bit devilish at times, Mrs. Sunseri often teased her family and friends. But she wasn’t afraid to be stern when she needed to get something done, and she didn’t hesitate to tell you when you were wrong, “whether or not your last name was Sunseri,” Gus said.

She wasn’t just a mom to five, Gus said.

“She was a second mom to hundreds of others, and the empathy and sympathy she displayed made them all feel so special,” he said.

Mrs. Sunseri’s greatest love was her husband. Even after 66 years of marriage, they still held hands, and until his death in 2017 from heart issues, they supported each other and their children unconditionally. She also doted on her 39 grandchildren and great-grandchildren.

In addition to her sons Jimmy of Highland Park, Gus and Nino, she is survived by another son, Sal of San Francisco; a daughter, Linda Wright of Fox Chapel; 18 grandchildren; and 21 great-grandchildren.

Advertise with us

A Mass will be celebrated at 10 a.m. Monday at St. Stanislaus Church, 21st and Smallman streets, in the Strip District. Interment will be private.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.